Processed Issues41

This page shows a list of issues for bravo.de that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Issue #1
May 20, 2017
Advertisements
Accepted by admin
Template #2 Issue #1
May 23, 2017
Images and media captions that exists in the source must be shown in IV page
Accepted by admin
Template #3 Issue #1
May 23, 2017
Author is missing
Declined by admin
Template #4 Issue #1
May 24, 2017
Anything that is not essential to the article should be removed from the Instant View page.
Accepted by admin
Template #5 Issue #1
May 24, 2017
Article has a Cover image, this should be at the top of the page
Aleksandr
According clarifications it is optional in this case. Also at that site there are bunch of articles with single image and no significant text
Declined by admin
The cover image is optional in this case.
Template #7 Issue #1
May 24, 2017
Anything that is not essential to the article should be removed.
Chris
A Page about EPaper should contain information about the EPaper
Accepted by admin
The rudimentary content should either be removed, or links to the stores, etc. should be included so that users can access the ePaper somehow.

The "heading" where to download something is pretty useless when you aren't able to download it in the end.
Template #7 Issue #2
May 26, 2017
Any captions present in the source article must be preserved.
Chris
Cover Picture can't have a Caption, however, a Cover should be present if present
Accepted by admin
Cover pictures *can* and *should* have captions if present in the source!
Template #8 Issue #1
May 30, 2017
This should be a cover
Aleksandr
According to clarifications its kinda optional
Declined by admin
It is optional to add a cover in this case: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-cover-images
Template #8 Issue #2
Jun 7, 2017
Missing video
Aleksandr
Its all about how IV bot parsing an original page. For example after parsing there is no video tag on the left side iframe. Also content differ in the editor mode and current mode. So there is no way to support that kind of issues.
Accepted by admin
The original article contains unsupported embedded video:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-8-2-videos-from-unsupported-players
Template #9 Issue #1
Jun 7, 2017
Missing video
Accepted by admin
Template #11 Issue #1
Jun 8, 2017
Pages with static article-like content should be generated
Chris
In case the Content cannot be created or otherwise be linked to (as it is the case with the videos here), the page should not be generated
Declined by admin
Issues regarding articles with unsupported content may be considered if they include a link to a template that handles the disputed content well (including videos).
Template #11 Issue #2
Jun 13, 2017
Page with unsupported video must not be generated
Chris
There is no Video here as far as I can see
At the bottom there is one, but it's not related to the article in any way, it might be no advertisment, but it's a kind of 'read more'; a video thats recommended for the article
I've ruled this area out from the start as this bottom content doesn't relate to the rest of the article
Accepted by admin
There is a video at the bottom of the page. It should either be displayed or marked as unsupported if it can't be displayed in IV.

You can find the full rules here: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-8-2-videos-from-unsupported-players

While you are right that the content is more of a "related" video, it could also be important content - check this url for example:
http://www.bravo.de/jessica-paszka-alle-infos-zur-bachelorette-2017-376297.html
Template #15 Issue #1
Jun 16, 2017
Figcaption (source) partly missing
Accepted by admin
Template #16 Issue #1
Jun 17, 2017
Everything not essential to the article should be removed
Accepted by admin
Template #16 Issue #2
Jun 17, 2017
Missing important dates for the article story
Declined by admin
Template #16 Issue #3
Jun 17, 2017
That messy external links deteriorate UX and should be removed.
Accepted by admin
Template #18 Issue #1
Jun 18, 2017
This Page contains a submit form, the rules state that pages containing them must not be generated
Accepted by admin
This page must not generate an IV in accordance to 2.2 of Perfect Template Checklist: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-2-pages-that-require-significant-interaction
Template #19 Issue #1
Jun 18, 2017
Missing significant part of an article
Accepted by admin
Template #21 Issue #1
Jun 18, 2017
This page is a static article without special elements, it should have IV
Aleksandr
My template was supporting that area well. But as you can see in clarifications:

"While it's possible to modify interactive components of a page into simple links, the IV format was primarily designed to allow Telegram users to enjoy web content in a quick and uniform way."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-2-pages-that-require-significant-interaction

This page require that interaction because this is gallery-like page where it require clicking to the next or previous slide buttons (interactive components) and require to generate new page every time you click it.
Declined by admin
Template #21 Issue #2
Jun 18, 2017
The page isn't complete, the last offer is missing
Accepted by admin
Paragraphs are missing.
Template #22 Issue #1
Jun 18, 2017
"While it's possible to modify interactive components of a page into simple links, the IV format was primarily designed to allow Telegram users to enjoy web content in a quick and uniform way."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-2-pages-that-require-significant-interaction

This page require that interaction because this is gallery-like page where it require clicking to the next or previous slide buttons (interactive components) and require to generate new page every time you click it.
Chris
The page is a simple site, with text, image etc.
there are no widgets involved, the 'interactive part' is simply a navigation containing up to 5 links.
This representation of the seite with IV neither takes any option away nor is it overloaded with links or more complex structures.
All in all, this should be more enjoyable than the original site, as it is ad-free and minimalistic
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #2
Jun 18, 2017
"zusammengefasst" link have been removed
Declined by admin
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-6-read-also-read-more-more-on-this-topic-links
Template #22 Issue #3
Jun 18, 2017
These links where converted into plane text what deny access. What isn't advisable. You should either remove it or put at the bottom as a links.
Accepted by admin
Template #22 Issue #4
Jun 18, 2017
The same slideshow-like page which shouldn't be generated. Additionally to the previous issue there is no any content.

Here the page of the same type (http://www.bravo.de/fuer-deine-beste-freundin-tolle-weihnachtsgeschenke-unter-20-euro-173745.html)
but that is a store area which also shouldn't be generated according the rules.
Declined by admin
Template #23 Issue #1
Jun 18, 2017
This page should still be generated, it is simple enough and has no interaction exept the switching of the page (I personally would define interaction as some kind of wicked javascript or something)
Aleksandr
Duplicate non valid issue. My answers and position about that here:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/bravo.de/template21/issue1/
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/bravo.de/template22/issue4/
Declined by admin
Template #23 Issue #2
Jun 18, 2017
One story is Missing, this is essentially the whole reason for the article and therefore obligatory
Aleksandr
That links could be classified as further reading links and are optional. It can be removed or placed at the bottom of an article.

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-6-read-also-read-more-more-on-this-topic-links
Declined by admin
The link is optional.
Template #23 Issue #3
Jun 18, 2017
The reason for this page is to give an introduction to the gallery thats solely accessible through this link
This should make the link obligatory
Aleksandr
That link could be classified as further reading link and is optional. It can be removed or placed at the bottom of an article.

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-6-read-also-read-more-more-on-this-topic-links

Also that link leads to the page which shouldn't be supported (slideshow-like page).
Declined by admin
The link is optional.
Template #23 Issue #4
Jun 18, 2017
This paragraph isn't complete
Accepted by admin
Some parts of the text are missing.
Template #24 Issue #1
Jun 18, 2017
"While it's possible to modify interactive components of a page into simple links, the IV format was primarily designed to allow Telegram users to enjoy web content in a quick and uniform way."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-2-pages-that-require-significant-interaction

This page require that interaction because this is gallery-like page where it require clicking to the next or previous slide buttons (interactive components) and require to generate new page every time you click it.


bravo.de/was-wuenschen-sich-jungs-zu-weihnachten-175511.html
The same slideshow-like page which shouldn't be generated. Additionally to the previous issue there is no any content.

Here the page of the same type (http://www.bravo.de/fuer-deine-beste-freundin-tolle-weihnachtsgeschenke-unter-20-euro-173745.html)
but that is a store area which also shouldn't be generated according the rules.
Chris
To answer to this in it's entirety:
The Page is simply an article (as seen in it's meta description). It is static and easily accessible and readable in html, it's not necessary to take it out of the IV. The 'interactive component' is simply a set of links for navigation, this is not what i understand under the term interactive (otherwise, no wikipedia article with a single link out of the site would fit the description). The generation of pages is not part of the debate and it's not presented that we should optimize the number of sites generated. On the other hand, a such generated site is quicker, simpler and free of ads for the user.

The missing text doesn't btw mean that the site shouldn't be generated, as pages without text should not solely consist of slideshows (Checklist 6.4), this means it is still accepted that a page consists of media only without any text.

Lastly, this has nothing to do with the rules, this is still a gallery or article, not generating a store site relates simply to the act of o
Declined by admin
Template #24 Issue #2
Jun 18, 2017
Not essential to the article content should be removed
Accepted by admin
Template #24 Issue #3
Jun 18, 2017
This text is pointing to the links which should be also removed all together
Accepted by admin
Template #25 Issue #1
Jun 18, 2017
This page should have an IV
Aleksandr
This page require significant interaction. There is a poll on a page and that is why page shouldn't be generated.
Declined by admin
Template #26 Issue #1
Jun 18, 2017
Missing content
Accepted by admin
Template #26 Issue #2
Jun 18, 2017
Ordinary static article page must be generated
Accepted by admin
Template #26 Issue #3
Jun 18, 2017
service area of a website
Declined by admin
It's optional.
Template #26 Issue #4
Jun 18, 2017
This page require significant interaction. There is a poll on a page and that is why page shouldn't be generated.
Accepted by admin
Template #26 Issue #5
Jun 18, 2017
There is different type of poll. This page require significant interaction.
Declined by admin
A duplicated issue.
Template #26 Issue #6
Jun 18, 2017
There is different type of poll. This page require significant interaction.
Accepted by admin
Template #26 Issue #7
Jun 18, 2017
Media captions must be shown on IV page, aligned under their corresponding media if captions exist in the source.
Accepted by admin
Template #26 Issue #8
Jun 18, 2017
Static page can be generated withot missing any content
Accepted by admin
Template #25 Issue #2
Oct 14, 2017
'Abstimmen' is from voting form button (in the bottom of article) that doesn't displayed on page.

'Anzeige' is from sidebar (adverticement header, code of element is <div class="contentMarker icon teaserAd">Anzeige</div>).

This two elements should be removed.
Accepted by admin