Preview
Issue #1
- chuchu
- It is not gallery. It is just navigation between pages. Navbars should be removed.
Essential? Really?:)
- Declined by admin
- It's not a gallery.
- Accepted by admin
- This issue was declined as the result of an error. If you open this page in a browser, you will see a gallery that holds all the covers for a magazine.
1. The user who shares this link will expect that he's sending more than just one picture.
2. The gallery is constantly updated with new covers as new issues of the magazine get published. The IV will become outdated within several months.
If this album were static, it would have been sufficient to support the navigation. But since this album is (and will be) updated daily with new covers, no IV should be generated at all.
- chuchu
- If I make whole site with navigation of that kind would you treat whole site as one big gallery?
Main goal of this page is to display one cover. Other is related articles, prev/next articles
>>1. The user who shares this link will expect that he's sending more than just one picture.
"Nobody expects the spanish inquisition"
I can't agree that this is an gallery, just convenient navigation.
It's like to say that the user who shares this link will expect that main nav bar will be preserved. Link correspond only to this cover, other covers has their link too
This moment should be in IV criteria..
- Accepted by admin
- If you open this page in a browser, you will see a large image followed by a list of thumbnails. After those thumbnails comes the comments section – this is where the page ends when you view it on the web (after the comments come links to other articles on this site and the rest of the footer). Before the comments section the user sees 11 images, 10 of them dynamically added (one new each day), and a 'show more' button.
But if you open the page in an IV generated by template #9, you will see one just image, nothing else. You would agree that such an IV does not represent the page I've described above.
Fitting the entire internet into a set of clear criteria is not an easy task – with luck we'll get to something like that by the end of the second contest. But I hope this explanation clarifies our reasoning a little better. Sorry for having to decline this appeal.
- Type of issue
- IV page is missing essential content
- Reported
- Jun 18, 2017
This is a multi-page gallery: it contains "prev" and "next" navigation buttons.
A gallery navigation should be preserved.