Processed Issues73

This page shows a list of issues for gazeta.ua that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Issue #3
May 26, 2017
This is a static blog article (see 1.1 in checklist).
Accepted by admin
IV should generate for that page.
Template #1 Issue #5
May 28, 2017
THIS IS A BLOG ARTICLE!!!
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #1 Issue #6
May 28, 2017
This is a static article
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #1 Issue #7
May 28, 2017
This is a typical article
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #2 Issue #1
May 28, 2017
looks like source link in author section
Accepted by admin
The link is incorrect.
Template #5 Issue #1
Jun 9, 2017
ilya
You see, in original page it's not a pullquote but a <div> with special styling, that wraps its text in big visible quotes. The text itself doesn't have quotes("") and simple transforming this div into pullquote (like in your template) wouldn't be understandable for the user (that it's a quote).

In my template there's at least some visible change. Anyway, I think such little decisions could be handled by template maker and it's not an issue
Accepted by admin
Eugene's template looks closer to the original, but both interpretations are ultimately imperfect. It would be advisable to manually add quote marks to such paragraphs, since quotes is what the user sees in the original and it appears that this formatting is fairly consistent - and identifiable - on the source website.
Template #5 Issue #2
Jun 9, 2017
Additional for previous issue.
There are two types of quotes, with different style on the site.

Pullquote is horizontally centered. And from checklist: "Pullquotes must be horizontally centered on IV page if pull quotes exist in the source."

Blockquote is not horizontally centered, and have left border. For example here, at page bottom: https://gazeta.ua/articles/culture/_den-narodzhennya-mashiny-vremeni-top6-hitiv-grupi/774887

I have seen issues like this that is accepted by admin. I don't know, we will be waiting his decision :)
Declined by admin
Duplicate issue. Thanks for the extra info.
Template #7 Issue #1
Jun 14, 2017
Irrelevant and should be removed
Deleted Account
Some of articles have more photos than page contains. This link is need to see page with all photos of article.
For example gallery of this page has 2 photos, not 1 (you can even see count of photos in page title)
Declined by admin
Yes, removing this would lead to loss of essential content.
Template #7 Issue #2
Jun 14, 2017
There's a gallery on this page and it has no previews to pull images from. It only could be opened with JS and images are loaded dynamically via API

Some of the galleries have previews and are usable (but not this one and similar to it):
https://gazeta.ua/articles/science-life/_sotni-ogolenih-balerin-sfotografuvalisya-v-centri-nyujorka/778252
Deleted Account
There is only one photo on the page (there is no second image), but there are 2 photos in full gallery. Gallery of article and full gallery may contains different count of photos, I don't why, but it is. So in IV I insert special link to full gallery.

If you check your link in my template, you will see slideshow in IV with all images that the page contains, so it works fine.
Declined by admin
This is acceptable.
Template #5 Issue #3
Jun 14, 2017
There's a gallery on this page and it has no previews to pull images from. It only could be opened with JS and images are loaded dynamically via API

Some of the galleries have previews and are usable (but not this one and similar to it):
https://gazeta.ua/articles/science-life/_sotni-ogolenih-balerin-sfotografuvalisya-v-centri-nyujorka/778252
Accepted by admin
Indeed, missing some content.
Template #7 Issue #4
Jun 16, 2017
Some galleries have more photos than existing previews to pull from.
For example - this page has 4 photos, but it's only possible to pull 3 images.


TO ADMINS:
There's no way of load all of them, but I want to clarify this:

What should be done in such cases? Should we mark such galleries as @unsupported or it's better to create a link with photos number to open it in browser?

Now it's unclear and different admins treat it differently:
ACCEPTED: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/gazeta.ua/template5/issue3/
DECLINED: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/gazeta.ua/template7/issue2/
Declined by admin
To clarify, all essential content must be accessible, otherwise an IV should not be generated. So if a photo is missing, then some essential content would not be accessible.

However, if a link to the full gallery is included, then the essential content would still be accessible. So that is a reasonable solution.
Template #12 Issue #1
Jun 19, 2017
blockquote or pullquote is expected
ilya
Agree, but your template handles it in the exact same way as mine does
Accepted by admin
ilya
Yeah, like I mentioned in response, this is a valid issue, but template #7 doesn't solves this either - so if it was accepted it should be done to both templates, but it makes no sense

As for the other issues - please take the weight and count of the issues into consideration - for example, Issue #3 of Template #7 is a follow-up to this issue: https://goo.gl/Hk5HNm - admins suggested a valid solution and I provided it.

Anyway, doesn't really matters how it ends for this site - the whole competition was much more fun than I intentionally thought, so thanks to your team for this experience)
Accepted by admin
This does not change the status of this issue. And eventually pending issues will be reviewed, thank you.

We're glad you had fun, good luck!
Template #13 Issue #1
Jun 19, 2017
blockquote or pullquote is expected
Deleted Account
good point, but you didn't done it either
Accepted by admin
Template #12 Issue #2
Jun 19, 2017
part of caption is missing, there is copyright (You can see it if you open gallery on original page)
ilya
Any type of copyright is not an essential content - its usually advisable to remove all of it

And btw as was reported your template has much serious issues :)
Accepted by admin
Any captions present in the source article must be preserved.
Template #13 Issue #2
Jun 19, 2017
part of caption is missing, there is copyright also (You can see this if you open gallery on original page)
Deleted Account
This info is irrelevant
Accepted by admin
Any captions present in the source article must be preserved.
Template #13 Issue #3
Jun 19, 2017
Page must contain a link that lends to gallery, there are not all photos on the page (full gallery has 15 photos, but page contains only 6 photos)
Accepted by admin
Template #7 Issue #8
Jun 22, 2017
Accepted by admin
Template #18 Issue #1
Feb 4, 2019
/
Declined by admin
Template #18 Issue #2
Feb 4, 2019
Missing slideshow and video from youtube
Accepted by admin
IV page is missing essential content
Template #20 Issue #1
Feb 4, 2019
quotes are represented as quotes
Accepted by admin
Template #21 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
the image is missed
Declined by admin
Template #21 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
copyright info is redimentary
Ostap ꑭ
It's required, because article isn't property of this site
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #1
Feb 6, 2019
No real author name
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #2
Feb 6, 2019
Quote is represented as paragraph
Accepted by admin
Template #22 Issue #3
Feb 6, 2019
Video is missing.
Accepted by admin
Template #22 Issue #4
Feb 6, 2019
The category is represented as part of an article
Accepted by admin
Template #22 Issue #5
Feb 6, 2019
The image is missing - the link is shown instead
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #6
Feb 6, 2019
The blockquote is not represented
Accepted by admin
Template #21 Issue #3
Feb 6, 2019
The "join" button is unnecessary
Ostap ꑭ
You are wrong
Declined by admin
Template #21 Issue #4
Feb 6, 2019
The "join" button repeats here too
Declined by admin
Template #21 Issue #5
Feb 6, 2019
The link to the image is unnecessary. Shouldn't such link either load the image or just do not appear at all?
Declined by admin
Template #21 Issue #6
Feb 6, 2019
The "join" button appears for the "blog articles" too.
Ostap ꑭ
Read about IV before submitting issue
Declined by admin
Template #21 Issue #7
Feb 7, 2019
Photos are set differently .. In the article, the content of the text is associated with photography .. The sequence of the photos must be done as shown in the article.
Ostap ꑭ
I agree. Cover could be omitted, but used figure can be used as a cover.
Also, rules describe it as 'optional', so it can be used
Accepted by admin
Template #21 Issue #8
Feb 7, 2019
Should be in <related>
Ostap ꑭ
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-2-related-articles

'they are identifiable in the source'
But it isn't, it's simply paragraph
Declined by admin
Template #25 Issue #1
Feb 7, 2019
Should be a gallery
Accepted by admin
Template #25 Issue #2
Feb 7, 2019
IV should be generated
Accepted by admin
Template #25 Issue #3
Feb 7, 2019
this page must be generated
Accepted by admin
Template #30 Issue #2
Feb 7, 2019
Each photo from slideshow contains additional figcaption. Add them would be more informative for the user. Look my template
Accepted by admin
Retaining captions in slideshows is required.
Template #25 Issue #4
Feb 7, 2019
No Instant View available
Accepted by admin
Template #30 Issue #4
Feb 7, 2019
wrong time
Declined by admin
IV site preview uses UTC.
Template #32 Issue #1
Feb 7, 2019
blockquote is essential part of article
Yury
dynamically created paragraph. does not apply to this article
Accepted by admin
Template #32 Issue #2
Feb 8, 2019
Wrap in bold at least
Accepted by admin
Template #32 Issue #3
Feb 8, 2019
it's essential, blockquote will be fine
Accepted by admin
Template #35 Issue #1
Feb 8, 2019
wrong time
Ostap ꑭ
Time is correct.

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-2-date-and-time

<meta> has datePublished property
Accepted by admin
If conflicting dates are stored in multiple places on the source page, preference should be given to the time that is visible to the ordinary user who views the page in a browser.
Template #42 Issue #1
Feb 9, 2019
Wrong time.

If conflicting dates are stored in multiple places on the source page, preference should be given to the time that is visible to the ordinary user who views the page in a browser.
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-2-date-and-time
Accepted by admin
Template #45 Issue #1
Feb 10, 2019
Skipped image captions
Accepted by admin
Template #46 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
problem with timezone
Vladislav
Its UTC date published. Time is correct
Declined by admin
Template #45 Issue #2
Feb 11, 2019
page have ad block in end page
Declined by admin
Template #49 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
Timezone is uncorrect. Shoud be 20:25 by UTC.
Look
<meta property="article:published_time" content="2019-02-08T22:37:11+0200">
Yury
My template: http://prntscr.com/mjnfl9
Your template: http://prntscr.com/mjnfya
What are the issues? I take the date the user sees
Declined by admin
Handling of timezone is optional and up to the template creator.
Template #48 Issue #1
Feb 12, 2019
This page should not generate IV, and unsupported embed must be marked as @unsupported
Declined by admin
Template #49 Issue #2
Feb 12, 2019
This page should not generate IV, and unsupported embed must be marked as @unsupported
Yury
Perhaps in the future the item will be supported, then my template will work for this page and yours will not. Both are not working at the moment. I don't see much difference.
Declined by admin
The author properly handles this case.
Template #52 Issue #1
Feb 13, 2019
Wrong author
Accepted by admin
The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #49 Issue #3
Feb 13, 2019
This is not an author but a link to another site
Yury
In this place on all pages is the name of the author of the article. If a site is indicated on this place, then the article is taken from this site.
(But this is an exception to the rules. There are very few such pages)
Accepted by admin
The link to the original article is definitely not an author. The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #48 Issue #2
Feb 13, 2019
This is not an author but a link to another site
Accepted by admin
Template #49 Issue #4
Feb 14, 2019
Wrong author, look: https://clip2net.com/s/3ZOqXqm
Yury
This is not the author. This is the site editor. The user should not see his name.
Accepted by admin
Template #48 Issue #3
Feb 14, 2019
Wrong author, look: https://clip2net.com/s/3ZOqXqm
Declined by admin
The author name is optional in this case: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-1-author-name
Template #52 Issue #4
Feb 14, 2019
No Instant View available
Accepted by admin
The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #55 Issue #1
Feb 15, 2019
Declined by admin
Using <iframe> would be perfect but @unsupported is also acceptable.
Template #52 Issue #5
Feb 15, 2019
There is no video. Find a way to download a video, or do not generate a page.
Accepted by admin
Kindly mark any unsupported essential content using the @unsupported function: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-2-video-audio-from-unsupported-players
Template #56 Issue #1
Feb 16, 2019
In original page this text isn't have . You added their own content!
Yury
Slideshows are required only if the source article shows several photos or other media as a slideshow or gallery. If this is the case, do the following:
- Present all images in the IV as a gallery, if possible.
- If that's not possible, keep a link to the full gallery.
- If none of the above is possible, generate no IV for the page.
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-3-galleries-and-slideshows

The original slideshow page has 9 photos. I implemented the page in accordance with the rules.
Declined by admin
Template #56 Issue #2
Feb 18, 2019
Missing top caption for image
Accepted by admin
Template #56 Issue #3
Feb 18, 2019
IV should be generated
Accepted by admin
Template #60 Issue #1
Feb 18, 2019
Wrong date. Original page has date is 03.02.2010, but IV displayed is 02.02.2010
Accepted by admin
Reporter's template handles the case better.
Template #61 Issue #1
Feb 18, 2019
This page should be processed, embed need convert to iframe
Yury
No. This can affect other <embed>tags. Now the page does not work for both of us, I do not see the difference.

https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/gazeta.ua/template49/issue2/
Declined by admin
Template #60 Issue #3
Feb 18, 2019
Inappropriate image quality, there is better quality image in article.
"6.2.1 Image quality
When several image resolutions are available, the IV page should use better quality images."
Accepted by admin
Reporter's template handles the case better.
Template #61 Issue #2
Feb 18, 2019
Inappropriate image quality, there is better quality image in article.
"6.2.1 Image quality
When several image resolutions are available, the IV page should use better quality images."
Accepted by admin
Template #68 Issue #1
Feb 20, 2019
Wrong author. See other templates.

https://clip2net.com/s/3ZXaPY5
Yury
We will not accept issues based on absence of author names for articles in which no author can be easily identified by a regular viewing user.

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-1-author-name
Declined by admin
Template #68 Issue #2
Feb 21, 2019
Page may be generate IV, this page has not a unsupported elements. My template fully supports similar pages
Yury
I will answer with a quote from a similar question :

"An outdated article from 2013, when Flash was over HTML5. Now no one will share the yt video as <object> because it is the old-old-old method and YT uses <iframe> as the default sharing method."

https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/politsovet.ru/template17/issue3/
Declined by admin
Template #68 Issue #3
Feb 22, 2019
image credit must be inside cite tag :
"Фото: Думская"
Yury
http://prntscr.com/mom6r7

All text in the <figcaption > tag. I do not think that it is necessary to process such exceptions. You're just nitpicking. :)
Declined by admin
Not identifiable
Template #71 Issue #1
Feb 22, 2019
image credit must be inside cite tag :
"Фото: Думская"
Vladislav
This is figcaption and everything is fine here.
Look original site
Declined by admin
Template #68 Issue #4
Feb 22, 2019
There is no video. Find a way to download a video, or do not generate a page.
Yury
IV does not automatically generate a page for this video. Especially for such cases there is a block "after". No need to install @unsupported on everything.
Declined by admin
Template #71 Issue #2
Feb 22, 2019
There is unsupported video on this page. Find a way to download a video, or do not generate a page.
Vladislav
It is optional
Declined by admin
Template #68 Issue #5
Aug 9, 2019
Нет выделений разделов, хотя могли бы быть
Declined by admin