The 2019 Instant View contest is over. View results
The Instant View Editor uses a three-column layout, so you really want to use it on a desktop screen that's wide enough. Sorry for the inconvenience.

Back to the main page »



Link Preview

Issue #1

Not correct video src, video can be supported, simple html5
This page has two videos. One's missing in your template.
Declined by admin
Second video is also missing in your template.
Accepted by admin
We are sorry for the confusion. The second video is unrelated to the article and can be removed.
Declined by admin
Thank you for the very detailed investigation here:

It appears that this is indeed a one-off case that could be ignored. This template generates proper IVs for all the other videos that we've checked.
Declined by admin
Correction: 'one-off' is not the right way of describing the situation with these videos. Please accept our apologies.

Indeed, as Yuri noted in an appeal (, pages that use a different URL structure for videos do appear infrequently, e.g.:

At the same time, this issue is not common. We have checked ~40 of the latest videos posted on and none of them use the short link format. While template #5 indeed generates slightly more IVs due to support for these cases, not supporting those few specific pages is a Grade 7 issue (doesn't cause any damage to the end user, see

At the same time, template #7 has a minor Grade 5 issue on some pages (also not critical):
Declined by admin
Sorry, got cut off:

This issue also doesn't appear consistently across all articles and is not serious enough, so we will not reject any of the templates, but the order remains.
Type of issue
IV not generated for target page
Jun 18, 2017 at 9:27 PM