Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues36

This page shows a list of issues for k-tai.watch.impress.co.jp that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Сергей Герасимов	Issue #1 Jun 5, 2017	Антон Цуварев Author face not removed. Accepted by admin
Template #3 Сергей Герасимов	Issue #1 Jul 25, 2017	admin Two images are missing. Accepted by admin This issue was created as part of our final checks on the winning templates (see https://instantview.telegram.org/rules#identifying-winners). If you think this issue was accepted as the result of an error, you still have time to submit an appeal. Thank you very much for taking the time and effort to participate in our contest! Results are coming soon.
Template #2 Антон Цуварев	Issue #1 Jul 25, 2017	admin Two images are missing. Accepted by admin This issue was created as part of our final checks on the winning templates (see https://instantview.telegram.org/rules#identifying-winners). If you think this issue was accepted as the result of an error, you still have time to submit an appeal. Thank you very much for taking the time and effort to participate in our contest! Results are coming soon.
Template #7 Deleted Account	Issue #1 Feb 6, 2019	smailzhu 🐸 the mark seems need to be header but not blockquote Accepted by admin
Template #7 Deleted Account	Issue #2 Feb 6, 2019	smailzhu 🐸 It's needs an instant view page Accepted by admin
Template #13 Антон Цуварев	Issue #1 Feb 9, 2019	Alex Should be slideshow Accepted by admin Slideshows are required if the source article shows several photos or other media as a slideshow or gallery. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-3-galleries-and-slideshows Антон Цуварев In this template without slideshow - issue, but in template 17-18- not? https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/k-tai.watch.impress.co.jp/template17/issue1/ https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/k-tai.watch.impress.co.jp/template18/issue1/ Declined by admin
Template #16 smailzhu 🐸	Issue #1 Feb 12, 2019	Антон Цуварев Hi. Photo missing. smailzhu 🐸 it's as same as original page which telegram provide https://imgur.com/4QASbaN Accepted by admin The IV is missing the extra photos. Anton's template shows that it's possible to support these photos in IV. smailzhu 🐸 So I need to show the photo which not shown in original page which telegram provide? Accepted by admin Yes, an IV must display all essential content, otherwise an IV should not be generated. Even with what the IV format provides though, it's possible to support these photos, which is demonstrated by Anton's template.
Template #17 Gi	Issue #1 Feb 12, 2019	Антон Цуварев Slideshows are required if the source article shows several photos or other media as a slideshow or gallery. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-3-galleries-and-slideshows Gi Rules also state that > If there are several ordinary images/videos/GIFs following each other in the source, you may also convert them into a slideshow, but this is purely optional. and > We will not accept issues based on presence or absence of slideshows for ordinary images following each other in the source article. Which is the case here. There is no slideshow in the original article. And these images serve as additional content. While looking potentially nice too, a slideshow remains optional here. Declined by admin This case seems optional. The source page does not seem to necessarily be displaying the photos as slideshows. So IV displaying the photos as slideshow or not seems optional.
Template #18 Alex	Issue #1 Feb 12, 2019	Антон Цуварев Slideshows are required if the source article shows several photos or other media as a slideshow or gallery. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-3-galleries-and-slideshows Alex Slideshows are required here because this content is shown in a slideshow on the original site https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/fakty.com.ua/template20/issue1/ ===> There is no slideshowes on the original site p.s. Anton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slide_show Declined by admin
Template #16 smailzhu 🐸	Issue #2 Feb 12, 2019	Антон Цуварев Missing image. smailzhu 🐸 it's as same as original page which telegram provide Accepted by admin Yes many photos are missing. If an IV cannot display all essential content, then an IV should not be generated. However, Anton's template shows that this page can be supported.
Template #17 Gi	Issue #2 Feb 13, 2019	Антон Цуварев Wrong author. Accepted by admin
Template #17 Gi	Issue #3 Feb 13, 2019	Антон Цуварев [みんなのケータイ] - it is not in the original title. Accepted by admin
Template #17 Gi	Issue #4 Feb 13, 2019	Alex Missed subtitle Declined by admin
Template #23 Антон Цуварев	Issue #1 Feb 13, 2019	Alex MIssed subtitle Антон Цуварев I don't see subtitles. Declined by admin
Template #23 Антон Цуварев	Issue #2 Feb 14, 2019	smailzhu 🐸 missing some related artical Accepted by admin
Template #25 Gi	Issue #1 Feb 14, 2019	smailzhu 🐸 the title for this related article seems wrong Gi 「ケータイの形態学展－ The morphology of mobile phones －」? What's wrong with it ? It's the label this outer link is given in the original article. Accepted by admin Text from <a> shouldn't be parsed as related header
Template #23 Антон Цуварев	Issue #3 Feb 15, 2019	心当たりのない The parenthesis in the author name should be removed Declined by admin
Template #26 Sean Wei	Issue #1 Feb 17, 2019	admin it's possible to extract bigger images. See: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/k-tai.watch.impress.co.jp/template23/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fk-tai.watch.impress.co.jp%2Fdocs%2Fnews%2F1071602.html Accepted by admin Sean Wei Okay, thanks Accepted by admin
Template #27 Alex	Issue #1 Feb 17, 2019	admin It's possible to extract bigger images. See: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/k-tai.watch.impress.co.jp/template23/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fk-tai.watch.impress.co.jp%2Fdocs%2Fnews%2F1071602.html Accepted by admin
Template #28 Sean Wei	Issue #1 Feb 20, 2019	Антон Цуварев 1 photo missing. Accepted by admin Indeed, one is missing.
Template #30 Gi	Issue #1 Feb 20, 2019	Антон Цуварев Related articles. Gi 1) These are not "rudimentary content" they're external links in relation with the content of the article (press release, official website of the product / event, etc). As such they are an integral part of the article and should be included, not removed 2) They're not related _articles_, but related _links_. They all link to external webpages which aren't articles (and as such would have no IV), and they should always appear as they're part of the article (not some other article on a related but different subject). Declined by admin
Template #30 Gi	Issue #2 Feb 20, 2019	Антон Цуварев It shouldn't be here. Gi It's in the original article. It's an external link to the specific product introduced in the article (although it doesn't exist anymore on the target website as it's an old article / product). This is no advertisement. It is an integral part of the original article and as such should be part of the IV as well. Declined by admin There's no collapsible block in the article Accepted by admin There's no collapsible block in the article Gi Do you confirm the link _should_ be included in the IV ? (just not in a collapsible block) Accepted by admin It's acceptable to leave the link.
Template #30 Gi	Issue #3 Feb 20, 2019	Антон Цуварев Image with category name not deleted. Gi This is a _cover_. As per the rules: "It is obligatory to use a cover image: - If the image is present on the page and described in the source as “featured-img”, “cover”, “lead_img”, “main_image”, etc. - When the article has a cover on the source website (above the title or subtitle)." This image: - is described in the source as "hdg-image" - is right above the title and so its use as a cover is obligatory according to the rules. Declined by admin
Template #33 Антон Цуварев	Issue #1 Feb 20, 2019	Gi Text "2017年2月「SHINKTAI concept」" from source missing in IV. Accepted by admin
Template #34 Alex	Issue #1 Feb 22, 2019	Gi Uses thumbnails while it's possible to use bigger resolution images. As previously reported in the following accepted issues: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/k-tai.watch.impress.co.jp/template27/issue1/ and https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/k-tai.watch.impress.co.jp/template26/issue1/ . Accepted by admin
Template #35 smailzhu 🐸	Issue #1 Feb 22, 2019	Gi One picture ("au design project" window front) is missing. Accepted by admin
Template #37 Gi	Issue #1 Feb 24, 2019	Антон Цуварев Link preview photo missing. Accepted by admin Gi Thumbnail for link preview must be shown if a suitable image exists in the source. What makes this image suitable for link preview ? There's no cover nor image in meta tags on this page. Is any image from the article suitable as link preview image ? Accepted by admin First image from the body can be used as a link preview image
Template #39 Alex	Issue #1 Feb 26, 2019	Gi Related articles ("関連記事" section in the source) are missing from the IV. Accepted by admin Alex On this site, it's optional, because it's not related, it's articles of theme look equal issues: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/benchmark.rs/template7/issue2/ Accepted by admin
Template #47 Gi	Issue #1 Feb 27, 2019	Антон Цуварев Static article. Should be IV. Accepted by admin
Template #48 Alex	Issue #1 Mar 1, 2019	is summer missing iv Declined by admin Article from 2010
Template #48 Alex	Issue #2 Mar 1, 2019	Sergey The images can be obtained. They are not obtained because you deleted "_s"(at the end of the image) from the image source. Accepted by admin
Template #48 Alex	Issue #4 Mar 1, 2019	Sergey Should be obtained higher resolution. The way to obtain it: First, you should check the higher level is there a tag <a>, if it is then check the @href. If it exists then check if the href has and "/img/" part. Then replace ".html" to "" and "/html" to "" and you will get an image in higher resolution. Example of this image in higher resolution https://k-tai.watch.impress.co.jp/img/ktw/docs/1163/500/01_o.jpg Or just replace "_s.jpg" to "_o.jpg" :D, but it's not a safe method Accepted by admin
Template #53 Gi	Issue #1 Mar 2, 2019	Антон Цуварев Needs IV. Accepted by admin
Template #59 Gi	Issue #1 Mar 6, 2019	Антон Цуварев Photo caption missing. In original 2 photos have one caption. Gi All captions from the source are present in the IV : no content is missing. All captions appear below the images they refer to, like in the source. They are just presented horizontally in the source, vertically in the IV. In this case, I think it's the better way to present captions in the IV: if we duplicate the same caption under each image, it would add content and be further away from the original look in the source (where they appear only once), and the reader would have to read several times the same caption (in some articles the captions are very long). Note, anyway, that there is only one caption in the source. Accepted by admin The images must be wrapped in <slideshow> with a caption Gi Because the caption spans over 2 images ? The problem is that it is impossible to reliably identify how many images these captions apply to on all articles of this website. See this article for example : https://k-tai.watch.impress.co.jp/docs/column/stapa/682327.html . We could make several 2-image slideshows one after the other for the cat images, but look at the table with 9 pigeon images down the article : the caption reads "I tried to cut the flight of a bird in 9 pictures" (translated), so the caption clearly applies to the 9 pictures above it. However there is nothing in the source which allows to identify this. Other templates which do as you recommend here end up showing the 6 first pigeon pictures individually and then a slideshow with a caption which essentially reads "9 bird pictures" but with only the 3 last pictures in it. The source doesn't allow to distinguish this case with the case where the caption actually only applies to the last 3 images of the table (sometimes the case on other pages). Accepted by admin
Template #60 Alex	Issue #1 Mar 6, 2019	Антон Цуварев It is possible to extract normal size images. Accepted by admin
Template #62 Антон Цуварев	Issue #1 Mar 12, 2019	Gi Static recent article : should have an IV. Accepted by admin

Processed Issues36

Log In