Processed Issues187

This page shows a list of issues for elementy.ru that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #4 Issue #1
May 27, 2017
Missing cover
Declined by admin
It is optional to add a cover in this case: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-cover-images
Template #4 Issue #2
Jun 6, 2017
This is not author, but hero of article;
Missing paragraph
Accepted by admin
It's possible to use that author name. Unfortunately, the template doesn't work properly with other articles (e.g. http://elementy.ru/nauchno-populyarnaya_biblioteka/izbrannoe/430055/Khronologiya_dalekogo_proshlogo)
Template #6 Issue #1
Jun 6, 2017
This is not author
Accepted by admin
Template #11 Issue #1
Jun 12, 2017
Missing content
котолий
It isn't essential content. It is links to related articles and some RELATED(not main) content, for example this is article about "принцип коперника", but you selected content about "планисфкра коперника". Also this content is placed under "share" links, so i think this content is optional
Declined by admin
Template #15 Issue #3
Jun 13, 2017
Please check this page:
http://elementy.ru/trefil/21136/Chisla_Fibonachchi
it is not "related topics" , it is part of article
котолий
It is optional
Declined by admin
It's optional.
Template #19 Issue #1
Jun 16, 2017
we can not support tables http://prntscr.com/fkmbbd

maybe you have ideas about supporting all tables
Vitaly Doronin
No, we can: Conditions offer unlimited flexibility for our templates. using ?exists - ?true blocks that allows use both types
Declined by admin
We may accept an issue if it can demonstrate how this approach could lead to problems.
Template #17 Issue #2
Jun 17, 2017
The title must be shown prominently and clearly on IV page.
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#3-1-general-properties
Accepted by admin
Vitaly's template handles it better:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template19/?url=http%3A%2F%2Felementy.ru%2Fkartinka_dnya%2F322%2FKoala_na_dereve
Template #17 Issue #3
Jun 17, 2017
Missing date and author
Accepted by admin
Vitaly's template handles it better:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template19/?url=http%3A%2F%2Felementy.ru%2Fkartinka_dnya%2F322%2FKoala_na_dereve
Template #19 Issue #2
Jun 18, 2017
there is no date in article
Vitaly Doronin
This is charter of book, the main page is
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template19/?url=http%3A%2F%2Felementy.ru%2Fbookclub%2Fbook%2F596%2FShans_est
Accepted by admin
The date must not be shown if it's incorrect.
Template #25 Issue #1
Jun 18, 2017
there is no date in article
Accepted by admin
Template #27 Issue #1
Jun 18, 2017
Missing formatting
котолий
I think it looks pretty good
And it isnt critical
Accepted by admin
Template #19 Issue #3
Jun 19, 2017
date is missing
Vitaly Doronin
page has no date, even in meta
Declined by admin
Template #25 Issue #2
Jun 19, 2017
author is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #27 handles the case better.
Template #27 Issue #2
Jun 19, 2017
date is missing
котолий
because there is no date huh
Declined by admin
Template #25 Issue #3
Jun 19, 2017
Incorrect date; this date of this post
http://elementy.ru/novosti_nauki/433037/V_techenie_fanerozoya_khishchniki_stanovilis_krupnee; page has no date even in meta
Accepted by admin
Yana is right. Google cached this page on 18 Jun 2017 09:08:20 GMT so the presented date and time can't be correct.

https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:WsmxShFcmfIJ:https://elementy.ru/email/5021740/A_belye_medvedi_zimoy_tozhe_spyat+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=ru
Template #27 Issue #3
Jun 19, 2017
Missing comma between authors
котолий
it isn't matter what divider you use
Accepted by admin
Vitaly is right. No divider at all makes it hard to understand if it's one author or several ones. And combined with far from perfect table handling these reports have to be accepted.
Template #19 Issue #4
Jun 19, 2017
>This is chapter of book, the main page is ...
yep it is chapter of book, but after all it have not date and date must not be showed
Vitaly Doronin
Fixed
Accepted by admin
Duplicated issue.
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template19/issue2/
Template #25 Issue #4
Jun 19, 2017
Missing author existing on page
Accepted by admin
Template #27 handles the case better.
Template #29 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
author does not exist, but can be found on page
Glеb
Solved
Accepted by admin
Template #29 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
No Instant View available
Glеb
Solved (img in table issue)
Accepted by admin
Template #29 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
author is present on page, but not in IV
Glеb
Solved
Accepted by admin
Template #29 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
site_name is not present in Link Preview
Glеb
Solved
Accepted by admin
Template #30 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
A lot of rudimentary content are not removed
Accepted by admin
Template #33 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
there is no cover image
Accepted by admin
Template #34 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
no cover image
Glеb
this image is a part of the content and I'm not sure that it should be used as cover
Declined by admin
The image is below the title, so this case is optional.
Template #34 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
no cover image
Glеb
this image is a part of the content and I'm not sure that it should be used as cover
Declined by admin
Duplicate issue
Template #34 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
no cover image, content with <details> not applied
Declined by admin
The source page doesn't have a cover at all.
Template #35 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
img missing
Иван Соболев
Not my mistake, you can see cover image in link preview
Accepted by admin
This source page does not have a cover at all.

If your template sets an image as the cover, the IV generated will use that cover image for the link preview as well.

So this is a valid issue with the template. The template should not be taking any image from the article as the cover, especially if the image is all the way at the bottom of the page.

Here's another example page:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template35/?url=https%3A%2F%2Felementy.ru%2Fproblems%2F1570%2FTsentr_Broka

The image used as cover is taken from the bottom of the source page (Послесловие section). This corrupts the IV.
Template #34 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
missing img
Glеb
The mentioned image could be seen both here and in editor.
Declined by admin
Template #33 Issue #4
Feb 7, 2019
The author is repeated in the content.
Declined by admin
seems okay
Template #34 Issue #5
Feb 7, 2019
The date isn't shown in original content, the date is incorrect. The author is repeated too.
Accepted by admin
The source page actually displays the author twice, so that is not an issue with the template.

However, the issue with date is a valid issue with this template. The source page does not show a publish date. However, the template is getting the date from a related article's date.

The IV says the article is from today, but if you check the comments, they go all the way back from 2010. So this article definitely was not published in Feb 2019.
Template #35 Issue #2
Feb 7, 2019
The content must be removed fully.
Accepted by admin
Template #37 Issue #1
Feb 8, 2019
This isn't author, the content is about the person and his book. Cover is missing too.
Accepted by admin
Template #37 Issue #2
Feb 9, 2019
Caption is missing.
Declined by admin
image is missing -> caption is missing (duplicate)
Template #37 Issue #3
Feb 10, 2019
cover image not presented
Accepted by admin
Template #38 Issue #1
Feb 10, 2019
rudiment content
Accepted by admin
Template #38 Issue #2
Feb 10, 2019
own date content in template
Accepted by admin
indeed
Template #41 Issue #2
Feb 10, 2019
IV is missing necessary information that is about the book. It is useful and essential information.
Accepted by admin
Template #42 Issue #1
Feb 10, 2019
Figcaption is missing. The figcaption is incorrect.
Иван Соболев
up to admins but my figcaption fits too very well
Accepted by admin
Template #37 Issue #4
Feb 10, 2019
The static and essential content isn't generating IV.
Accepted by admin
Template #37 Issue #5
Feb 10, 2019
Figcaption is missing.
Accepted by admin
Template #43 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
Hint's content is missing
Anvar Jamgirov 🇵🇸
If you clicked the toggle you would see the content. Nothing is missing.
Accepted by admin
There is actually content in the detail blocks for this IV.

However, in the "Решение" block, the gif under "Рис. 6." is missing.

The formulas displayed in the IV are also corrupted.

So essential content is missing and a corrupted IV is generated.
Template #44 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
wrong author
Accepted by admin
Template #44 Issue #2
Feb 11, 2019
missed journal title
Declined by admin
title is there
Template #48 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
Figcaption is missing.
Accepted by admin
Template #49 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
Author of Post must be
Accepted by admin
Template #51 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
Must be author
Anvar Jamgirov 🇵🇸
This isn't the author. This is the part of the title.
Declined by admin
Template #55 Issue #2
Feb 11, 2019
The content doesn't fit to the original page.
Accepted by admin
The table is broken. The reporter's templates handles it better.
Template #58 Issue #1
Feb 12, 2019
Text format has been changed.
Anvar Utepov
Author text the same.
Declined by admin
Template #58 Issue #2
Feb 12, 2019
Author is missing.
Anvar Utepov
Author is there
Accepted by admin
There's more than one author. The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #58 Issue #3
Feb 14, 2019
This can't be a cover
Accepted by admin
Template #58 Issue #4
Feb 14, 2019
That's not a kicker.
Accepted by admin
Template #58 Issue #5
Feb 14, 2019
Missing the very essential part of the article
Accepted by admin
Template #61 Issue #1
Feb 14, 2019
Text format has been changed.
Andrew
IV doesn't support advanced formatting.
In my template this block looks as similar to the original one as possible.
Declined by admin
Template #61 Issue #2
Feb 16, 2019
some unsupported content
Andrew
I'm aware of this issue.
I don't see a way to detect some random latex formulas.

MathJax script is included on the every page -> bad method.

The only possible way is to use regexes, but they fail (regexes like \\\((.+)\\\) and [\][(](.+)[\][)] ) with "Regexp pattern is empty" error (by the way, why do they fail!?).

Moreover, some latex formulas aren't even within a paragraph tag (for example here: https://elementy.ru/problems/1968/Kvadraty_v_kvadrate). Even more problematic to do something about it.
Declined by admin
Template #61 Issue #3
Feb 17, 2019
Nested elements not handled. This page need IV see my template.
Andrew
I saw the same error in your template :) https://pp.userapi.com/c846021/v846021776/1b4d0e/DhEhVp-JWj0.jpg

Basically they decided to wrap a blockquote in a table for whatever reason. I haven't seen something like this on other pages.
Accepted by admin
Template #61 Issue #4
Feb 17, 2019
"Пэт Шипман" isn't the author of the article. He is the author of the book. It is the kicker. See my template
Andrew
Your template handles this page much worse that mine does by the way.
I don't know about the author though. I decided to show book's authors in more clear way.
Also, "Пэт Шипман" can't be a kicker either: https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/kicker-definition-meaning
Accepted by admin
Template #61 Issue #5
Feb 17, 2019
Too many dividers make it difficult reading the article.
Andrew
Not template issue. That't how they presented in the original article.
Declined by admin
Template #62 Issue #1
Feb 18, 2019
Poorly formatted block
Accepted by admin
Template #66 Issue #1
Feb 19, 2019
Author is missing.
Accepted by admin
The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #67 Issue #1
Feb 19, 2019
Author link is missing.
Declined by admin
author link is optional
Template #68 Issue #1
Feb 19, 2019
all elements are supported
Accepted by admin
The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #67 Issue #2
Feb 19, 2019
all elements are supported
Accepted by admin
The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #66 Issue #2
Feb 19, 2019
all elements are supported
Accepted by admin
The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #67 Issue #3
Feb 19, 2019
This is not author
Accepted by admin
Template #68 Issue #2
Feb 19, 2019
IV must be generated.
Accepted by admin
The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #72 Issue #1
Feb 20, 2019
Dynamically updated list of articles
Accepted by admin
Template #72 Issue #2
Feb 20, 2019
Missing content
Accepted by admin
Template #68 Issue #3
Feb 20, 2019
Should have IV
Accepted by admin
The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #68 Issue #4
Feb 20, 2019
That not suits for cover
Declined by admin
Why doesn't it suit?
Template #68 Issue #5
Feb 20, 2019
Missing related links. It's part of article
Accepted by admin
Template #77 Issue #1
Feb 20, 2019
Unsupported formulas.
Vitaly Doronin
I think, this problem not about supported from IV, or not supported. But it about how the site displayed formulars. It used tex language. But IV engine parse formulars as simple paragraphs, so you can't track them by using reg exp. Or tag <div>. Seems , authors like using Tex language, for example, there:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template78/?url=https%3A%2F%2Felementy.ru%2Fnovosti_nauki%2F433019%2FS_pomoshchyu_atomno_silovogo_mikroskopa_mozhno_izmerit_elektrootritsatelnost_otdelnogo_atoma
You can handle it, but, these pages might be even more.It's difficult question. If IV been able to found math script, then we could track them.
Declined by admin
Template #77 Issue #2
Feb 21, 2019
The author name is being repeated. It is better not to use "author:" property here.
Vitaly Doronin
I think it's not important extract auhor from here, besides, "Ответил: " migtht be also important
Declined by admin
Template #78 Issue #1
Feb 21, 2019
Author is repeated.
Andrew
That's not an issue. "Ответил" might be also important.
Declined by admin
Template #77 Issue #4
Feb 22, 2019
That's not a subtitle.
Vitaly Doronin
Its one of main headers. I marked it as subtitle
Accepted by admin
In this case it should be formatted as a kicker
Template #81 Issue #1
Feb 23, 2019
Need IV. Static and essential content must generate IV.
Andrew
Such pages contain formulas looking like tables, which could be misunderstood by a reader.
Declined by admin
Template #81 Issue #2
Feb 23, 2019
Poorly formatted content. The dividers not removed.
Andrew
I love the reports from people which have the same page formatted even more poorly.

What's wrong with my formatting? This looks very similar to the original layout. The presence of these dividers doesn't ruin the reading experience, they also just present on the original page.
Accepted by admin
Template #81 Issue #3
Feb 23, 2019
Author is repeated.
Andrew
That's not an issue at all. There is no rules about that.
Declined by admin
Template #81 Issue #4
Feb 23, 2019
This isn't a cover.
Andrew
That's a perfect image for a cover in the sense that this isn't part of the article (it doesn't have to be in a specific place).
Declined by admin
Template #84 Issue #1
Feb 24, 2019
Author and published date are missing. They were not handled as "author:" and "published_date:". The "ИНДИКАТОР " catalogue must be removed.
Accepted by admin
Template #87 Issue #1
Feb 25, 2019
All elements are supported
Accepted by admin
Template #90 Issue #1
Feb 27, 2019
Not removed author and date
Declined by admin
Duplicate
Template #92 Issue #1
Feb 27, 2019
IV can be rendered.
Andrew
It contains unsupported formulas which I'm detecting and marking with @unsupported.

Just search in your template for "Если бы только по этому правилу можно было создавать" and you'll see.
Declined by admin
Template #92 Issue #2
Feb 27, 2019
Not author
Accepted by admin
Template #92 Issue #3
Feb 28, 2019
Not author, it source link
Accepted by admin
Template #92 Issue #4
Mar 1, 2019
I think, this image not suits for cover, it taken from main part of article
Declined by admin
Template #94 Issue #1
Mar 1, 2019
<math> tag must be marked as unsupported. Pages with broken formulas lose sense.
Vitaly Doronin
I prove, that we won't be able detect all formulars this site, until IV engine can finds MathJax script. here examples:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template77/issue1/
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template77/issue3/
And if you think, that all formulars can't be displayed not properly true. For example, "x+y = z" is plane equation. There a lot of math equations, that may be displayed. Or mark @unsopported them all?
Declined by admin
Template #94 Issue #2
Mar 1, 2019
Formulas can be 100% identified using regexps & pages containing them should be marked as unsupported (and also tables imitating fractions)
Vitaly Doronin
I prove, that we won't be able detect all formulars this site, until IV engine can finds MathJax script. here examples:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template77/issue1/
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template77/issue3/
And if you think, that all formulars can't be displayed not properly true. For example, "x+y = z" is plane equation. There a lot of math equations, that may be displayed. Or mark @unsopported them all?
Declined by admin
Template #94 Issue #3
Mar 1, 2019
This isn't related article. This is a part of the article.
Accepted by admin
Vitaly Doronin
This article about charter from book, and link on this book is related to this article and this block serve as preview of book, charter of which is an article. And link supported from IV:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template94/?url=https%3A%2F%2Felementy.ru%2Fbookclub%2Fbook%2F468%2FNachalo_beskonechnosti
As you can see , it just preview other article.
Accepted by admin
Template #96 Issue #1
Mar 3, 2019
This image not suits for cover. "Рис.1" sould be in the article body for better understanding
Andrew
This is not a part of the body. This block is located right after the title and before the lead paragraph. It's just turning out I swapped the title and this image. That's it.
Having a numbering on the images editors can have references to them in the text.
Declined by admin
Template #96 Issue #2
Mar 3, 2019
missing iv
Accepted by admin
Template #100 Issue #1
Mar 4, 2019
Need IV.
Andrew
Contains unsupported formulas:
"Диапазон системы уже был расширен правилом, предписывающим умножать на десять тысяч число, написанное над \( M \). Например, двадцать обозначалось символом \( κ \), а четыре — \( δ \), и двадцать четыре мириада (240 000) можно было записать как \( \overset{κδ}{M} \).",

"Если бы только по этому правилу можно было создавать многоуровневые числа, чтобы \( \overset{\overset{κδ}{M}}{M} \) "
Declined by admin
Template #100 Issue #2
Mar 4, 2019
Missing link on the book existing on source. Without this link this block is pointless/also not clear what means "..."
Accepted by admin
Template #100 Issue #3
Mar 4, 2019
Here all formulas is supported with table. Should have IV
Andrew
I marked them as unsupported on purpose, they look ugly and may be misunderstood.
Declined by admin
Template #100 Issue #4
Mar 4, 2019
this is not blockquote due to this issue. There are exists simple way https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/htmlbook.ru/template68/issue1/
Accepted by admin
Template #100 Issue #5
Mar 4, 2019
Also formulas is supported
Andrew
Duplicate https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template100/issue3/
Declined by admin
Template #100 Issue #6
Mar 4, 2019
Sorry for #2 but there really missing links on the books existing on source.
Andrew
Yes, I saw you issue. Give me some time, I'm not able to fix it right now.
P. S. I already hate this site :(
Declined by admin
Template #100 Issue #7
Mar 4, 2019
Big Sorrry for # 2 and #6 , all ok with links, but no author on this page. "Постнаука" is link on sorce
For example, similar page with author: https://elementy.ru/bookclub/review/5273547/
Andrew
Omg, even I completely forgot I had links on the images xD
Although this is an issue, agree
Accepted by admin
Template #109 Issue #1
Mar 6, 2019
Missing captions for media. List supports captions in v.2.0: Also media should not be list elements.
Accepted by admin
Template #113 Issue #1
Mar 9, 2019
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-1-pages-with-dynamic-content
Catalogs

Why do you support this page? It's list of articles, not article. Should not generate. And if you decided to support this , you missing introduction text and picture
Accepted by admin
Template #113 Issue #2
Mar 9, 2019
Description in link preview not correct. It should be taken from brief to this book.
Accepted by admin
Template #120 Issue #1
Mar 10, 2019
Missing captions under 4 photo and others below. this is the same , as under 2nd an 3rd and look like : //div[@class="comment"]
Accepted by admin
Template #120 Issue #2
Mar 10, 2019
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-1-image-links
In IV 2.0, <img> tags support the optional attribute href to make the image clickable. This should only be used if the link behind the image leads to some different page or content. E.g., if the link opens the same image in a higher resolution, it should be ignored.

Link opens same image
Andrew
Stop, stop, I know about it, not my first day in the contest..
Accepted by admin
Template #120 Issue #3
Mar 10, 2019
Answer to https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template118/issue3/

Without main link "Главы" it's not clear for user, what means links below
Accepted by admin
Template #120 Issue #4
Mar 10, 2019
dublicate title
Accepted by admin
Template #125 Issue #1
Mar 10, 2019
Spoilers
Accepted by admin
Since the content of these cuts are presented, there is no need to preserve links
Template #126 Issue #1
Mar 11, 2019
Need IV.
Andrew
I've already explained it here:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template92/issue1/
Declined by admin
Template #126 Issue #2
Mar 11, 2019
Missing quote caption
Accepted by admin
Template #128 Issue #4
Mar 11, 2019
Missing quote
Accepted by admin
Template #126 Issue #3
Mar 11, 2019
Missing quote, identifies in source
Accepted by admin
Template #126 Issue #4
Mar 11, 2019
This is blockquote on the source, not contains unsupported elements to transform it
Declined by admin
Template #138 Issue #1
Mar 13, 2019
Links are missing.
Andrew
Stop reporting stupid issues, the link is here
Declined by admin
Template #138 Issue #2
Mar 13, 2019
Need IV
Declined by admin
Template #138 Issue #3
Mar 13, 2019
This must be <blockquote>.
Declined by admin
Template #138 Issue #4
Mar 13, 2019
Need IV.
Declined by admin
Template #138 Issue #5
Mar 13, 2019
This must be header.
Declined by admin
Template #143 Issue #1
Mar 15, 2019
Author of the article is missing. See my template!
Declined by admin
Template #143 Issue #2
Mar 16, 2019
Author is duplicated.
Andrew
That's not an issue.
Declined by admin
Template #143 Issue #3
Mar 16, 2019
Link is missing
Andrew
The link is here.
Declined by admin
Template #143 Issue #4
Mar 16, 2019
Images are missing.
Andrew
They are here:
https://pp.userapi.com/c850020/v850020168/149dff/_tYdSalMgDg.jpg
Declined by admin
Template #143 Issue #5
Mar 16, 2019
Rudimentary anchor; not working
Andrew
Not visible in the app
Declined by admin
Template #143 Issue #6
Mar 16, 2019
Same: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template125/issue1/
also forgot spoilers:)
so much content missing
Accepted by admin
Template #143 Issue #7
Mar 16, 2019
Rudimentary; you cant display "+" and "-" in IV
Declined by admin
Duplicate
Template #148 Issue #1
Mar 16, 2019
Rudimentary icon "+". This icon replaced by details "up" or "down"
Andrew
I'm not sure about this. Does this really matter? I don't know.
Accepted by admin
Template #148 Issue #2
Mar 16, 2019
Table with 1 column no make sense. It can be simplify into text
Andrew
This is a weird table from 2014 page. Still looks ok in the app.
Declined by admin
2014
Template #148 Issue #3
Mar 16, 2019
This is blockquote on the source, not contains unsupported elements, so no reason convert it into text
Andrew
Also no reason to convert it into block*quote* - because this block is not meant for quotes
Declined by admin
Template #148 Issue #4
Mar 16, 2019
Dublicate link into related
Andrew
The first link is a part of the article.
The "Related articles" block is generated from the right column of the page.
So that's a content "issue".
Declined by admin
Template #148 Issue #5
Mar 18, 2019
Should not generate, contains unsupported widget
Accepted by admin
Template #161 Issue #1
Mar 20, 2019
For what reason you did add dividers?
Andrew
In order to separate .ins_block from the rest of the content
(why I don't transform such blocks into blockquote: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template158/issue2/)
Declined by admin
Template #161 Issue #2
Mar 20, 2019
common article
Andrew
The article contains formulas that cannot be displayed properly (like \(g\bar{q} \to \bar{t}H^+ \to \bar{t}+t\bar{b}\)).
Declined by admin
Template #161 Issue #3
Mar 20, 2019
You are used cropped (?) image. should be original one
Andrew
This is the original one actually: just click the enlarge icon.
Declined by admin
Template #161 Issue #4
Mar 20, 2019
should be a blockquote
Andrew
Such blocks are not meant for block*quotes* and may contain arbitrary elements, for example:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template158/issue2/
Declined by admin
Template #161 Issue #5
Mar 20, 2019
common article
Andrew
Duplicate: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template161/issue2/
(\[\nabla^2\Phi-\lambda\Phi=4\pi G\rho.\])
Declined by admin
Template #161 Issue #6
Mar 20, 2019
photo is missing
Andrew
Broken image behind the "enlarge" button
Declined by admin
Template #161 Issue #7
Mar 21, 2019
Andrew
What is wrong with it? It differs from the rest of content both in my template and yours.
Declined by admin
Template #161 Issue #8
Mar 21, 2019
Dublicate title
Andrew
The first title is a title of the whole pages (IV pages cannot be generated without a title obviously). But this title is also a part of the name of the book:
"Хроники тираннозавра: Биология и эволюция самого известного хищника в мире" (David Hone. The Tyrannosaur Chronicles: The Biology of the Tyrant Dinosaurs).
Declined by admin
Template #161 Issue #9
Mar 21, 2019
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template158/issue10/

Actually, your template not handled this case properly too: second blockquote used as caption
Andrew
Yes, but that's what not possible to know, what the nested blockquotes is going to be.
Declined by admin
Template #161 Issue #10
Mar 21, 2019
Missing quote identifiable on the source
Accepted by admin
Template #161 Issue #11
Mar 21, 2019
Missing quote , identifiable on the source
Andrew
Duplicate
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template161/issue10/
Declined by admin
Template #161 Issue #12
Mar 22, 2019
If this page have IV
https://elementy.ru/time/biophysics/biophysics-folding-2.html
it also should have iv, supports quote into list
Andrew
Fair enough
Accepted by admin
Template #161 Issue #13
Mar 22, 2019
Missing linebreaks between paragraphs in blockquote
Accepted by admin
Template #170 Issue #1
Mar 25, 2019
This is blockquotes on the source; first two - supports small images, last- only text
Andrew
No. Like I said earlier (https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template158/issue2/, also note https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template163/issue5/) this block ("ins_block") is not meant for blockquotes (QUOTES!), and <blockquote> tag was added here not for semantics, but for CSS styling (check the css).
Declined by admin
Template #170 Issue #2
Mar 25, 2019
Quote caption is missing
Andrew
This is not a caption. This is just a text aligned to the right which means pretty much nothing. An example when your template fails: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template173/?url=https%3A%2F%2Felementy.ru%2Fbookclub%2Fchapters%2F433635%2FZhizn_na_grani_Glava_iz_knigi
Declined by admin
Template #170 Issue #3
Mar 25, 2019
One more case with broken blockquotes; no need to break them this case
Andrew
Duplicate https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template170/issue1/
Declined by admin
Template #170 Issue #4
Mar 25, 2019
Andrew
1) New types of nuclear decays are being discovered every day?
2) This project ("Масштабы: времена") is completed and not filled anymore.
3) I didn't see a link to this page on any article from this section
Accepted by admin
Template #170 Issue #5
Mar 25, 2019
Answer to Andrew:
1. Yea, this list of articles, but there are not present nuclear decay named "gamma".
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gamma_ray#Radioactive_decay_(gamma_decay)
2. There are no article about beta-plus and beta-minus decays. It is big theme, new articles may happen:)
Andrew
This page has not changed since (at least) 2015:
http://web.archive.org/web/20150420211407/elementy.ru/time/nuclear
Declined by admin
Template #170 Issue #6
Mar 25, 2019
It is not article, but catalog, should not generate
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-1-pages-with-dynamic-content
Catalogs
Andrew
2014 page:
"Обновление раздела прекращено в 2014 году. Версии законов могут не быть актуальными."
"We won’t accept issues on news articles posted before 2016 if the template correctly handles articles published recently."
Declined by admin
Template #170 Issue #7
Mar 25, 2019
Missing preview suitable image, existing on the source
Declined by admin
Template #176 Issue #1
Mar 25, 2019
Accepted by admin
Template #180 Issue #1
Mar 25, 2019
1) Dublicate link
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-2-1-formatting-related-articles
2) Your IV may only have one block of related articles at the end of the page. If the source has several blocks, merge them together or choose which one to keep.
Andrew
Are you kidding? Two completely different blocks, second link is unique at all
Declined by admin
Template #180 Issue #2
Mar 25, 2019
Answer to: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template177/issue1/

Since should be only one related block ,better to stay only one, not duplicate. I decided to leave first, because the authors themselves choose the most appropriate news.
Declined by admin
Template #180 Issue #3
Mar 28, 2019
if you fix this:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template170/issue5/
why do you not fix this page? Also should'n generate
Andrew
And why should I fix it? Like I said, such pages have been static since at least 2015:
http://web.archive.org/web/20150414102101/http://elementy.ru/time/particles
Declined by admin
Duplicate
Template #180 Issue #4
Mar 28, 2019
Aslo should not generates, it's not article. It is dynamic updated section. You can see "NEW" stickers, that means articles have been added recently.
There are more sections, that should not generates:
https://elementy.ru/LHC/HEP
https://elementy.ru/LHC/LHC, etc.
Declined by admin
Duplicate
Template #180 Issue #5
Mar 28, 2019
Thanks for this example,
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template170/issue2/
if you know about this case, you should take care about captions in this quotes
Andrew
No, I should not. They cannot be identified reliably.
Declined by admin
Template #180 Issue #6
Mar 28, 2019
Also missing captions
Andrew
Duplicate
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template180/issue5/
Declined by admin
Template #185 Issue #1
Mar 31, 2019
Duplicate link. My template handles it better
Andrew
Your template handles it much worse
Declined by admin
Template #185 Issue #2
Mar 31, 2019
Missing quote captions. My template handles it better
Declined by admin
Template #185 Issue #3
Mar 31, 2019
1) Rudimentary zoom
2) Better quality of images exists on the source
Andrew
One more pretty old page
http://web.archive.org/web/20150516132315/http://elementy.ru/time/continents/continents-1.html
Declined by admin
Template #185 Issue #4
Mar 31, 2019
Description in link preview is not correct.
Andrew
Exactly correct. First paragraph of the article.
Declined by admin
Template #185 Issue #5
Apr 1, 2019
Should have IV, I did not find any unsupported formula, except \n > 2\, that not contains any unsupported symbol.
Andrew
It is not possible to write exceptions for simple formulas like this in order to support the page. Moreover, the result is not going to be perfect: \(n>2\) - that's what user will see
Declined by admin
Template #185 Issue #6
Apr 1, 2019
Link Preview description should be "Интервью Ольги Баклицкой-Каменевой с Владимиром Воеводским". Your description begins with dialog.
Accepted by admin
Template #187 Issue #1
Apr 3, 2019
Should have IV, n>2 is supported formula
Andrew
Like I said, a user will still see "\(n>2\)" instead of just "n > 2". It is barely possible to detect if formula is simple enough.
Declined by admin
Template #187 Issue #2
Apr 3, 2019
Missing quote caption. My template handles it better
Andrew
I'm still not going to risk adding captions here
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template170/issue2/
Declined by admin
Template #187 Issue #3
Apr 3, 2019
Duplicate related section; duplicate link.
Accepted by admin
Andrew
These links are from two different blocks (related block is on the right). Since the block at the end of the page cannot be reliably identified and may contain important links and information, it is not possible to reliably exclude duplicate links from any of these blocks.
Declined by admin
That's a fair counter argument. The link is duplicated in the source page itself, and the link at bottom of article is not identifiable.

Also, looking at some articles from this domain, it does not seem that the duplication of the link is very common.

Please remember though that it's important to make your counter arguments before arbiters process issues.
Template #187 Issue #4
Apr 3, 2019
This from reviews dynamic section. Shoul be removed
Andrew
Anchors are not visible in the actual IV
Declined by admin
It's not ideal, but overall this seems okay
Template #187 Issue #5
Apr 3, 2019
Should not generate. This page represent dynamic list of articles. It is section like https://elementy.ru/LHC/LHC
https://elementy.ru/LHC/LHC_results
Andrew
It looks like this page has not been updated since 2015, so it is an old page
Accepted by admin
Template #187 Issue #6
Apr 3, 2019
punctuation error in title: there are no dash after question mark in russian;
and after exclamation mark: https://elementy.ru/bookclub/review/5273507/
and after "...":
https://elementy.ru/bookclub/review/5273319/
If you going to compose your own title, you should take it maximally closer to source. For example , on "Биомолекула.ру" using following pattern: Author: "Title". Рецензия
Andrew
I think the way of composing a title is up to creator of template in this case. The dash here is a delimiter between book name and "Рецензия на книгу".
Accepted by admin
Template #187 Issue #7
Apr 3, 2019
Andrew
It is optional to generate IV for service pages if they don't feature unsupported elements
Declined by admin
Optional
Template #188 Issue #1
Apr 6, 2019
Author is still missing
Accepted by admin
Vitaly Doronin
It is not identifiable at all. In //div[@class="sublink]/span can be absolutely any text
Accepted by admin
It's actually identifiable and a consistent structure for authors.

You can look here:
https://elementy.ru/bookclub/review?source=5205287

Checking the first 8 articles there, they all use the same author structure.
Template #188 Issue #3
Apr 6, 2019
And I still think you should set a proper link preview description for such pages
Accepted by admin
Vitaly Doronin
my desription match original desription //meta[@name = "description"] . And take description from first paragraph not safe it may cause this:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template185/issue6/
Accepted by admin
Meta info can be unreliable across numerous domains. It's not something to rely on blindly or by default.
Template #195 Issue #1
Apr 8, 2019
As I can see, you managed to fix it.
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template189/issue1/

My congratulations.

I think you already understand why the descriptions are not correct in that case))
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template189/issue1/
Declined by admin
Template #195 Issue #3
Apr 11, 2019
That issue is still present
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template188/issue2/
Not also you're risking losing important link, but it may happen that only one of multiple links from the same sentence will be preserved.
Vitaly Doronin
That's not an issue. This is not essential links. It links from block "related". And seems as one-case , usually authors put links on the same site:
https://elementy.ru/novosti_nauki/433460/Otkryt_novyy_sezon_okhoty_za_gravitatsionnymi_volnami
https://elementy.ru/novosti_nauki/433452/Boyatsya_li_filologi_anatomii_Eshche_raz_o_prikuse_i_fonetike
please, check this links, they are from 2019
Accepted by admin
Since these links are used as references, they are important and must nor be formatted as related
Template #196 Issue #1
Apr 11, 2019
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template187/issue3/
I still think, that it is issue.
Check also this: https://elementy.ru/novosti_nauki/433460/Otkryt_novyy_sezon_okhoty_za_gravitatsionnymi_volnami
Related block is duplicated. My template handles this better.
Declined by admin
"Cм также" block from the body must not be formatted as related, since it may contain essential links.

This link is duplicated as related in the article. Acceptable formatting
Template #196 Issue #2
Apr 11, 2019
Andrew
Still cannot be reliably identified
Declined by admin
Template #196 Issue #3
Apr 11, 2019
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template187/issue6/
Still i think, no dash after question mark in russian.
Accepted by admin
"Рецензия на книгу:" must be a kicker in this case
Template #196 Issue #4
Apr 11, 2019
Answer to this:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template195/issue2/
description is incorrect. This kind of pages does not have description, exception is from //meta.
Andrew
Agree
Accepted by admin
Template #200 Issue #1
Apr 11, 2019
Must be icon
Andrew
That's what it is
Declined by admin
Low res images should be using <pic> so that they do not get upscaled to full screen width.

This IV seems to be using <pic> here, which is correct.
Template #200 Issue #2
Apr 11, 2019
Image preview is missing. see my template
Andrew
Your image is invisible in the browser.
Declined by admin
Not critical: there's no suitable image in the artcle
Template #200 Issue #3
Apr 11, 2019
description si wrong
Andrew
I don't think that the description formed from the first paragraph is worse.
Declined by admin
Template #200 Issue #4
Apr 11, 2019
Incorrect description. This description from preview of the book. But it is article about charter of the book. Correct description in //meta
Andrew
I'm not sure whether this is a serious issue because the fact that this is an article about the chapter of the book is mentioned in the title anyway. Want to hear admin's opinion about this.
Declined by admin
Seems relevant, so no issue.
Template #200 Issue #5
Apr 14, 2019
Not part of the article, navigation link.
Andrew
Important link to the chapter of this book. See no reasons to remove it.
Declined by admin
Template #200 Issue #6
Apr 14, 2019
Not part of the article and contains dynamic list of other books of this author
Andrew
Information about the authors is important here.
"Dynamic list of other books" - people don't write new books every day and even every year, don't they?
Declined by admin
Template #200 Issue #7
Apr 14, 2019
addition to this: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template196/issue4/

I think, that description can't contain annotation link. Other examples of the fact that there is no description for these kind of pages:
1) https://elementy.ru/nauchno-populyarnaya_biblioteka/432676/Chetyre_stikhii_Empedokla
In this article tells about 6 different practicies, but description taken from first.
2) https://elementy.ru/nauchno-populyarnaya_biblioteka/434543/Mir_v_ravnovesii_drevneyshie_shumerskie_zaklinaniya

Too big first paragraph for description. Description should be short.
3) https://elementy.ru/nauchno-populyarnaya_biblioteka/430622/Dzheyms_Uotson_Chestnost_polezna_etomu_miru_ona_zastavlyaet_mir_rabotat_effektivnee

Iterview again, description contains direct speech. There are may be other pages 1) , 2) or 3) types .
Andrew
Perfect description
Declined by admin
Template #200 Issue #8
Apr 14, 2019
This inserted block should be separated from the text from 2 sides.
Andrew
That's an interesting case, I see this for the first time. Usually ".ins_block" blocks are never nested in additional blocks like ".clear". I put <hr> before ".ins_block" if it has a previous sibling.
Declined by admin
Not critical: it's separated with header and <hr>
Template #200 Issue #9
Apr 14, 2019
Andrew
You idiot?
Declined by admin
Template #200 Issue #10
Apr 14, 2019
based on this:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/elementy.ru/template188/issue1/
Author can be removed and identifiable by "author" in link in common cases.
Andrew
Not identifiable
Declined by admin
Template #200 Issue #11
Apr 14, 2019
Mising image in link preview; incorrect description
Andrew
Description is okay. No suitable image can be seen on the original page.
Declined by admin