Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues16

This page shows a list of issues for idevice.ro that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #2 Andrii Babenko	Issue #1 May 22, 2017	Anton not working Andrii Babenko Template is correct. All used tags and classes are on this page. Accepted by admin If you've updated your template since submitting it, you will need to resubmit your template for the updates to show.
Template #2 Andrii Babenko	Issue #2 May 22, 2017	Anton no link to the author Andrii Babenko All text content and images are present Declined by admin Author links are optional: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-author-link
Template #5 Elian Doran	Issue #1 Jun 5, 2017	Serhii author link missed Elian Doran Checklist §6.2: "Author links are optional. [...] We will not be accepting issues based on the availability of author links. The only exception is when the author link is pointing to an inappropriate page." (https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-author-link) Declined by admin Author links are optional.
Template #5 Elian Doran	Issue #2 Jun 7, 2017	Anton The author installed not quite right. It is possible to obtain a link to a particular author and formating, leaving only the name. In this case: zaonero Accepted by admin If the author name is unknown, it's better not to display an author than to show a URL.
Template #6 Anton	Issue #1 Jun 13, 2017	Elian Doran Might I ask from where you obtained the author name? Opening the original webpage's source code and searching for "zaonero" reveals only the following data: a) The "article:publisher" meta property, but publisher is not author. If you used this property, I believe it's incorrect to do so. b) The "twitter:site" meta property, which again cannot be used for author. c) Two social links, one Facebook and one Instagram, none of which are useful. d) It was hard-coded by the template author, which is always bad. Declined by admin It is possible to omit the author in cases where no name can be seen by a regular user opening the original article in the browser. It is possible to omit the name when there‘s no identifiable person, only the website’s ‘team’, ‘editors’, etc. Indeed the author looks very strange. If you find another page where it's more obvious that it's the wrong author, kindly resubmit the issue.
Template #6 Anton	Issue #2 Jun 17, 2017	Elian Doran Author is actually "zaone", as mentioned directly in the article's visible content. Oddly enough, the author isn't shown on mobile resolutions, but on desktop it can be clearly seen. Please open the page in a web browser (or see proof at http://i.imgur.com/vDVHP5g.png ). Accepted by admin What the user sees when viewing the original article in an ordinary browser has priority over invisible meta-information.
Template #7 Elian Doran	Issue #1 Jun 17, 2017	admin This is the wrong author name. You even mentioned it in your issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/idevice.ro/template6/issue2/ Elian Doran The author cannot be visibly obtained, as it is not mentioned anywhere on some versions of mobile. The IV only gets the mobile version. The competitor used the article:publisher meta tag, whereas I use the correct article:author meta tag. Referring to https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/idevice.ro/template6/issue2/ , that was different, because the author "zaonero" was obtained through article:publisher, which isn't correct. Declined by admin This is a site bug. There is no real author put into the meta tags. No way for the template creator to find out.
Template #7 Elian Doran	Issue #2 Jun 18, 2017	Anton You left the issue for my template - https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/idevice.ro/template6/issue2/ Where indicated that the in FULL version of site, the author differs from the one that I display, But we do not work with the full version. We work with the fact that the IV-editor loads, And there is no author in the visible part of, so that it must be extracted from the meta-information (That's what you do). Therefore, I hope that the administration would reconsider its decision. And also, I think that you are displaying author is incorrect. Yes, the field is called 'article: author', but it always leads to a group site in Facebook, The actual author is placed in the 'article: publisher' field. My English is not very good, but I hope you understand what I mean. Elian Doran Thanks for reporting. You are quite right, it seems that the website provides a mobile version of it on some of the pages, in which the author is not displayed. Firstly, the publisher is not the author! The publisher meta is used to describe the entire entity administrating the website, in this case it coincides partially with the writer, but it cannot always be so. Semantically speaking, this is completely incorrect. Secondly, the author displayed here coincides with the website, meaning that there should be no problem with it being present. Thirdly, `article:author` does not lead to a group site in Facebook, it leads to the website's official page. Interestingly enough, Facebook marks the page as being "Author": http://i.imgur.com/JRcZi8W.png -- quite fitting for my plead, is it not? Declined by admin Duplicate issue #1 on this template.
Template #7 Elian Doran	Issue #3 Jun 18, 2017	Anton Image duplicated Accepted by admin
Template #7 Elian Doran	Issue #4 Jun 18, 2017	Anton This is slideshow and images can be increased Accepted by admin Low res images must always be reworked. The reporter's template did this quite good.
Template #8 Yuri	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	Anton Images can be enlarged Yuri They can, but should they? Give me a rule that say it. Accepted by admin Template #12 handles the case better.
Template #7 Elian Doran	Issue #5 Jun 18, 2017	Anton This is slideshow Declined by admin This is no slideshow in the source.
Template #8 Yuri	Issue #4 Jun 18, 2017	Anton Missing author (in this case, it is meta information) Yuri There is no meta tags with author, which are specified in the desktop version of the original. Accepted by admin The author is seen on the source.
Template #12 Anton	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	Elian Doran An image that is way down and has relevance in its context has been set as cover image. Accepted by admin A cover image should not duplicate an image from the article.
Template #8 Yuri	Issue #6 Jun 18, 2017	Elian Doran Checklist §4: "Anything that is not essential to the article in question should be removed from the Instant View page. Advertisements removed". Yuri There is no clear way to detect ads like this one. Are you really want to remove it from every single page by unique method? Accepted by admin
Template #13 Elian Doran	Issue #1 Jul 16, 2017	admin Pages are not being generated Declined by admin It appears that the layout of the website was changed after the template was submitted. Since the template would have won the contest, had our admins been able to sort through all the issues immediately after the contest was closed, we will decline this issue. We kindly ask you to support the new layout after the winners are announced.