Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues43

This page shows a list of issues for indosport.com that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #2 Deleted Account	Issue #1 Feb 5, 2019	Bambang Catur Pamungkas additional image lacks media caption Accepted by admin
Template #3 Bambang Catur Pamungkas	Issue #3 Feb 5, 2019	shab photo gallery with could be parsed Accepted by admin
Template #4 shab	Issue #1 Feb 6, 2019	Елена Бурлакова Rudimentary content not removed shab these are related articles. also they are very essential for this kind of posts, because this site tends to split text between multiple pages Accepted by admin In this case it's technically possible to generate IV for both pages using inline function
Template #4 shab	Issue #2 Feb 6, 2019	Елена Бурлакова gallery shab EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used: When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content. Declined by admin
Template #4 shab	Issue #3 Feb 8, 2019	Deleted Account Wrong author. This article is not written by Coro Mountana (editor). "Penulis" means writer or author in Indonesia. Declined by admin This author can't be identified as an author (looks like a simple text in the source code)
Template #7 Alex Schneider	Issue #1 Feb 9, 2019	Darkcomet Lost bold subtitle Alex Schneider I agree that this is a valid issue, but I wouldn't consider it critical. Accepted by admin
Template #11 Houssen Moshinaly	Issue #1 Feb 10, 2019	Dima Missing caption Accepted by admin The caption is missing.
Template #11 Houssen Moshinaly	Issue #2 Feb 10, 2019	Yx video is missed Accepted by admin The YouTube video is missing.
Template #11 Houssen Moshinaly	Issue #3 Feb 10, 2019	Yx Remove it or add to figcaption Accepted by admin Captions are missing.
Template #7 Alex Schneider	Issue #2 Feb 10, 2019	Yx Wrong title Accepted by admin
Template #15 Alex Schneider	Issue #1 Feb 11, 2019	Yx It should be removed or added as related Alex Schneider These are links to the different parts (pages, basically) of the same article, each part on its own URL. They are essential for the reader to see that there are multiple pages and navigate between them. I've considered a few ways of dealing with them. - Inline the parts using iframes and @inline Not only does this seem unnecessarily difficult, but also silly. Since each part has its own URL, after inlining them, IVs for all the parts would be identical. Users would share a link to a certain part and then get an IV for the whole article. - Format them as related links This is how it was made in the previous version of my template, but then I realized there are a couple of issues with this, too. 1. I'm not sure how related links are displayed by IVs, but I think it won't be clear to the reader which link leads to which part. 2. Some of the parts may contain unsupported content preventing the IV to be generated. According to a note in Checklist, "If pages have no IV, they will not be displayed.". It means th Declined by admin This seems to be a reasonable way to handle the source page's pagination. Since the article is split into 2 pages, the contents of the pages must be accessible in the IV. They cannot be simply removed. Also, converting these links into <related> blocks is not necessarily a good idea, because if a related link doesn't generate an IV link, the link won't show at all. Plus, <related> links show up as similar to link previews (name of article, desc, image preview), which can be quite different than how pagination looks. This can become confusing to a reader.
Template #15 Alex Schneider	Issue #2 Feb 13, 2019	shab this type of articles splitted into multiple parts can be inlined properly. check this issue https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/indosport.com/template4/issue1/ Alex Schneider These are parts (pages, basically) of the same article, each on its own URL. The links are static. I've considered a few ways of dealing with them. - Inline Since each part has its own URL, after inlining them, IVs for all the parts would be identical. Imagine a user who wants to share a video on the 5th part and gets an IV for the whole article. This is just weird and unexpected. - Format as <related> 1. I'm not sure how related links are displayed by IVs, but I think it won't be clear to the reader which link leads to which part. 2. Some of the parts may contain unsupported content preventing the IV to be generated. In such a case no link will be shown to that part. - Keep them in the body This way the experience for the reader will be identical in IV and on the actual website. I decided to do it this way and add clear captions ("Daftar Isi" means "Table of Contents", "Bagian" means "Part"). Accepted by admin
Template #18 Yx	Issue #1 Feb 13, 2019	shab this type of articles splitted into multiple parts can be inlined properly. check this issue https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/indosport.com/template4/issue1/ Accepted by admin Handling pagination through <related> is not a good idea. The <related> blocks will not always show, for instance, if related links do not generate IV. Related links also display as link previews (article name, desc, image preview), which is quite different than how pagination looks.
Template #22 Deleted Account	Issue #1 Feb 13, 2019	shab this type of articles splitted into multiple parts can be inlined properly. check this issue https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/indosport.com/template4/issue1/ Deleted Account For this problem, I found that three Telegram arbitrer or admin (in other site contests) made different resolutions for this. Admin in the contest of this site teds to recommends using @inline (and tagged the other resolutions wrong), other suggestions using the <related> block, and others say that multi-page navigation is better to leave as is. So, if Telegram itself does not have an "official way" for this problem, is this issue still worth debating? Accepted by admin Handling pagination through <related> is not a good idea either way though. The <related> blocks will not always show, for instance, if related links do not generate IV. Related links also display as link previews (article name, desc, image preview), which is quite different than how pagination looks.
Template #24 Houssen Moshinaly	Issue #1 Feb 13, 2019	shab this type of articles splitted into multiple parts can be inlined properly. check this issue https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/indosport.com/template4/issue1/ Accepted by admin The content of the second page is not accessible here at all. This means essential content is missing from the IV.
Template #24 Houssen Moshinaly	Issue #2 Feb 13, 2019	Yx Sorry, but It's still not figcaption https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/indosport.com/template11/issue3/ Map all dives with images, change div into figure, div with img-source class into cite. If this figure have neighbour with caption append it to figure changing tag to figcaption Accepted by admin
Template #24 Houssen Moshinaly	Issue #3 Feb 13, 2019	shab caption is missing. this image has both <figcaption> and <cite> Accepted by admin
Template #28 shab	Issue #1 Feb 13, 2019	Deleted Account Author name doublicated shab it is a plain text. different patterns are used for this kind of author mentions. check this issue https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/indosport.com/template4/issue3/ Declined by admin
Template #15 Alex Schneider	Issue #3 Feb 14, 2019	Deleted Account I believe image credit for image on article body must combined into caption like page cover (which this template handled very well). Accepted by admin
Template #28 shab	Issue #2 Feb 15, 2019	Yx No figcaption Accepted by admin
Template #29 Deleted Account	Issue #1 Feb 16, 2019	Alex Schneider The image is missing the link and credits. Accepted by admin
Template #33 Alex Schneider	Issue #1 Feb 16, 2019	Yx IV not generated for static pages from block "TEMPAT OLAHRAGA" it contains content about sport centers Alex Schneider Those aren't periodic posts. Generating IVs for them is not required. Accepted by admin
Template #35 Yx	Issue #1 Feb 18, 2019	Alex Not sure, but it seems to me that it is important to leave this part Yx I decided to use @inline to join all pages into one. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/indosport.com/template4/issue1/ Maybe there're some methods to improve this decision, because i don't think it's perfect Declined by admin it's okay to use this function.
Template #35 Yx	Issue #3 Feb 19, 2019	F wairbar is not removed Accepted by admin
Template #35 Yx	Issue #4 Feb 19, 2019	F this page has dynamic contet Accepted by admin Dynamic. content
Template #36 Alex Schneider	Issue #1 Feb 20, 2019	F Social media links is not removed. Alex Schneider In this case the social media links are contacts of the gym. They are essential to the page and I believe they should be preserved. Declined by admin
Template #36 Alex Schneider	Issue #2 Feb 20, 2019	F multi page websites can implement using inline method. Alex Schneider https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/indosport.com/template15/issue1/ Accepted by admin That report was about pagination formatting. I accept the issue, since the Template #40 (by F) displays all article pages in one IV. It's better than pagination. Alex Schneider Can you please elaborate on why inlining is better? I agree that it would be better for the site to have whole articles on a single page, but they made a different decision. In the original, different parts of an article are each on their own web page, with distinct URLs. For the user, there is no "whole article" page, just separate parts. If we inline them, all the parts will generate identical IVs. Imagine that someone wants to share a video on the 5th page, but gets an IV for the whole article. That's just weird and totally unexpected for the user. "You wanted a banana but what you got was a gorilla holding the banana and the entire jungle." If we keep pagination in the body, though, there is no problem at all. That's how it's made on the website. The user experience with IV is the same as with the original, they get what they expect. Accepted by admin - If we inline them, all the parts will generate identical IVs It's not critical
Template #36 Alex Schneider	Issue #3 Feb 20, 2019	F IV for this page doesn't implemented correctly Alex Schneider There is no problem on template's side. The tweet has been deleted. Declined by admin
Template #36 Alex Schneider	Issue #4 Feb 20, 2019	F IV for this page doesn't implemented correctly Alex Schneider Duplicate Declined by admin
Template #36 Alex Schneider	Issue #5 Feb 20, 2019	F the cover image is not 1st image in the list Alex Schneider "Several images appear in the article one after another. In this case, the template should not break the sequence by extracting one of them as a cover" Declined by admin
Template #43 Mehmet Akif Şahin	Issue #1 Feb 23, 2019	F IV not generated for this page Mehmet Akif Şahin its not a article page Accepted by admin
Template #44 Diyor	Issue #1 Feb 23, 2019	F IV not generated for this page Accepted by admin
Template #44 Diyor	Issue #2 Feb 23, 2019	F Related article section is nit implemented Declined by admin
Template #44 Diyor	Issue #3 Feb 23, 2019	F missing image caption Accepted by admin
Template #45 F	Issue #1 Feb 26, 2019	Alex Schneider The title should be identical to what is seen by the user. Accepted by admin
Template #46 Alex Schneider	Issue #1 Feb 26, 2019	F embedded post is not loaded. my template can do it Alex Schneider This is an embed of a deleted tweet. Your template doesn't load the embed. It simply shows the text as a paragraph, which is a wrong way to do it. My template, on the other hand, properly embeds the tweet and also keeps the text inside as a fallback. How to display it is up to Telegram. Declined by admin
Template #46 Alex Schneider	Issue #2 Feb 27, 2019	Mehmet Akif Şahin SITENAME IS WRONG. THIS SHOULD BE JUST INDOSPORT Alex Schneider They refer to themselves as INDOSPORT.com: <meta property="og:site_name" content="INDOSPORT.com" /> Accepted by admin
Template #49 Mehmet Akif Şahin	Issue #1 Mar 1, 2019	Diyor media abl writen twice Accepted by admin
Template #50 Diyor	Issue #1 Mar 4, 2019	Alex Schneider This is an eligible page. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/indosport.com/template33/issue1/ Accepted by admin
Template #46 Alex Schneider	Issue #3 Mar 4, 2019	admin The credit text is incorrect. The Instagram account name is cut. The text is affected by email protection by mistake and it seems the template removes protected emails at all. Protected emails should be preserved, since they might be fixed by the IV parser in the future. Accepted by admin
Template #48 F	Issue #2 Mar 4, 2019	admin Missing author Accepted by admin F this site have author in many pages and have editor in some of them. I thought that EDITOR is mot author. anyway, I will correct it and submit another template based your opinion. Accepted by admin Editor as a person who published the post can be considered as an author.
Template #51 F	Issue #1 Mar 7, 2019	Alex Schneider The image is missing the link and credits. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/indosport.com/template29/issue1/ Accepted by admin
Template #52 Alex Schneider	Issue #1 Mar 8, 2019	F figure caption should be present in "figcaption" format. Alex Schneider These captions aren't formatted in any meaningful way to extract them: <span style="font-size:11px"><em>McGregor tengah bersama sang istri, Dee Devlin.</em></span> Declined by admin

Processed Issues43

Log In