Processed Issues49

This page shows a list of issues for formula1.com that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #2 Issue #1
May 20, 2017
Control buttons below photos (Info, Close etc.)
Accepted by admin
This buttons need to be removed.

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#4-content-to-be-removed
Template #7 Issue #1
Jun 6, 2017
Paragraph with article text has height that is too big. All image descriptions are lost
Declined by admin
It's not a critical issue.
Template #5 Issue #1
Jun 6, 2017
Rudimentary images menu is not deleted
Accepted by admin
Template #5 Issue #2
Jun 6, 2017
Images descriptions are lost
Accepted by admin
Template #9 Issue #1
Jun 17, 2017
It is slideshow in source, so have to be slideshow in IV.
+ not remove rudimentary words (Info,Close,Next) and capations are misplaces.

My template process it correct.
Accepted by admin
Yes, it should be a slideshow, since the original article uses a slideshow.

The caption is not preserved as a caption attached to the corresponding media, and the rudimentary button text are not removed.

Since no template could parse this website perfectly, this domain will have no winners in the first contest.
Template #7 Issue #2
Jun 17, 2017
It is slideshow in source, so have to be slideshow in IV.
+ captions of these images are removed.

My template process it correct.
Accepted by admin
Slideshows are required if the source article shows several photos or other media as a slideshow or gallery.
Template #7 Issue #3
Jun 17, 2017
It is main page with list of articles - no need IV.
Accepted by admin
Template #8 Issue #1
Jun 18, 2017
IV is missing all the content
Accepted by admin
Template #9 Issue #2
Jun 18, 2017
IV is missing all the content
Accepted by admin
Template #9 Issue #3
Jun 19, 2017
Is hidden text
Declined by admin
Duplicate issue
Template #8 Issue #2
Jun 19, 2017
Figcaption missing
Accepted by admin
Template #9 Issue #4
Jun 19, 2017
Slideshow
Declined by admin
Duplicate issue
Template #10 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
no instant view
Accepted by admin
I don't see why this page should not generate an IV.
Template #12 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Is showing elements that are not on the original, for example Latest and News
Accepted by admin
Template #13 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Checklist 1.1: IV must be generated for static article-like content such as this driver profile
Declined by admin
Template #12 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
Latest news
Accepted by admin
Template #13 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
IV not showing in this page
Accepted by admin
Template #17 Issue #1
Feb 6, 2019
Video is not supported by Telegram IV
Amin
the video does not exist in the original view (the left column of this page), there is a video in the desktop screen version of the page but it is removed in mobile screens, so the mobile version of this page consists of some images and text that are supported.
Accepted by admin
Opening the source page on a mobile browser still displays the video.

The video is essential content. If all essential content cannot be displayed, then an IV should not be generated.
Template #17 Issue #2
Feb 8, 2019
Slideshow is missing, check my template
Accepted by admin
Template #17 Issue #3
Feb 8, 2019
Caption and slideshow missing
Declined by admin
Duplicate
Template #19 Issue #1
Feb 8, 2019
Captions missing
Nitish Sharma
resolved
Accepted by admin
Nitish Sharma
this was resolved in the recent update
Accepted by admin
If you resolved the slideshow captions in your template, you would need to re-submit your template.
Template #20 Issue #1
Feb 9, 2019
missing IV
Declined by admin
Would need link to template that can fully support this source page to consider this issue.
Template #20 Issue #2
Feb 9, 2019
missing IV
Declined by admin
Duplicate
Template #29 Issue #1
Feb 9, 2019
When several image resolutions are available, the IV page should use better quality images. Check my template

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-1-image-quality
Accepted by admin
Template #31 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
When several image resolutions are available, the IV page should use better quality images

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-1-image-quality
Accepted by admin
Template #38 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
Missing site name.

§3.2: "The site_name property must include the correct name of the website. If the webmaster includes unnecessary data (e.g. ‘Site {sitename}’) or mixes the site name with the article title, your template must take care of this."
Declined by admin
Site name is present. See: https://telegra.ph/file/2ec7ec5ed197427f90b11.png
Template #39 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
Strange characters in the preview
Elian Doran
These "strange characters" you are mentioning are called HTML entities. They can be used to safely represent ("escape") some characters that might otherwise be invalid when passing around, such as in an XML.

Despite the preview showing the HTML entities as they are, Telegram for Android and Telegram for Desktop properly parse them and display the information.

Screenshot of proof:
http://telegra.ph/HTML-Entities-02-11
Declined by admin
Template #39 Issue #2
Feb 13, 2019
Video missing
Accepted by admin
Template #38 Issue #2
Feb 14, 2019
The country flag is missing. While one might argue that this is unneeded, the number (33) without the flag is without context. It is supposed to mean number 33 of Netherlands, not 33 globally.

Refer to my template for an example implementation.
Sherali Rysbekov
Country is always written in the table below
Accepted by admin
Template #38 Issue #3
Feb 14, 2019
Although the template author has fully supported "Driver" pages (e.g. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/formula1.com/template38/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.formula1.com%2Fen%2Fdrivers%2Fsebastian-vettel.html), it seems that "Team" pages have not received the same treatment. These can be fully supported, please refer to my template for an implementation.
Sherali Rysbekov
Look at the version of this page from 3-4 years ago (you can use webarchive com), it has different team members - this is dynamically updated page
Declined by admin
Template #38 Issue #4
Feb 14, 2019
I would like to ask an admin's opinion on whether the "Year by year" pages should be supported. At a first glance they seem to be plain articles, but - by definition - they should be yearly. Where does this sit on the "dynamic-static" scale? Should it be implemented (as it is right now on my template) or should it not be supported?
Sherali Rysbekov
Use the official channel to ask questions
Declined by admin
They shouldn't generate IV
Template #38 Issue #5
Feb 14, 2019
Again, pure speculation, but in response to the Drivers page having dynamic content (https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/formula1.com/template38/issue3/), so do the statistics of a driver.

The number of podiums, points, top positions, etc. is bound to change even more regularly than the team members. And even if, perhaps an admin could clarify on the interval pages are refreshed in IV, especially in situations like these.
Declined by admin
Template #42 Issue #1
Feb 15, 2019
The author is missed
Elian Doran
Indeed, the author is present, but it is as a paragraph that is part of the content. There is no identifiable region in order to mark it as author.

The only way to do this would be to probe the text, but there are no keywords to search for ("Text" is very ambiguous).
Declined by admin
Template #42 Issue #2
Feb 15, 2019
The date is here
Elian Doran
Thank you, but no, it is not. That is the date for the recommended article called "Hall of Fame".
Declined by admin
Template #42 Issue #3
Feb 16, 2019
There is no № symbol at the source page
Elian Doran
The numero sign is meant as a visual aid to the number 44 because it might seem out of context for users. If you have a look at the "44" number in the code, you'll see that it's wrapped in a div.driver-number. By itself, the symbol is harmless and offers additional context; I do not think there would be a reason to invalidate this template unless more severe issue is found or this one is found to cause issues in text and so on.
Declined by admin
Template #42 Issue #4
Feb 16, 2019
Links must be kept
Elian Doran
Although having links, thus navigation, between pages would be a good idea I do not think this should be basis for rejecting the template.

Navigation should be considered as an issue only if essential, and in this case it is arguably not. Additionally, from an UX point of view, making the photo a link with no visual indication of what it does (does it open the image full screen or go to a different page?...) makes little sense for me.
Declined by admin
Template #42 Issue #5
Feb 18, 2019
As admin already said, this is not a static page and shouldn't generate IV.
Please, see this issue: https://www.formula1.com/en/teams/Ferrari/Year_by_Year.html
Declined by admin
Template #42 Issue #6
Feb 18, 2019
Missing videos! IV shouldn't be generated!
Accepted by admin
Template #49 Issue #1
Feb 18, 2019
Missing unsupported videos. IV shouldn't be generated for this page.
Accepted by admin
Template #42 Issue #7
Feb 18, 2019
Missing Poll. IV shouldn't be generated in this page!
Accepted by admin
Template #52 Issue #1
Feb 18, 2019
Related articles should be handled with <related> tag

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-2-related-articles
Elian Doran
§6.3.2. «We will accept issues if: [...] Other “More" links are identifiable and not either removed or formatted as “Related articles”.»

My template properly identifies and properly removes said related articles.
Declined by admin
"YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE" isn't "related"
Template #52 Issue #2
Feb 21, 2019
If the webmaster includes unnecessary data (e.g. ‘Site {sitename}’) [...] your template must take care of this.

You should remove from the site_name "The Official F1 Website", the correct site_name is just "Formula 1"

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#3-2-link-preview
Elian Doran
I do not think this is applicable here. The rule you have mentioned is specifically for "unnecessary data" such as obviously redundant words or mixing page titles.

"Formula 1" is, unarguably a term that is quite prevalent in today's society. I have chosen not to remove the "official" slogan in order to make it stand out and easy to identify that it is not a fan-made site, but a website to the actual entity.

"Website" by itself is not redundant in this case because if we wanted to keep the "official" idea, the title would not make much sense or be confusing (e.g. Formula 1 Official).
Declined by admin
The template author has a point. It's acceptable site name
Template #52 Issue #3
Feb 21, 2019
Wrong description in Link Preview
Elian Doran
That is the description the author of the page has provided, both as the meta description and the description for both Facebook and Twitter share boxes (see https://developers.facebook.com/tools/debug/sharing/?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.formula1.com%2Fen%2Fresults%2Fawards%2Fdhl-fastest-lap-2015.html).

Most, if not almost all other pages do not exhibit this issue, as the information is correct. I think it is not up to the template authors to fix issues that are present in the original page.
Accepted by admin
Link preview description should be set by template in this case
Template #54 Issue #1
Feb 21, 2019
Static page
Accepted by admin
Template #58 Issue #1
Feb 21, 2019
IV missing
Deleted Account
Yes, cause there is an unsupported video in this article
Declined by admin
Template #59 Issue #1
Feb 22, 2019
This page can be fully supported. Please refer to my template for a sample implementation.
Francesco
This page contains an unsupported video embed, and your template doesn't support it too...
Declined by admin
Template #61 Issue #1
Feb 22, 2019
This page can be fully supported. Please refer to my template for a sample implementation.
Deleted Account
It can not be fully supported! Your template is missing the poll!
Accepted by admin
In this case the poll is optional
Template #61 Issue #3
Feb 22, 2019
§6.2.3: "EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used: [...] When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content."

By its very title, this is a gallery page meaning that it has no other content than an introductory paragraph and a small footer at the bottom. The slideshow should be unwrapped.

Please refer to my template for a reference implementation.
Deleted Account
The checklist is clear. "When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content."

There is other content and the pictures are displayed as a gallery. So it must be displayed as a gallery. Just like I did :)
Declined by admin
Template #63 Issue #1
Feb 25, 2019
Checklist says that slideshow must not be used only if the article consists ENTIRELY of a slideshow and there is NO OTHER CONTENT. In this case there is a paragraph and a footer, so it is correct to use the slideshow.
Elian Doran
"EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used: When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content."

The two paragraphs amounting to a total of 67 words fits perfectly into the definition of the slideshow description.

This should not be considered basis for rejecting this template, especially considering the title of the page explicitly mentioning "GALLERY".
Declined by admin