Preview
Issue #4
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/intraday.my/template161/issue1/
- valid
- https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-1-author-name
My template works as described. There is no visible author mentioned on this page, therefor it gets article:author from meta tags. It's not requied, but also not prohibited to do so in this case.
- Accepted by admin
- In reality, this entire page should not generate IV - it's useless and also contains Cloudflare-protected [emails]
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-2-pages-that-require-significant-interaction
- valid
- I'm confused about admin decisions. The previous similar issues have been declined, making clear that service pages are optional. Please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/intraday.my/template58/issue1/
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/intraday.my/template63/issue3/
Also this have been said: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/intraday.my/template155/issue4/
Now here's a specific page which generates - I see that it's useless, but it's not a problem at all, it has only static content anyway. Making it IV-less would require custom logic, which you say isn't expected, the point is to support usual pages the better - but appearently it's an issue. So in cases when IV doesn't generate for target pages it's acceptable, but now it's an issue that it generates for a page that has nothing that a target page couldn't have. (Emails are Cloudflare-protected on every page they have emails on, it doesn't mean IV shouldn't generate.)
And my otherwise perfect template gets rejected because of it.
- Accepted by admin
- Hey
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/intraday.my/template58/issue1/
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/intraday.my/template63/issue3/
were rejected because the Issue creators were saying that the contact page should not be supported at all - as if it was against the rules to do so. This is of course not the case so the issues were rejected.
However, this issue indicates that the generated IV for this page, is malformed - which is correct because the email on this page is protected by Cloudflare. Therefore the one piece on information which is useful here (it provides a way to get in contact with the site owner) is lost and cannot be supported, this makes the IV useless in comparison to the original page.
So, as it is not possible to extract this email, and it is essential content for this page, the issue is valid.
Hopefully we will publish some concrete guidance on how to handle pages with protected emails soon, or bypass the Cloudflare protection...but for now this page should not gene
- Declined by admin
- Hey
Another update for you, we now bypass the Cloudflare protections on our side - as I mentioned we may investigate in my last message
So, this issue is no longer valid, and this page becomes optional to support
Many thanks for your comments here - they were very useful
- Type of issue
- Author added their own content
- Reported
- Feb 12, 2019