Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues20

This page shows a list of issues for newatlas.com that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Enes	Issue #1 Feb 5, 2019	Yedidya Laufer Missing image caption. Accepted by admin
Template #2 Diyor	Issue #1 Feb 6, 2019	Enes IV should be generated for this page Declined by admin The page contains unsupported Kickstarter video
Template #2 Diyor	Issue #2 Feb 6, 2019	Enes Images, Author and Date are missing Accepted by admin
Template #3 Enes	Issue #1 Feb 7, 2019	Edoardo Image at the end of the page not removed. Also cover's caption is missing. Enes Image at the end is a slideshow from the article's gallery. Each article has gallery and sometimes consists of several images, sometimes only single image. For the second problem: Cover images are included in the galleries which also includes the captions, I've done this to remove duplicates. Accepted by admin
Template #3 Enes	Issue #2 Feb 8, 2019	dotvhs Links are not parsed Accepted by admin
Template #5 Enes	Issue #1 Feb 8, 2019	dotvhs Source not linked as related. Enes It's not a related article. Its literally the source of the article, and Source link rules have their own section (Check 6.3.4), and it doesn't mention anything about considering it as a "RelatedArticle" Declined by admin
Template #5 Enes	Issue #2 Feb 8, 2019	Falko Section 6.2.2: The cover must not be set if the cover image is duplicated in the article. Enes The image below is actually a slideshow, sometimes it consists of multiple images and sometimes only single image depending on the page. Note that in the source, the cover image is always included in the gallery. Accepted by admin Since the image may be a part of a slideshow and it's not identified as a cover, it's better to not set it as a cover at all.
Template #6 dotvhs	Issue #1 Feb 8, 2019	Falko Although not visible in the page, the date of pblication is extractable from the source of the site and according to 6.1.2 it is obligatory to include. Accepted by admin
Template #7 Falko	Issue #1 Feb 9, 2019	Mostafa Memariani images in article are missing Falko They are not actually missing, they are part of the slideshow. I agree that this is kind of problematic though, since there is the dilemma of either having a) Duplicate images, or b) Images appearing in the slideshow but not the article body. I want to wait for an admins opinion on this before I change anything, since the other templates as of now have the same problem. Accepted by admin This slideshow is improperly generated. The images should be at the same places as they are in the original article
Template #8 Diyor	Issue #2 Feb 11, 2019	Елена Бурлакова all pictures are lost Accepted by admin Indeed.
Template #9 Enes	Issue #1 Feb 11, 2019	Falko Images missing from IV. Accepted by admin Falko did it better in his template.
Template #12 Diyor	Issue #1 Feb 12, 2019	Falko Image not included Accepted by admin
Template #13 Enes	Issue #1 Feb 13, 2019	Falko Cover image missing. Checklist 6.2.2 specifies the following: "It is obligatory to use a cover image: If the image is present on the page and described in the source as “featured-img”, “cover”, “lead_img”, “main_image”, etc. When the article has a cover on the source website (above the title or subtitle)." In this case, the image is clearly a cover image and is described in the source as "hero_image", so it falls in the above category and must be set as a cover. Enes Section 6.2.2: The cover must not be set if the cover image is duplicated in the article The image you highlighted is always included in the gallery of each page (Unless there is a single image in the entire article). In other words, cover image should not be set. Declined by admin
Template #13 Enes	Issue #2 Feb 14, 2019	Falko Sorry to make this a duplicate, I wish one could reply to/edit issues. You are right that cover images should not be set if they are duplicated in the article - and they are duplicated in cases where there is a gallery on the page. However, in pages with only a single image (as in this one), the image is clearly not duplicated in the article and has the class "hero_image" in the source, so it is obligatory to set it as cover image in these cases. Absence of gallery can be detected by looking for the "View Gallery" button that is always present on gallery-pages, and cover image can then be conditionally (@if blockfunction) set based on that. Enes According to the rules you are right. Its easy to set but I left it this way intentionally. Because for this particular website, this will make the pages inconsistent. "Pages with single image have cover while others don't" doesn't seem to be right. Declined by admin
Template #15 Falko	Issue #1 Feb 15, 2019	Deleted Account Essential part (gallery) is missed Falko No, it is there, just at the end of the article. The four images you selected always appear when there is a gallery associated with the page and serve as a preview of images in the gallery. Evidence for this: Class name is "gallery_preview", and it never gets discussed in the article text (probably dynamically inserted). If included, images would be duplicated because they also appear in the gallery at the end. Declined by admin
Template #13 Enes	Issue #3 Feb 17, 2019	admin It's not a kicker Accepted by admin
Template #15 Falko	Issue #2 Feb 17, 2019	admin It's not a kicker Accepted by admin
Template #18 Enes	Issue #1 Feb 17, 2019	Falko Incorrect author link: The link should either be set to the correct page, as in the source (https://newatlas.com/author/michael-irving/) or not set at all. Right now, it's just linking to a low-res icon of the author. Accepted by admin
Template #20 Enes	Issue #1 Feb 17, 2019	Falko Don't know why the editor has a malfunctioning preview of the page, but this is a static article page which should be supported (see same link in my template) Enes I have no idea, But its working properly in the editor but not here? The code isn't changed, lets see admin's response and fix to this issue but its not related to my template since its working fine in my editor. Declined by admin Yes, this doesn't seem to be an issue with the template itself. If you manually reload this source page URL in Template #20, it will generate an IV.
Template #20 Enes	Issue #2 Feb 18, 2019	Falko Image cropped and low-quality, instead full image should be used like this: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/newatlas.com/template21/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fnewatlas.com%2Fgo%2F6790%2F (Btw, I agree about the previous issue [https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/newatlas.com/template20/issue1/], it should be declined. Just reloading the URL without the issue's cached preview you can see that it works fine, it must have been a temporary bug that wasn't your fault.) Enes Agree but this is what is displayed in the article. Declined by admin Since that's how the image is displayed in the original article, it's not critical

Processed Issues20

Log In