Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues45

This page shows a list of issues for odpublic.net that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #3 Sergiy Moskalenko	Issue #1 Feb 5, 2019	AV No publication date and author for articles, that were published "today" Accepted by admin
Template #3 Sergiy Moskalenko	Issue #2 Feb 5, 2019	AV No slideshow, which is present on the original Sergiy Moskalenko The original article doesn't have any slideshows. I believe that in this case using slideshow element is optional. Accepted by admin
Template #4 Sergiy Moskalenko	Issue #1 Feb 6, 2019	Dzmitry Radkevich unwanted content Sergiy Moskalenko According to Checklist "‘Read more’ blocks that feature links to other articles on the same site are the best candidates for" RelatedArticles element. Declined by admin
Template #5 Dzmitry Radkevich	Issue #1 Feb 6, 2019	Sergiy Moskalenko Photos from the original article are missed. Accepted by admin
Template #8 AV	Issue #1 Feb 7, 2019	Sergiy Moskalenko Information about the sources of the photos is missed. Accepted by admin
Template #5 Dzmitry Radkevich	Issue #2 Feb 7, 2019	AV No publication date Accepted by admin
Template #5 Dzmitry Radkevich	Issue #3 Feb 7, 2019	AV Link preview does not contain the site name Accepted by admin
Template #16 AV	Issue #1 Feb 9, 2019	Sergiy Moskalenko Event page is static and IV must be generated for it. The only dynamic content on the page is the word "Today", which is displayed for today's events, and can be easily replaced with a date (as in my template). AV The "Events" section items seems to be relevant only until certain point of time (usually 1-2 weeks ahead), which is assumed to fall into "dynamic" category Declined by admin
Template #16 AV	Issue #2 Feb 10, 2019	igo http://odpublic.net/videos/eksgibitsionist-pugaet-zhiteley AV A page containing nothing but single video does not seem to require an iv Declined by admin
Template #16 AV	Issue #3 Feb 10, 2019	igo There is a title, date & video content. What's wrong with it, why didn't you made IV for that? Declined by admin
Template #16 AV	Issue #4 Feb 10, 2019	igo This must be modified to h1 header & hr must be removed. AV This is just a <p> on the website with no special attributes or other markings that would allow to destinguish them, so if it is modified, all <p>'s will be modified as h1, which does not make sense. Anyway, the original is presented the same way, why it should be modified? Declined by admin
Template #16 AV	Issue #5 Feb 10, 2019	Kirill S There is a lack of IV Accepted by admin
Template #16 AV	Issue #6 Feb 10, 2019	Kirill S IV is not generated correctly Accepted by admin
Template #16 AV	Issue #7 Feb 10, 2019	Kirill S Cover is missing AV Cover images are not supposed to be created if they are repeated in the article Declined by admin
Template #18 Kirill S	Issue #2 Feb 10, 2019	AV The article contains 6 pictures, but there are only 5 in the slideshow. This is because in the template the first picture in the article is always taken as a cover Kirill S It's done on purporse to not duplicate content. Accepted by admin The chosen image is clearly inappropriate for the cover.
Template #19 AV	Issue #1 Feb 10, 2019	Sergiy Moskalenko Event page is static and IV must be generated for it. The only dynamic content on the page is the word "Today", which is displayed for today's events, and can be easily replaced with a date (as in my template). AV This section of the website mostly does not contain even a description of an event and the articles are relevant only in short-term perspective, so the section seems to fall into category of pages which do not require iv Declined by admin
Template #19 AV	Issue #2 Feb 13, 2019	Kirill S That element appears on several pages, for example: https://odpublic.net/news/2013/08/06/voennye-igry-v-pamyat-o-pobede http://odpublic.net/news/2013/08/21/zhivaya-shaurma-na-odesskih-ulitsah It should be removed. AV It exists in the source, iv should not correct the site mistakes Declined by admin
Template #19 AV	Issue #3 Feb 13, 2019	Kirill S href attribute was removed for no reason Declined by admin Declined by admin Accepted by admin
Template #19 AV	Issue #4 Feb 13, 2019	Kirill S Those design elements are not essential to the article and should be removed Accepted by admin
Template #19 AV	Issue #5 Feb 13, 2019	Sergiy Moskalenko Information about sources is missing in slideshow. Accepted by admin
Template #20 Sergiy Moskalenko	Issue #1 Feb 13, 2019	AV cover image is repeated in the article Sergiy Moskalenko This website provides cover image separately. Sometimes this image (but with a different URL) is present in the article body. (as in this case) Sometimes the article has no images, but has a cover. (http://odpublic.net/news/2019/02/07/yanukovich-ne-znaet-845378) Sometimes the article contains images, but the cover does not match any of them. (http://odpublic.net/articles/2015/04/15/kriminalnaya-odessa) There is no way to distinguish between these cases. That's why image in the article body was left untouched. Accepted by admin There's an issue because the template extracts the cover from //head//link[@rel="image_src"], what is a bad idea, since there's no cover in the article.
Template #26 AV	Issue #1 Feb 14, 2019	Kirill S Empty paragraphs have to be removed. Declined by admin
Template #26 AV	Issue #2 Feb 15, 2019	Kirill S Description in Link Previev contains date and time AV This is not date and time of publication, but a date when the described event will take place. This is an event section and date and time there is a leading paragraph, suitable for the role of description of an event. Declined by admin
Template #26 AV	Issue #3 Feb 15, 2019	Kirill S Thumbnail for link preview is missing, according to the checklist it must be shown if a suitable image or document exists in the source. Accepted by admin
Template #31 Kirill S	Issue #1 Feb 15, 2019	AV The date of event is an essential part of "events" section Kirill S The event section as such doesn't belong to the must generate targets, it's not article-like content and therefore optional. Nevertheless, the event's date is not essential content (which is the publication date). Accepted by admin Reporter's template handles the case better.
Template #31 Kirill S	Issue #2 Feb 15, 2019	AV The picture from the gallery was used as a cover, which extracted it from the page content Kirill S According to the checklist the cover must not be set if: "The chosen image is clearly inappropriate for the cover." Photo galleries on that site are thematically. Chosen image related to any other. Accepted by admin The cover must not be set if several images appear in the article one after another: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-2-cover-images
Template #33 AV	Issue #1 Feb 16, 2019	Sergiy Moskalenko Link preview contains HTML character entities ("). Accepted by admin
Template #35 AV	Issue #1 Feb 18, 2019	Kirill S Image captions are missing Accepted by admin
Template #35 AV	Issue #2 Feb 18, 2019	Kirill S Missing subtitle. Declined by admin
Template #36 Sergiy Moskalenko	Issue #1 Feb 18, 2019	Kirill S Missing subtitle Accepted by admin The reporter's template handles this case better. Sergiy Moskalenko This block is not a subtitle. According to 6.1.4 of Checklist: "Even if the lead uses a different style from the rest of the text, it is less desirable to present it as a subtitle" Declined by admin The issue was accepted by mistake.
Template #36 Sergiy Moskalenko	Issue #2 Feb 18, 2019	Kirill S Missing subtitle Accepted by admin The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #36 Sergiy Moskalenko	Issue #3 Feb 18, 2019	AV no picture in link preview: Thumbnail for link preview must be shown if a suitable image or document exists in the source. Accepted by admin The reporter's template handles this case better. Sergiy Moskalenko Website provided invalid URL of thumbnail, so it can't be displayed. This is a website issue. Accepted by admin Template must take care of the correct link preview image. In this case it can be extracted from body
Template #36 Sergiy Moskalenko	Issue #4 Feb 18, 2019	AV Service section of website Accepted by admin Sergiy Moskalenko Service areas of websites must not generate IV if they require significant interaction. But this page has no dynamic or interactive elements. 2.2 of Checklist is not about this page. Declined by admin Sorry, this issue was indeed accepted as the result of an error. It's optional to keep pages with no dynamic content.
Template #37 Kirill S	Issue #1 Feb 18, 2019	AV Cover image was taken out from the album Kirill S It is allowed https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/odpublic.net/template31/issue2/ Accepted by admin The cover must not be set if several images appear in the article one after another: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-2-cover-images
Template #41 AV	Issue #1 Feb 19, 2019	Kirill S It's subtitle. Here and across all the site. AV The website does not iddentify subtitles specifically. Making each first //p as a sibtitle may lead to creating a subtitle out of lead paragraph or summary sentence as in this case: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/odpublic.net/template43/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fodpublic.net%2Farticles%2F2014%2F01%2F05%2Fglavnye-sobytiya-2013-goda Checklist: Somewhat more common are short summary sentences that are also shown below the title (and are called standfirst by the British). These summary sentences are usually short and are not part of the article's text. It is advisable but not required to represent them as subtitle elements. Generally, it is advisable to avoid setting too much text as the subtitle. Declined by admin
Template #41 AV	Issue #2 Feb 21, 2019	Kirill S IV is not generated Accepted by admin
Template #46 Sergiy Moskalenko	Issue #1 Feb 24, 2019	Kirill S Link preview image is missing. Sergiy Moskalenko This is website issue. The page provided invalid URL of thumbnail. It is possible to use one of the images from the article body, but then on many pages the thumbnail will not correspond to the one that the author of the article wanted to establish. In fact, the template will change the original article. Moreover, some articles contain a thumbnail that is not presented in the body. If we replace it with an image from the body, then the article will lose some of the content. Accepted by admin Since the site provides incorrect URLs in meta, the template should set the link preview image from body
Template #47 AV	Issue #1 Feb 24, 2019	Kirill S Link preview image is missing. Declined by admin
Template #47 AV	Issue #2 Feb 24, 2019	Kirill S This page contains unsupported video source. Accepted by admin See https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/odpublic.net/template46/issue3
Template #46 Sergiy Moskalenko	Issue #2 Feb 24, 2019	Kirill S Two <hr> in a row Accepted by admin The two <hr> tags are not the issue - it's an issue that the content from in between is simply missing.
Template #46 Sergiy Moskalenko	Issue #3 Feb 24, 2019	Kirill S This page contains unsupported video source. Accepted by admin There is a flash video embedded in the source (flowplayer) which should be unsupported if it can't be worked around.
Template #47 AV	Issue #3 Feb 24, 2019	Kirill S 1. Spoiler is missing. 2. It's not a quote, <blockquote> tag was used as spoiler wrapper. Accepted by admin Although this is an article from 2016 and the source actually uses <blockquote> you might consider fixing this issue as well. This issue was accepted because the template was rejected because of another issue already. Otherwise this might be an one off/edge case.
Template #49 Kirill S	Issue #1 Feb 26, 2019	AV Slideshows must not be used: When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content. Kirill S "When the article consists entirely of a SLIDESHOW (and its CAPTION/DESCRIPTION) and there's no other content." As you can see, the original page is not a slideshow, it's a gallery. And there are no captions at all. Accepted by admin
Template #52 AV	Issue #1 Feb 27, 2019	Sergiy Moskalenko Video is missing. AV It is missing in the source, although it is just a <video> embed with src attribute Declined by admin
Template #52 AV	Issue #2 Feb 27, 2019	Sergiy Moskalenko The site_name is missing for pages, where IV is not generated. Declined by admin

Processed Issues45

Log In