Processed Issues11

This page shows a list of issues for hackncast.org that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Issue #1
Jun 10, 2017
missing figcaption
Accepted by admin
Accepted by admin
Template #2 Issue #1
Jun 10, 2017
missing figcaption
Accepted by admin
Template #3 Issue #1
Jun 11, 2017
Code blocks should be wrapped in <code>
‌‌ ‌‌Nikita Balakirev
on this page code blocks marked my black background
it's not what you selected
Accepted by admin
Template #3 Issue #2
Jun 12, 2017
There are three authors: Magnun, Ricardo and Jorge Flávio. Just one is shown.
‌‌ ‌‌Nikita Balakirev
got it from meta tag
Declined by admin
We decided that this should be optional in this case.

Main point:
1. It's a podcast, so listing participants is less critical: podcasts usually start with the participants announcing themselves, so if you listen, you won't miss this content (by contrast, in a regular text article with multiple authors, if you list only one, the reader will have no chance of knowing there were others).

Secondary points:
2. They are not listed as actual names, only photos/links without as much as a header saying 'in this podcast', so a casual reader wouldn't probably even notice.
3. One author is present in the meta tags.
4. Listing more than three-four-five people in the author field doesn't look very nice in mobile IVs anyway.
Template #4 Issue #1
Jun 12, 2017
There are three authors: Magnun, Ricardo and Jorge Flávio. Just one is shown.
☄️
No. I've considered this and concluded that's not the case.
Look: the author is specified right above this block in the so-called byline: "terça, 09 de agosto de 2016 às 00:42, em Programação"

And these are person participating in the episode, not necessary authors.
You wouldn't add a respondent to the author name of a interview article, for example.
Declined by admin
Yes, this is optional.

Main point:
1. It's a podcast, so listing participants is less critical: podcasts usually start with the participants announcing themselves, so if you listen, you won't miss this content (by contrast, in a regular text article with multiple authors, if you list only one, the reader will have no chance of knowing there were others).

Secondary points:
2. They are not listed as actual names, only photos/links without as much as a header saying 'in this podcast', so a casual reader wouldn't probably even notice.
3. One author is present in the meta tags.
4. Listing more than three-four-five people in the author field doesn't look very nice in mobile IVs anyway.

___
In addition to the above, the template creator makes another good argument:
People participating in a podcast episode are not necessarily authors — same as a person who was interviewed in an article is not its author.
Template #4 Issue #2
Jun 12, 2017
Re: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/hackncast.org/template4/issue1/

Oops, the author is not specified in the byline. It's specified in meta.
Still, the statement about participants not being an authors of a publication holds.
☄️
P.S. Too bad we can't edit a response or leave more comments for a constructive discussion.
Declined by admin
Yes, we also find it rather complicated to have (and decipher) meaningful conversations in this interface. Maybe a future revision of the system will make this easier.
Template #4 Issue #3
Jun 12, 2017
In a written article, all contributors are considered authors, right? Well, why not to be the same with the contributors of podcasts too?

If you check https://hackncast.org/devs you'll notice that Ricardo is a contributor like any other. Not host, moderator or something like that. I believe it's a discrimination to mention only him and ignore the other four.

Indeed, in meta tags of the site, only the first contributor is mentioned. Maybe it's just a bug or limitation of their web site. But it's more important what the user see on the page, rather than what is in meta tags. The contributors are clearly listed on the top of the page.

Sorry for the duplicate, I just wanted to give you my point regarding the previous issue.
☄️
We probably need a clarification from moderators.
Your reasoning makes some sense. But at the same time this site has a special semantically correct place for the author, ant it always contains valid information, and it's not the same for every publication.

We can see Ricardo here
And Magnun there: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/hackncast.org/template4/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fhackncast.org%2Fv12-a-culpa-e-das-estrelas

I thinks they are some kind of a host after all.
Declined by admin
Difficult case indeed. We decided this should be optional here.

Main argument:
1. It's a podcast, so listing participants is less critical: podcasts usually start with the participants announcing themselves, so if you listen, you won't miss this content (by contrast, in a regular text article with multiple authors, if you list only one, the reader will have no chance of knowing there were others).

Secondary arguments:
2. They are not listed as actual names, only photos/links without as much as a header saying 'in this podcast', so a casual reader wouldn't probably even notice.
3. One author is present in the meta tags.
4. Listing more than three-four-five people in the author field doesn't look very nice in mobile IVs anyway.
Template #4 Issue #4
Jun 17, 2017
article structure broken - all text in one parapgraph
Accepted by admin
Template #6 Issue #1
Jun 17, 2017
page structure broken
Accepted by admin
Formatting must be preserved.
Template #7 Issue #3
Jun 18, 2017
This was a 3-level nested list. The structure is broken. It can be supported, but not like this. See my template.
Accepted by admin
Nested lists should be marked as @unsupported.
Template #8 Issue #1
Jun 19, 2017
This should be an aside.
☄️
This is not a pullquote.
Declined by admin