Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues41

This page shows a list of issues for dailyhodl.com that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Felipe V	Issue #1 Feb 5, 2019	Samuel The blank line at the beginning of every first paragraph should be removed. Accepted by admin Not necessarily that the blank line at start should be removed, but more the parsing of paragraphs in general.
Template #3 chuchu	Issue #1 Feb 5, 2019	Samuel "Join" Link does not work for me. Declined by admin The channel link seems correct and matches what the source website lists.
Template #3 chuchu	Issue #2 Feb 5, 2019	Samuel The disclaimer could be important, maybe consider to add it here as well. chuchu Well, it's not essential content. But I wanted to preserve it Declined by admin The disclaimer does not seem to be essential content, so it could be optional (rather than required).
Template #3 chuchu	Issue #3 Feb 5, 2019	Samuel Consider adding the author-link. Declined by admin Author links are optional.
Template #4 Samuel	Issue #1 Feb 5, 2019	Grigory Korepanov Pullquote 3.3. Supported elements Pullquotes must be horizontally centered on IV page if pull quotes exist in the source Samuel This is sadly not a quote in the source and therefore not identifiable (believe me, I checked everything). It's an h4 and text in general is poorly tagged on dailyhodl.com because every author uses their own preferences for formatting text by abusing html-elements. This is the reason I left it this way. Declined by admin Kindly submit a link to the template that handles this case better
Template #4 Samuel	Issue #2 Feb 5, 2019	Grigory Korepanov Missed images It is not cover pullquote Accepted by admin
Template #5 chuchu	Issue #1 Feb 5, 2019	Samuel Love your template! "6.2.1 Image quality" of the docs states to not use images below 320px. I think this right here is not a suitable cover image (maybe use the one below). Accepted by admin
Template #6 chuchu	Issue #1 Feb 6, 2019	Simon seems to be an ad and should be removed. correct me if i'm wrong Accepted by admin
Template #6 chuchu	Issue #2 Feb 6, 2019	Simon video is missing Accepted by admin
Template #6 chuchu	Issue #3 Feb 6, 2019	Azyhan missing tag Declined by admin The category tag is not essential content.
Template #10 Amin	Issue #1 Feb 7, 2019	Kirill S The most part of the text in the paragraph is missing Accepted by admin
Template #12 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 7, 2019	Kirill S Missing the event's date and place Andrew Oh, you're right. Sorry for my issue then. Accepted by admin
Template #15 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 7, 2019	Kirill S IV is not generated Accepted by admin
Template #18 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 7, 2019	Kirill S Advertising Accepted by admin
Template #20 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 8, 2019	Kirill S IV is not generated Accepted by admin
Template #24 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 8, 2019	Kirill S IV is not generated Andrew This issue has nothing to do with me. The custom player embedded in the page unsupported by parser itself, so, according to 2.3, IV must not be generated. Declined by admin
Template #26 Kirill S	Issue #1 Feb 8, 2019	Andrew This video is a part of the article Kirill S IV doesn't support iframe from that media service Accepted by admin If there is an unsupported essential content it must be marked as that so no IV will be generated.
Template #24 Andrew	Issue #2 Feb 8, 2019	Kirill S Another iframe from unsupported service, has to be removed Andrew It should not be removed, otherwise the logical order of the article would be broken. Strictly speaking, I operate to (2.3) of the checklist: "IV Targets: Must NOT Generate Pages featuring content unsupported in the IV format: Pages with unsupported embedded content that can't be displayed" Declined by admin
Template #24 Andrew	Issue #3 Feb 8, 2019	Kirill S missing essential content Andrew Everything is in place here. Declined by admin
Template #24 Andrew	Issue #4 Feb 8, 2019	Kirill S missing essential content Accepted by admin
Template #24 Andrew	Issue #5 Feb 9, 2019	Kirill S IV is not generated Accepted by admin
Template #26 Kirill S	Issue #2 Feb 9, 2019	ozeVzH The author profile should be delete or be complete Accepted by admin
Template #28 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 9, 2019	ozeVzH It is not a normal paragraph. Andrew What is this then? It is even <h6> for whatever reason on the original page. So i decided to replace it with <p>. What tag should I use here instead of <p>? It seems to me that there are no appropriate tags that IV supports. Declined by admin
Template #28 Andrew	Issue #2 Feb 10, 2019	ozeVzH It is not a subheader Declined by admin
Template #26 Kirill S	Issue #4 Feb 11, 2019	Andrew Duplicates actually Accepted by admin
Template #31 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 11, 2019	chuchu That's clearly not a caption Accepted by admin
Template #34 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 13, 2019	Amin It's a definitely identifiable pull-quote 3.3. Supported elements Pullquotes must be horizontally centered on IV page if pull quotes exist in the source. there are also a lot of other pullquotes that your template doesn't cover. Andrew That's definitely not a pullquote. Do they really look similar, mine and this one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pull_quote ? Moreover, in the site markup this quote is presented as two regular independent paragraphs with <i> tag inside. There are no guarantees that transforming such block into something else won't ruin some other articles. Declined by admin
Template #36 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 14, 2019	chuchu Not essential. Image is too small to be <img>. Format or remove Andrew I think this is essential part of text, basically this is the info about guest author: "This article by Brian Sewell was originally published ...". Writer decided to include it, so I think I have no rights to exclude it, because this is a unique bit of information, not repeating in the other articles. This gives an idea to reader who the guest is. Declined by admin Since this block can't be identified and safely removed, it's acceptable to leave as it is. Also the Template #37 (by chuchu) doesn't handle the case better. That's how the page looks in the TG client: https://telegra.ph/file/8827569d7a1839b9d7d36.png
Template #36 Andrew	Issue #2 Feb 14, 2019	chuchu This is not a paragraph. It's must be in subscript tag Andrew It's just a smaller text, this is not a subscript even based on semantics. IV doesn't support smaller texts, so I don't know a better way to format it. And I don't think it is that important to do. Is is even in <h6> in the original article for some reason... Declined by admin Not critical
Template #36 Andrew	Issue #3 Feb 15, 2019	chuchu I used to put such images in a cover. Here's the result: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/dailyhodl.com/template5/issue1/ Andrew My template handles that link suggested by you fine, and I think this is just a pretty unique case for this site: just a random small image. As for your link - in that case like 70% of the screen are occupied by 2 pretty similar logo images. Moreover (at least in my opinion; I don't claim I don't break the rules here) it doesn't really matter a lot where to put this picture: under or below the title. It has a white background and looks nicely as a cover. And the last thing, this is more an introductory image for this article, so it wound't ruin the article reading experience. Declined by admin 1) The image in question has a resolution of 400x400 2) It uses the image exactly below the title Using this specific image as cover is okay.
Template #35 Amin	Issue #4 Feb 15, 2019	Andrew Non-clickable image: "In IV 2.0, <img> tags support the optional attribute href to make the image clickable. This should only be used if the link behind the image leads to some different page or content." Accepted by admin
Template #36 Andrew	Issue #4 Feb 17, 2019	admin It seems the template isn't protected enough from dynamic pages. In this case it tried to generate IV for the main page but did not succeed only because of images inside <aside>. If the site developer changes this <aside> to <div>, for example, the template will generate IV for the main page, that is unacceptable Accepted by admin
Template #37 chuchu	Issue #1 Feb 17, 2019	admin That's how this image looks in the TG client: https://telegra.ph/file/8827569d7a1839b9d7d36.png Accepted by admin
Template #38 Amin	Issue #1 Feb 18, 2019	Andrew This block must be removed. Amin It's just an ordinary link inside this page, it's not a general footer and writer put this in this article Not generally identifiable Accepted by admin
Template #38 Amin	Issue #2 Feb 19, 2019	Andrew Again: you identified "Join us on Telegram ", but not identified this. Two links next to each other. Must be removed. Declined by admin Duplicate issue https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/dailyhodl.com/template38/issue1/
Template #41 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 20, 2019	Amin this should be removed Accepted by admin
Template #43 Amin	Issue #1 Feb 20, 2019	Andrew The page contains unsupported iframe. IV should not be generated. Amin the video you're mentioning is replaced by a link to the video's website, it's the default behavior of the site on mobile devices Declined by admin https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-2-video-audio-from-unsupported-players
Template #44 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 23, 2019	Andrew That's not an issue. Admins, help, my appeal is being ignored :( https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/mel.fm/template44/issue2/ Declined by admin
Template #44 Andrew	Issue #2 Feb 23, 2019	chuchu Missing captions Andrew I haven't seen any pages with this pattern being used for image captions. Unique case? Accepted by admin
Template #48 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 26, 2019	chuchu Line breaks Andrew They're preserved actually. Why it might be not a good idea to add <br> I've already explained in the similar issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/mel.fm/template54/issue1/ Declined by admin
Template #48 Andrew	Issue #2 Feb 26, 2019	chuchu Should be removed Andrew Your issue about this has already been declined: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/dailyhodl.com/template36/issue1/ Declined by admin

Processed Issues41

Log In