Processed Issues52

This page shows a list of issues for ng72.ru that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Issue #1
Feb 4, 2019
This page in 'Afisha' is a static article and needs an Instant View
Accepted by admin
Template #3 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Journalist's name is irrelevant for an online newspaper. In addition, there is no jounalist's name on the website.
Nikita
No, there is a section with the author & publication date right below the article. It's clearly visible so it's ok to show it. (Also, you are making online journalists sad :)
Declined by admin
3.1 of General properties: author name can be shown on the IV page if an author is specified in the source (author is specified on the original page).
Template #13 Issue #1
Feb 7, 2019
This line just restates the date, first part is always the same
Declined by admin
it's a part of the article text, it can't be identified and be removed without endangering essential content
Template #11 Issue #1
Feb 7, 2019
IV is not generated
Nikita
This is a really old article. 2015! A news item! Format has changed since then. Anything current works
Accepted by admin
Template #13 Issue #2
Feb 8, 2019
Age restriction is not part of the content
Accepted by admin
Template #15 Issue #1
Feb 8, 2019
These are the most recent items with the same topic (accidents). Most recent list is dynamic and must not be used https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-2-related-articles
Accepted by admin
Indeed, the list of related articles is dynamic and the issue is valid: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-2-related-articles
Template #22 Issue #1
Feb 9, 2019
Instant View is not being loaded on this page.
Nikita
Embed not supported. You need to provide working implementation
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #2
Feb 9, 2019
Nikita
Hard to reliably tell this is a cite, and not just figcaption
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #3
Feb 9, 2019
Missing paragraph from original article.
Nikita
It is not part of the text - it is the same on all pages. Date is already seen where expected
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #4
Feb 10, 2019
Missing caption
Nikita
That's not a caption, just an age restriction. Not part of the content
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #5
Feb 11, 2019
Videos' captions are not marked up as captions
Nikita
Not possible to do reliably with what we have - just an <em> tag
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #6
Feb 11, 2019
this URL needs an Instant View page
Nikita
That's a forum thread (with no responses), no an article, if I understand correctly
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #7
Feb 12, 2019
IV not generated for a target page
Accepted by admin
Template #32 Issue #1
Feb 14, 2019
"761" in title not removed.
Accepted by admin
Template #31 Issue #1
Feb 14, 2019
Not part of the text
Egor Danilin
I think it is
Accepted by admin
Template #35 Issue #1
Feb 14, 2019
Caption is missing (age requirement).
Nikita
It's not a caption - it references article in general, not an image. Also, looking at code: <div class="Cens">16+</div> this is a special element (that is not supported by IV), not a caption
Declined by admin
Template #35 Issue #2
Feb 15, 2019
Blog page. IV must be generated.
Nikita
This is an entry on a forum (see http://live.ng72.ru/live/), not an article. This example does not have any responses, but generally IV cannot support this.
Declined by admin
Template #31 Issue #2
Feb 15, 2019
Blog page. IV must be generated.
Egor Danilin
> https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-1-pages-with-dynamic-content
- Forum threads

This url is forum's page
Declined by admin
Template #35 Issue #3
Feb 15, 2019
The video at the bottom of the page does not work.
Nikita
I don't know, docs say vk video is supported... Do I need to modify something about iframe?
Declined by admin
Not the template's issue and will be fixed soon on the IV side
Template #31 Issue #3
Feb 15, 2019
The video at the bottom of the page does not work.
Declined by admin
No the template's issue and will be fixed soon on IV side
Template #35 Issue #4
Feb 17, 2019
The video at the bottom of the page does not work. My past issue was rejected with the following wording: "Not the template's issue and will be fixed soon on the IV side". Issue was rejected even though I provided a working version in my template (https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/ng72.ru/template36/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fng72.ru%2Fnews%2Fview%2F01-12-2018-idi-ty-v-studiyu-chto-modno-v-novom-fitnes-sezone). Even if this issue is rejected, then the item "UNSUPPORTED CONTENT" (https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#unsupported-content) takes effect. According to him for this page IV should not be generated as the page contains unsupported content (although in my opinion this is not the case and the working template was provided).
Nikita
(Dupe https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/ng72.ru/template35/issue3/)

Look, the iframe is there, src is set correctly, if you open this iframe in new tab it will load. Like they said, it will be fixed on IV side
Declined by admin
As already explained in the issue 3, this is a Telegram issue and will be fixed in the future. It is perfectly fine to leave the embed and NOT unsupport it!

This is a Telegram issue!

Also it looks exactly the same on your template: https://imgur.com/a/KqO8shY
Template #35 Issue #5
Feb 17, 2019
IV must be generated. A working example has been provided for similar pages. Past issue was rejected. But. The content on the page has a typical structure for a news blog similar to that presented on the main domain, as well as the title, date and author. This page is not dynamic. Its content is not updated in real time. Yes, this section in the original is called a forum, but in my opinion the content cannot be attributed to the item "2.1. Pages with dynamic content" (https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-1-pages-with-dynamic-content ). I would like to hear the comments of the administrator about the feasibility of generating or not generating IV for such pages and the corresponding grounds for this.
Nikita
(dupe https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/ng72.ru/template35/issue2/ )

Check out this page for example: http://live.ng72.ru/live/view/288 it generates IV in your template, but it's clearly missing essential content - responses to a forum thread (not a blog post!)
Declined by admin
Comments/user blog posts are definetly not the target for IV. IV should not generate for these kind of pages.
Template #35 Issue #6
Feb 17, 2019
Caption is missing (age requirement). Past issue was rejected. Age requirements (16+) - part of the content contained in the original article and directly related to its main content. If possible, I would like to hear admin comments about this issue. Based on what checklist criteria the desribed content (16+) may be treated as nonessentional and can be removed.
Nikita
Dupe https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/ng72.ru/template35/issue1/

Not a caption! Also, not part of the content: it's present on every page, no matter how little sense it makes (http://ng72.ru/news/view/28-01-2019-epoha-uhodit-v-istoriyu-gotovimsya-k-perehodu-na-cifrovoe-televidenie), and is therefore notf related to the content
Declined by admin
Duplicate of https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/ng72.ru/template35/issue1/
Template #35 Issue #7
Feb 17, 2019
IV is missing article's author
Nikita
According to Rule 6.1.1
"It is possible to omit the name when there‘s no identifiable person, only the website’s ‘team’, ‘editors’, etc."
Here = "Administrator"

Also, please note that even slightly more recent articles (with actual authors) have different formatting (e.g. http://ng72.ru/afisha/view/15 from December 2014)
Declined by admin
Template #35 Issue #8
Feb 17, 2019
Author is missing.
Nikita
Dupe https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/ng72.ru/template35/issue7/
Declined by admin
Template #38 Issue #1
Feb 17, 2019
The video at the end of the page does not work. In my template provided a working version.
Egor Danilin
duplicate https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/ng72.ru/template31/issue3/
Declined by admin
Template #38 Issue #2
Feb 17, 2019
Rudimentary content not removed.
Egor Danilin
duplicate https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/ng72.ru/template13/issue1/
Declined by admin
Template #35 Issue #9
Feb 17, 2019
Not formatted as blockquote.
Nikita
These shouldn't be formatted as blockquotes, because they contain attribution inline (" – отметили в МЧС."), that cannot be identified and put in <cite>. Italics is preserved.
Accepted by admin
Since the text can be identified as a quote (p class="TextQuot"), it should be formatted as blockquote in the IV. It's acceptable that "– отметили в МЧС." text won't be a cite
Nikita
In other cases, quotes are placed correctly inside <blochquote> element. See http://ng72.ru/news/view/25-09-2018-tyumenskaya-studentka-rasskazala-o-svoem-uchastii-v-goloy-vecherinke

This class denotes only formatting that is preserved, not semantics. Also, this is not what blockquotes are intended for - it is expected that the whole content of the block is, well, a quote.

Please reconsider!
Accepted by admin
Template #37 Issue #1
Feb 17, 2019
Missing caption
Declined by admin
It's not a caption, but a lead.
Template #37 Issue #2
Feb 19, 2019
> https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-1-pages-with-dynamic-content
- Forum threads

This url is forum's page, so IV must not be generated
Deleted Account
Forum threads is an example of a pages with dynamic content (2.1. Pages with dynamic content). This is NOT a page with dynamic content and not suitable for this criterion. This publication does not contain any dynamically loadable content on the page.
Declined by admin
Template #37 Issue #3
Feb 19, 2019
This is related articles, need format, look my template
Declined by admin
Not identifiable
Template #38 Issue #3
Feb 19, 2019
This is related articles, need format, look my template
Declined by admin
Not identifiable
Template #39 Issue #1
Feb 19, 2019
This is related articles, need format, look my template
Declined by admin
Not identifiable
Template #37 Issue #4
Feb 19, 2019
Service page should not generate IV
Declined by admin
It's optional
Template #38 Issue #4
Feb 19, 2019
IV slould be generated
Declined by admin
Would need to see a template that can fully support this page to consider an issue like this.

Issue creator's template misses many of the photos from this source page.
Template #46 Issue #1
Feb 19, 2019
Many photos are missing from this IV.
Accepted by admin
Template #37 Issue #5
Feb 20, 2019
Photos at the end of article are missing
Accepted by admin
Template #47 Issue #1
Feb 20, 2019
This paragraph is not part of the content: it just denotes category and is the same on all pages. Issue has been rejected before because author claimed it could not be safely identified.

In reality, it always follows <div class="C15"> + starts with "Новости Тюмени и Тюменской области". That is enough to safely identify it. Both other templates do it.
Egor Danilin
admin has already declined such type of issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/ng72.ru/template13/issue1/

I agree with admin that there is not enough reliable information to identify and delete this header
Declined by admin
Template #47 Issue #2
Feb 20, 2019
Missing vk post (https://c2n.me/3ZWrvrm), see my template that can fully support this page
Egor Danilin
Source HTML only contains div for vk post and script to load it:
<div id="vk_post_-48512305_1838721">&#13;</div><script>...</script>

So, vk post is not embedded in proper way and is loaded by script, so it can not be shown in IV
Accepted by admin
The post is an essential part of the article. Would be better to keep it. The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #48 Issue #1
Feb 20, 2019
Missing vk post (https://c2n.me/3ZWrvrm), see my template that can fully support this page
Accepted by admin
The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #49 Issue #1
Feb 20, 2019
Missing vk post (https://c2n.me/3ZWrvrm), see my template that can fully support this page
Accepted by admin
The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #56 Issue #1
Feb 24, 2019
It must either be removed or transferred to the caption of the photo
chuchu
This is not a caption
Accepted by admin
Template #56 Issue #2
Feb 26, 2019
wrong author
Accepted by admin
Template #58 Issue #1
Feb 26, 2019
Redumentary content should be removed or transfer to figcaption of cover image, look original site
chuchu
Not valid issue
Accepted by admin
Template #58 Issue #2
Feb 26, 2019
Wrong cover (with white strips), look my template , and original site
chuchu
Not valid issue
Accepted by admin
Template #58 Issue #3
Feb 26, 2019
Missing caption for image
Accepted by admin
Template #59 Issue #1
Feb 26, 2019
This is not caption
Vladislav
This is a caption, look original site - https://clip2net.com/s/403YZs6
Accepted by admin
Not a caption indeed.
Vladislav
Admin, and what is this, part of the content? Or rudimentary content?
Accepted by admin
16+ is a rudimentary content.
Template #59 Issue #2
Feb 26, 2019
Vladislav
My image is the same as on the original site, but your image is other (with missing watermark, contains unnecessary white strips and missing top figcaption)

https://telegra.ph/Originalno-original-cover-image-on-ng72ru-02-26
Declined by admin
Template #60 Issue #1
Feb 27, 2019
chuchu
In telegram cover looks almost the same as in source. And usually it is high res version. Also this image opens over click on cover so you are missing content.
Declined by admin
Duplicate
Template #62 Issue #1
Feb 27, 2019
Missing formating for subheader
Accepted by admin
Template #65 Issue #1
Mar 2, 2019
Missing captions
chuchu
Not identifiable
Declined by admin
Template #65 Issue #2
Mar 2, 2019
Missing figcaption. It's easy to identify. Look my template, it has the better decides .
chuchu
Anyway it's always different. There is no markup for caption.
I will consider this issue valid if you provide at least 2 links where image and caption structure are the same. For now I didn't find any articles with alike img+caption structure
Declined by admin