Processed Issues50

This page shows a list of issues for afr.com that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Issue #1
Jun 3, 2017
This page, though given as an example one, fails to satisfy article 2.4 of criteria "Pages that are only accessible to logged in users, etc.".
If you type the address of the page in the browser, the page will be shown briefly, but in a few seconds it will be hidden, with this disclaimer "You have reached an article available exclusively to subscribers."
☄️
As you can see it's displayed fine. And it works in the browser too, if you use an adblocker.
Declined by admin
If essential content is unable to be displayed, then an IV should not be generated.

If all essential content can be displayed, then an IV should be generated.
Template #1 Issue #2
Jun 12, 2017
Author is missing
Declined by admin
It is not an author, rather a source, and source references are optional: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-7-source-links
Template #2 Issue #1
Jun 12, 2017
Incorrect author name.
You've assigned a source to it, thought the actual author is clearly specified at the top of the article.
Accepted by admin
Reporter's template handles this case better: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/afr.com/template3/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.afr.com%2Fbusiness%2Fenergy%2Felectricity%2Falan-finkel-could-have-learned-from-adam-smith-20170608-gwnjbe
Template #3 Issue #1
Jun 19, 2017
There are two more authors, that should be shown.
Accepted by admin
Template #5 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Hour is an error. In page is 11.00 pm and in IV is 13.00
Declined by admin
Template #5 Issue #3
Feb 7, 2019
All headers are missing (highlighted the first one and where it must be)
Accepted by admin
Template #6 Issue #1
Feb 7, 2019
No author link
Dzmitry Radkevich
Author links are optional.
Declined by admin
Template #6 Issue #2
Feb 8, 2019
Rudimentary links
Accepted by admin
Template #6 Issue #3
Feb 8, 2019
This is image of author, its strange to use it as cover of all article
Accepted by admin
Template #9 Issue #1
Feb 8, 2019
In original this block is aside, but author make it as header. Author of this article mai do its as aside in purpose.
Odwalla
"Related quotes" looks like a subheader and not an aside and it's used all over the site as a subheader.
So I took the freedom to make it look as a subheader, it doesn't worsen reading experience and looks as the one in the original page.
Declined by admin
Template #6 Issue #4
Feb 8, 2019
Advertisment sign is there
Accepted by admin
Template #6 Issue #5
Feb 9, 2019
Accepted by admin
Template #12 Issue #1
Feb 10, 2019
There are 3 authors, but 1 link for all. I think it's better without link, than mislead readers.
Accepted by admin
Template #9 Issue #2
Feb 10, 2019
Hi!
author's pic is missing
bottom of the page cleared of excess
please, chek template #14
Accepted by admin
Template #14 Issue #1
Feb 10, 2019
This is a picture of an author, therefore it's can't be a cover of all article.
Dzmitry Radkevich
This chicken looks great on the cover!
Accepted by admin
Template #16 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
Generated with error.
Odwalla
Behind the frontend paywall there is an unsupported dynamic video, here a screenshot https://i.postimg.cc/BnC59DrD/tmp.png
Declined by admin
Template #16 Issue #2
Feb 13, 2019
Not generated for target pade. If this video not supported, they can be removed. There's many text beside this video.
Odwalla
Duplicate of https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/afr.com/template16/issue1/
Declined by admin
Duplicated issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/afr.com/template16/issue1/
Template #16 Issue #3
Feb 14, 2019
author link is missing
Odwalla
Author link is optional. I opted for this solution because often this site has many authors and using only one author link for three authors is wrong
Declined by admin
Author links are optional.
Template #16 Issue #4
Feb 14, 2019
related articles is missing
Odwalla
"Most Viewed In business" is a dynamic and unrelated list of articles, so it's not necessary
Declined by admin
Template #16 Issue #5
Feb 14, 2019
kicker is missing
Odwalla
This is not a kicker, Wikipedia says "A short, catchy word or phrase over a major headline", sadly this is not the case
Declined by admin
Template #17 Issue #1
Feb 14, 2019
kicker is missing
Declined by admin
No need to add the category as a kicker: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-5-kicker
Template #16 Issue #6
Feb 15, 2019
Rudimentary content in the author property
Accepted by admin
Template #17 Issue #2
Feb 15, 2019
Rudimentary content not removed or missing content
Accepted by admin
Template #18 Issue #1
Feb 15, 2019
Rudimentary not removed content or missing content
Accepted by admin
Template #19 Issue #1
Feb 18, 2019
missing iv
Odwalla
Not generated because the page contains iframe dynamicaly added, in this template the iframe is inside <div id="nextwave">
Declined by admin
Template #19 Issue #2
Feb 18, 2019
Accepted by admin
Template #22 Issue #1
Feb 18, 2019
6.3.2 Related articles
It is obligatory to format “Related articles” links using the new <related> tag, provided they are identifiable in the source. Related Articles:

Are thematically related to the current article.
valid
Please read further:
Other types of “More” links that are not suitable for the “Related articles” block should be removed, provided this is technically possible without endangering essential content. Examples:
- Dynamic lists of “Latest articles from this category”.
- Lists of categories (links to dynamic lists).

Related articles should be used when there're concrete articles set as related to the current one. This plugin just shows you the latest articles that has something to do with IMF Bentham Limited, so it's exactly a dynamic list of “Latest articles from this category”. For example the 2th article is about a general topic, but it mentions IMF Bentham once as an example, so it appears as a related article to this one. Please see the list where the "see all" link takes you, the latest two are showed here: https://www.afr.com/companies/imf-bentham-limited-imf-997010040
I see that there aren't too many articles about concretely this company, so it could be considered relatively static, but generally you c
Declined by admin
Template #26 Issue #1
Feb 18, 2019
missing IV
Odwalla
Indeed you are generating a page with unsupported content, here the screen https://i.postimg.cc/k5QBN2jx/tmp.png
Declined by admin
Template #26 Issue #2
Feb 18, 2019
6.3.2 Related articles
It is obligatory to format “Related articles” links using the new <related> tag, provided they are identifiable in the source. Related Articles:

Are thematically related to the current article.
Odwalla
"provided they are identifiable" all attributes in this site are random garbage (eg. class="_3xv7C", class="_2xMD5"...), they often vary and aren't consistent between pages.
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #2
Feb 18, 2019
Finishing my comment at the other issue, it got cut:
[...] but generally you can't include dynamic lists.
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #3
Feb 18, 2019
There is an unsuppoted iframe, here the screen https://i.postimg.cc/k5QBN2jx/tmp.png
valid
Maybe in the full version of the page, which you have to pay for. In the noscript version, which is accessable without paying and can generate IV, there's only text and images. Scroll down, everything is presented.
Accepted by admin
This page is free for me by default. There's unsupported widget before "Annoyingly nice" header. See: https://telegra.ph/file/813a44b884ec86cbfd34a.png
Template #26 Issue #3
Feb 19, 2019
missing IV
Odwalla
Duplicate of https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/afr.com/template26/issue1/
"Indeed you are generating a page with unsupported content, here the screen https://i.postimg.cc/k5QBN2jx/tmp.png"
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #4
Feb 19, 2019
these social media links can be easily identified and should be removed

4. Content to Be Removed
Social media links and buttons removed, including “Share” and “Like” links and buttons
valid
6.3.6 Social media links
Many articles include something like “check out our facebook page” at the end of every text. Such links must be removed if they are consistently placed in an identifiable container.

They are removed when they're in their consistent, reliable identifyable form - placed at the end formatted as bold and italic. Example: https://www.afr.com/brand/afr-magazine/five-luxury-cars-that-tell-the-future-of-motoring-20181212-h190m6

In this page they're in the body as simple paragraphs, without any formatting, so they aren't. It's a specific case, not the template's issue.
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #5
Feb 19, 2019
I'd like to add some more comment to issue https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/afr.com/template22/issue1/

that "MORE ON" section underneath "Related Quotes" is related articles about the same subject of financial report. This section is common in afr financial reviews. eg:
https://www.afr.com/street-talk/time-for-one-more-bust-up-myob-kkr-20181220-h19bbf

Thus, this section should be mark <related>
valid
It's still a dynamic list. Please see my comment: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/afr.com/template22/issue1/
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #6
Feb 19, 2019
missing iv
valid
6.4.2 Video/Audio from unsupported players
If it is not possible to represent the widget as an iFrame, but it is possible to get a direct link to the video/audio, use this link to generate a <video> or <audio> with the correct src attribute.
Otherwise, mark the object with the @unsupported function.

It's not possible to get the video source, so it's marked with unsupported, how it should be.
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #7
Feb 19, 2019
6.3.2 Related articles
It is obligatory to format “Related articles” links using the new <related> tag, provided they are identifiable in the source. Related Articles:

Are thematically related to the current article.
valid
Please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/afr.com/template22/issue1/
Declined by admin
Template #26 Issue #4
Feb 19, 2019
Must be in the <related> tag
Declined by admin
Template #26 Issue #5
Feb 19, 2019
IV should be generated
Odwalla
There is still an unsupported iframe, link is https://data.afr.com/2016/09sep/stevens-housing-hype/index.html
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #8
Feb 19, 2019
Must be in the <related> tag
valid
It's not consistently presented like this, just specificly in this page. It's not reliably identifiable being plain paragraphs in the body
Declined by admin
Template #27 Issue #1
Feb 19, 2019
Must be in the <related> tag
Declined by admin
Can't be identified. It's acceptable to leave it as it is
Template #27 Issue #2
Feb 19, 2019
link to dynamic page must be removed and this link is not related article
Declined by admin
Template #27 Issue #3
Feb 19, 2019
There is an unsuppoted iframe, here the screen https://i.postimg.cc/k5QBN2jx/tmp.png
Accepted by admin
Unsupported widget is before "Annoyingly nice" header in the original article
Template #29 Issue #1
Feb 21, 2019
A daily journal on a special topic should have IV
Odwalla
A very special page indeed, it's updated dynamically!
Declined by admin
This page is rather not a target page because of the chart widget & the dynamically updated content comparable to a live ticker.

https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/afr.com/template28/issue1/
Template #28 Issue #1
Feb 21, 2019
A daily journal on a special topic should have IV
abror_khurramov
A very special page indeed, it's updated dynamically!
Declined by admin
This page is rather not a target page because of the chart widget & the dynamically updated content comparable to a live ticker.
Template #28 Issue #2
Feb 21, 2019
A daily journal on a special topic should have IV
abror_khurramov
A very special page indeed, it's updated dynamically!
Declined by admin
Duplicate of https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/afr.com/template28/issue1/
Template #29 Issue #2
Feb 21, 2019
A daily journal on a special topic should have IV
Odwalla
Duplicate of https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/afr.com/template29/issue1/
Declined by admin
Duplicate. It even says "live" in the url.
Template #28 Issue #3
Feb 21, 2019
Image quality should be improved
abror_khurramov
Itʼs purely optional
Accepted by admin
Template #29 Issue #3
Feb 21, 2019
Missing site name

3.2. Link preview
The site_name property must include the correct name of the website.
Odwalla
For page that generate something, this page have no IV
Declined by admin
Template #29 Issue #4
Feb 21, 2019
6.3.6 Social media links
Many articles include something like “check out our facebook page” at the end of every text. Such links must be removed if they are consistently placed in an identifiable container.

It's placed in the same format at every articles end in this category, easily identifiable, should be removed.
Odwalla
How are you identifying them? There is no class nor id, they are in an anonymous paragraph
Declined by admin
Just normal text in a simple paragraph
Template #35 Issue #1
Feb 21, 2019
6.3.6 Social media links
Many articles include something like “check out our facebook page” at the end of every text. Such links must be removed if they are consistently placed in an identifiable container.

It's placed in the same format at every articles end in this category, easily identifiable, should be removed.
Declined by admin
These texts are not placed inside an "identifiable container", hence removing them is optional.

See also: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/afr.com/template29/issue4