Preview
Issue #1
Not an article. This is SEO article with index of other articles.
- Deleted Account
- Are you sure? Are you examined the URL and also the full content properly in bahasa?
This page is article which published on "Berita (news)" section or category. This also fall into "Isu Hangat (current issue)" subcategory.
The index page (subcategory) for that article is:
https://www.hukumonline.com/berita/isuhangat
When this response was written, this article still on the first page of that index page.
The index page for main category itself is in url:
https://www.hukumonline.com/berita
From that main category page, you can input "21 September 2018" as search parameter and you will notice that this article will show then.
FYI, Online media in Indonesia often make this kind of news (summaries) by linking other news links in their publications. Clearly this is article that you must support in IV.
- Declined by admin
- Accepted by admin
- "Liputan khusus" means "special coverage". Links are in<div id="terbaru">. "Terbaru" means "the latest". Normally articles on this site have <div @itemprop="articleBody"> as a body. This one doesn't. It seems this page is just a list of thematically related articles. So it shouldn't generate IV
- Deleted Account
- <div id="terbaru"> doesn't mean the latest on this context. This is "static" content that never change. You can compare similar page version from the first time it is published until now.
Compare (with):
1. https://www.hukumonline.com/berita/baca/lt559a6b15a530a/kasus-engeline
2. https://web.archive.org/web/20180630060848/http://www.hukumonline.com/berita/baca/lt559a6b15a530a/kasus-engeline
Author manually add relevant links at that time to this article (not dynamic).
If you mention about @itemprop="articleBody", this page also doesn't has that:
https://www.hukumonline.com/berita/bacafoto/lt5c544d6a940f2/kpk-perpanjang-masa-penahanan-taufik-kurniawan
If you said that this page like a list of thematically related articles, then it can presented as IV and we can wrap that links under <related> block, right? This case, can we identified this article as "single-image" article with related articles block (or presented as is) since this page HAS published_date and author? Index usually didn't have date-author.
- Accepted by admin
- The page shouldn't have IV, since it's not an article, it's list of articles.
- Type of issue
- IV generated for non-target page
- Reported
- Feb 18, 2019