Processed Issues310

This page shows a list of issues for pitchfork.com that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #2 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Image not shown properly
timur brachkow
It is shown properly in mobile and desktop app.
Declined by admin
Template #2 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
Final score missing (really?)
Accepted by admin
Template #3 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Missed cover image
Иван Ветошкин
Don't think it's my fault, not Pitchfork's. Images from the same source and formatted in the same way are present on other checked pages.
Declined by admin
Template #6 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Album image and review mark
Accepted by admin
Essential content - IV is incomplete without this
Template #6 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
incorrect view
Poolitzer X
dublicate of sergys one, but thanks, on it
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template6/issue1/
Template #11 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
link should not be displayed
Anton
I will argue it should (content is missing and it isn't because of the template) so user should be "notified" in some way.
Accepted by admin
An incomplete or "broken-looking" IV is not really acceptable, to the end-user this looks like a malfunction

Note also: Other templates have found graceful ways of getting around this issue, by not including this image, but instead sourcing related ones to use a cover. The result is so much nicer:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template28/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpitchfork.com%2Freviews%2Falbums%2Fdave-harrington-pure-imagination-no-country%2F
Template #13 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
news article with static content
Mehmet Akif Şahin
this page is a review page
but telegram wants from us to news page
so my news pages are completely true
Accepted by admin
The target here is not just news pages, but the main content of the site. Pitchfork has news, reviews, etc.

Other templates have been able to support these different types well, so at this point covering those sections can be considered as essential for the winning template
Template #18 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Link to home shouldn't be displayed.
Accepted by admin
Template #17 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
The selected element shouldn't be displayed.
undefined
duplicate issue
Declined by admin
Template #15 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Author added their own content
Sergey
This is a list of album authors
Accepted by admin
Since this is duplicated in the title, and the linked page will not generate IV it is better to remove this - it is not necessary here
Template #15 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
This element should be displayed as a heading
Sergey
This is a list of album authors with links to their pages
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template15/issue1/
Template #14 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
Tags must be removed; the template does not work for Levels.
Accepted by admin
Template #11 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
Some issue with image, the link should not be visible.
Anton
I think it shouldn't (user will see that an image was here). Also these images "errors" (src is correct) probably will be fixed and will load in the future.
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #17 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
List bullets present in instant view
undefined
I disagree. I placed it there for purpose. I've fixed the broken display though, thanks.
Accepted by admin
Template #6 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
Interacttion elements not removed
Accepted by admin
Template #13 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
It's an article, so it does.
Mehmet Akif Şahin
its article but different style .telegraam wants the news page from us
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #14 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
It's hard to understand what is it
Accepted by admin
Due to this being a review, making it clear that this number is the rating can be considered as essential

Especially as we do not have the benefit of displaying it with the additional styling that the original site uses to make it clear
Template #15 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
A mark is useless here
Sergey
Solved
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #17 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
Marks are useless here
undefined
another duplicate
Declined by admin
Template #18 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
Duplicates the heading
Accepted by admin
Since this information is duplicated in the title, and the linked page will not generate IV it is better to remove this - it is not really necessary here
Template #20 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Hard to understand what is it
Руслан Агишев
on the source site this information is presented in a similar way
Accepted by admin
Due to this being a review, making it clear that this number is the rating can be considered as essential

Especially as we do not have the benefit of displaying it with the additional styling that the original site uses to make it clear
Template #21 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Cover image is missing
Artem Morziev
label images didn't show correct at such category, so I just remove it
Accepted by admin
The album art and the rating can be considered as essential for this site
Template #24 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
It's an article, so it needs an IV.
Accepted by admin
Template #6 Issue #5
Feb 5, 2019
picture description displayed incorrecty
Accepted by admin
Captions shown in original article must be preserved as captions in IV

See: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
Template #6 Issue #6
Feb 5, 2019
headers not properly parsed
Accepted by admin
Template #6 Issue #7
Feb 5, 2019
needs some cleaning
Declined by admin
Not accepting this issue because these controls take the user to other pages, they should not be removed like they are in your template (https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template28/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpitchfork.com%2Ffeatures%2Flists-and-guides%2Fthe-50-best-albums-of-2018%2F)

However, it would be nice to make it more obvious what these numbers actually mean to the end user
Template #6 Issue #8
Feb 5, 2019
cover picture is missing
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template6/issue1/
Template #6 Issue #9
Feb 5, 2019
cover video instead of a picture
Accepted by admin
While it is acceptable to use a Video as the cover image generally, in this exact case it is undesirable as the original website explicitly has the album artwork here

"The cover is missing from an article that has a cover on the source website."
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-2-cover-images
Template #6 Issue #10
Feb 5, 2019
needs some cleaning
Accepted by admin
Template #6 Issue #11
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
The Spotify widget here is non-essential, and can be removed:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-3-auxiliary-widgets
Template #11 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
picture description displayed incorrectly
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #11 Issue #5
Feb 5, 2019
headers not properly parsed
Accepted by admin
Template #11 Issue #6
Feb 5, 2019
needs some cleaning
Declined by admin
Not accepting this issue because these controls take the user to other pages, they should not be removed like they are in your template (https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template28/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpitchfork.com%2Ffeatures%2Flists-and-guides%2Fthe-50-best-albums-of-2018%2F)

However, it would be nice to make it more obvious what these numbers actually mean to the end user
Template #6 Issue #12
Feb 5, 2019
You must make sure that your template only generates IV pages for articles and does not affect service areas of the website, as well as any other sections unsuitable for IV.
Accepted by admin
Please read: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-1-pages-with-dynamic-content
Template #11 Issue #7
Feb 5, 2019
cover picture is missing
Anton
I noticed you have this working. Great job! I would love to know your approach, at the same time I think that my template should also work. I have <figure> with <img> which has src inside (and no errors). I think that's Instant View Issue and my template will work as soon as it is fixed. Thank you in any way, your template is great.
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #11 Issue #8
Feb 5, 2019
cover picture is missing again, but on in different layout
Accepted by admin
Template #11 Issue #9
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
Spotify Widget here is non-essential to this article and can be removed, please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-3-auxiliary-widgets
Template #13 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Mehmet Akif Şahin
if i dont know this , please tell me .telegram wants the news page .this is an features page
Accepted by admin
The target here is not just news pages, but the main content of the site. Pitchfork has news, reviews, etc.

Other templates have been able to support these different types well, so at this point covering those sections can be considered as essential for the winning template
Template #13 Issue #5
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
Template #13 Issue #6
Feb 5, 2019
title pictures are better looking as covers
Declined by admin
This is not displayed as a cover on the original website, so this can be considered a style choice by the template creator
Template #13 Issue #7
Feb 5, 2019
needs come cleaning
Accepted by admin
Template #13 Issue #8
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
Template #13 Issue #9
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #13 Issue #10
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all.....
Accepted by admin
Template #14 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
figcaption is missing
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #26 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Marks are useless and irrelevant here. Also, the subheader duplicates the header
Accepted by admin
Template #14 Issue #5
Feb 5, 2019
descriptions are displayed incorrectly
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #14 Issue #6
Feb 5, 2019
headers not properly parsed
Accepted by admin
Template #14 Issue #7
Feb 5, 2019
needs some cleaning
Declined by admin
Not accepting this issue because these controls take the user to other pages, they should not be removed like they are in your template (https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template28/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpitchfork.com%2Ffeatures%2Flists-and-guides%2Fthe-50-best-albums-of-2018%2F)

However, it would be nice to make it more obvious what these numbers actually mean to the end user
Template #14 Issue #8
Feb 5, 2019
no picture
Accepted by admin
This is essential content
Template #14 Issue #9
Feb 5, 2019
these need to be removed
Accepted by admin
Template #14 Issue #10
Feb 5, 2019
title picture is better looking as a cover
Declined by admin
Since it is not a Cover Image on the original page, this is not essential - it is purely a style choice by the template creator.
Template #14 Issue #11
Feb 5, 2019
picture is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #14 Issue #12
Feb 5, 2019
a total mess with headers
Declined by admin
Duplicate issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template14/issue2/
Template #14 Issue #13
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
Spotify player is non-essential and can be removed as per:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-3-auxiliary-widgets
Template #14 Issue #14
Feb 5, 2019
no picture
Accepted by admin
This is essential content
Template #15 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
title picture is better loking as a cover
Declined by admin
This is not displayed as a cover (in the conventional sense) on the original website, so this can be considered a style choice by the template creator
Template #15 Issue #5
Feb 5, 2019
description is displayed incorrectly
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #15 Issue #6
Feb 5, 2019
description is missing
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #15 Issue #7
Feb 5, 2019
headers not properly parsed
Accepted by admin
Template #15 Issue #8
Feb 5, 2019
needs some cliening
Declined by admin
Not accepting this issue because these controls take the user to other pages, they should not be removed like they are in your template (https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template28/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpitchfork.com%2Ffeatures%2Flists-and-guides%2Fthe-50-best-albums-of-2018%2F)
Template #15 Issue #9
Feb 5, 2019
video embed is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #15 Issue #10
Feb 5, 2019
subtitle is missing
Accepted by admin
This text should be included, it is up to the template creator whether this summary sentence is displayed as a subtitle, or as the first part of the article text

Please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-3-subtitle
Template #15 Issue #11
Feb 5, 2019
picture is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #15 Issue #12
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
Others have shown that it is possible to display this page in IV
Template #15 Issue #13
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue - as you reported before, this template doesn't support such pages generally. Once that has been fixed this page should work fine

Note: the Spotify Widget here is non-essential to this article and can be removed, please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-3-auxiliary-widgets
Template #21 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
album cover and the score are missing
Artem Morziev
label images didn't show correct at such category, so I just remove it
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #26 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
description is displayed incorrectly
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #26 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
the picture should be a cover
Declined by admin
This is not displayed as a cover (in the conventional sense) on the original website, so this can be considered a style choice by the template creator
Template #26 Issue #5
Feb 5, 2019
description is missing
Accepted by admin
This is a really long and annoying credit, but we must keep it

Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #26 Issue #6
Feb 5, 2019
headers not properly parsed
Accepted by admin
Template #26 Issue #7
Feb 5, 2019
a picture is missing
Accepted by admin
This is essential content
Template #26 Issue #8
Feb 5, 2019
picture is missing
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #26 Issue #9
Feb 5, 2019
a little mess with headers
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template26/issue1/
Template #26 Issue #10
Feb 5, 2019
a picture is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #26 Issue #11
Feb 5, 2019
total mess with headers
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #26 Issue #12
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
Spotify Widget is non-essential to this article, please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-3-auxiliary-widgets
Template #26 Issue #13
Feb 5, 2019
picture is missing
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #26 Issue #14
Feb 5, 2019
needs some cleaning
Declined by admin
Not accepting this issue because these controls take the user to other pages, they should not be removed like they are in your template (https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template28/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpitchfork.com%2Ffeatures%2Flists-and-guides%2Fthe-50-best-albums-of-2018%2F)

However, it would be nice to make it more obvious what these numbers actually mean to the end user
Template #24 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
Template #24 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
Template #24 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
picture description is missing
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #24 Issue #5
Feb 5, 2019
date is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #24 Issue #6
Feb 5, 2019
there should be ambedded twitter posts
Accepted by admin
Template #24 Issue #7
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
Template #24 Issue #8
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #24 Issue #9
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #24 Issue #10
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all...
Accepted by admin
Template #21 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
Template #21 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
date is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #21 Issue #5
Feb 5, 2019
subtitle is missing
Accepted by admin
This text should be included, it is up to the template creator whether this summary sentence is displayed as a subtitle, or as the first part of the article text

Please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-3-subtitle
Template #21 Issue #6
Feb 5, 2019
description is missing
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #21 Issue #7
Feb 5, 2019
picture is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #21 Issue #9
Feb 5, 2019
picture is missing
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #20 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
descriptions are displayed incorrectly
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #20 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
headers not properly parsed
Accepted by admin
Template #20 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
picture is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #20 Issue #5
Feb 5, 2019
author is missing
Accepted by admin
Please see: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-1-author-name
Template #20 Issue #6
Feb 5, 2019
no IV art all
Accepted by admin
Template #20 Issue #7
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
Note:
The Spotify Widget here is non-essential to this article and can be removed, please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-3-auxiliary-widgets
Template #18 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
title picture is better looking as a cover
Declined by admin
This is not displayed as a cover (in the conventional sense) on the original website, so this can be considered a style choice by the template creator
Template #18 Issue #5
Feb 5, 2019
the whole text content of the page is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #18 Issue #6
Feb 5, 2019
no text content
Accepted by admin
Template #18 Issue #7
Feb 5, 2019
description is displayed incorrectly
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #18 Issue #8
Feb 5, 2019
picture is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #18 Issue #9
Feb 5, 2019
picture is missing
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #18 Issue #10
Feb 5, 2019
headers are messed up
Accepted by admin
Template #6 Issue #13
Feb 5, 2019
Embed not supported.
No IV to show.
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template6/issue11/
Template #18 Issue #11
Feb 5, 2019
no IV at all
Accepted by admin
Spotify Widget here is non-essential to this article and can be removed, please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-3-auxiliary-widgets
Template #18 Issue #12
Feb 5, 2019
description is missing
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #28 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
No audiplayer in IV page. In the original it is available.
undefined
They use not standart embed API, therefor IV can't parse this object.
Declined by admin
While Soundcloud is supported by IV, author has explained that they do not think it's possible to support it in this case.

"We will accept issues requesting to generate IVs for pages with content previously deemed unsupported if you include a link to a template that fully supports the content in question."
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#unsupported-content
Template #29 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
No instance view
Accepted by admin
Pitchfork has a variety of different features/story types, and other templates have been able to support them nicely
Template #14 Issue #15
Feb 5, 2019
not display main image
Declined by admin
Duplicate issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template14/issue14/
Template #28 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
text without white space
Accepted by admin
Template #30 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
missing img
Иван Ветошкин
It's not missing on my phone
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #30 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
missing img
Иван Ветошкин
It's not missing on my phone
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #30 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
missing img
Иван Ветошкин
It's not missing on my phone
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #29 Issue #2
Feb 5, 2019
No Instant View available
Accepted by admin
Pitchfork has a variety of different features/story types, and other templates have been able to support them nicely
Template #29 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
No Instant View available
Accepted by admin
Pitchfork has a variety of different features/story types, and other templates have been able to support them nicely
Template #11 Issue #10
Feb 5, 2019
Photo from Article does not showing
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #31 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
There is no image, but link to it. "Beirut" it's not the list element
Accepted by admin
Since this information is duplicated in the title, and the linked page will not generate IV it is better to remove this - it is not really necessary here
Template #29 Issue #4
Feb 5, 2019
Missing IV
Accepted by admin
Pitchfork has a variety of different features/story types, and other templates have been able to support them nicely
Template #29 Issue #5
Feb 5, 2019
IV missing
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #32 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
No image. No score
Nickolas Kyrylyuk
This is not essential content
Accepted by admin
Due to this being a review, the album art and rating can be considered as essential

Without it, the page loses very important context (Overall, IV should be better for end-users than the original page, not worse!)
Template #29 Issue #6
Feb 5, 2019
IV not generated
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #29 Issue #7
Feb 5, 2019
NO author and date published
Accepted by admin
Template #28 Issue #3
Feb 5, 2019
this is an article about the photographer and unfortunately you can only get a photo with low-resolution (31px).

Rule 6.2.1
If for some reason it is only technically possible to obtain low-resolution versions of images (lower than 320px) for a page, on which high-resolution images are available on the web, the page should not generate an IV.
Accepted by admin
Template #37 Issue #1
Feb 6, 2019
Author links are fetchable.
Declined by admin
"We will not be accepting issues based on author links. The only exception is when the author link is pointing to an inappropriate page."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-5-author-links
Template #37 Issue #2
Feb 6, 2019
Not a part of the article
Accepted by admin
Template #36 Issue #1
Feb 6, 2019
need to remove. should've in the author property
Иван Ветошкин
I think placing multiple names into the author property is impossible. So, it's worthwhile to include all the names in a separate line
Accepted by admin
They should all be mentioned properly, it is possible to have more than one author (separated by commas like you have already done here)

However, please bear in mind this advice regarding links:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-5-author-links
Template #37 Issue #3
Feb 6, 2019
photo caption is missing
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #28 Issue #4
Feb 6, 2019
You have a great template (the best probably). My template was rejected because my cover had the same (similar) issue as these pictures. I debug my <figures> everything is proper. I inspect the result the link is in <alt> attribute, while the src is empty (no errors in the process). This message is my way of asking the IV authorities about all of it. Maybe there are multiple links for cover images, but there aren't doubles for every image (this issue is global). Why templates are held accountable when it is probably a tiny bug in IV Code? Template's part of the pipeline seems good. If it is a bug and it will be found in a couple days, will rejected Templates be returned to their fair place?
P.S. here you have a little bit different issue, but you know what I am talking about considering you have your covers handled. And again, you template is great and please don't resubmit it before the response I am waiting. Best wishes)
undefined
I didn't understand what your trouble is. Sorry, but I need to resubmit the template after bulk edits.
I Hope, Admin will get here and will help you.
Declined by admin
Template #40 Issue #1
Feb 6, 2019
only one author is displayed when multiple authors are listed in the article
Accepted by admin
Yes, but please bear in mind this advice about author links:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-5-author-links
Template #36 Issue #2
Feb 6, 2019
There is no headline in your template. Also the first paragraph is stacked.
Accepted by admin
Template #28 Issue #5
Feb 6, 2019
This IV misses a score of the song/album.
Accepted by admin
Template #36 Issue #3
Feb 7, 2019
this picture should be set cover
Declined by admin
This is not displayed as a cover (in the conventional sense) on the original website, so this can be considered a style choice by the template creator.

It would certainly be better as a header, but not a major issue in this case.
Template #37 Issue #4
Feb 7, 2019
cover description is missing
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #40 Issue #2
Feb 7, 2019
template didn't work for this page
Accepted by admin
Template #36 Issue #4
Feb 7, 2019
the picture should be set cover
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #37 Issue #5
Feb 7, 2019
cover picture is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #40 Issue #3
Feb 7, 2019
template doesn't work for this page
Accepted by admin
Template #36 Issue #5
Feb 7, 2019
pictures' descriptions are displayed incorrectly
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #36 Issue #6
Feb 7, 2019
a picture in link preview is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #37 Issue #6
Feb 7, 2019
a picture in link preview is missing
Declined by admin
Template #37 Issue #7
Feb 7, 2019
pictures' descriptions are displayed incorrectly
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #28 Issue #6
Feb 7, 2019
Missing cover image
Accepted by admin
Template #36 Issue #7
Feb 7, 2019
these should either be removed or added to the pictures as descriptions
Accepted by admin
This repeated content looks bad here

Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #37 Issue #8
Feb 7, 2019
elements not handled properly
Accepted by admin
Template #36 Issue #8
Feb 7, 2019
element should be a header
Declined by admin
Please see https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-3-subtitle
Template #36 Issue #9
Feb 7, 2019
headers are displayed a bit incorrectly
Accepted by admin
Template #37 Issue #9
Feb 7, 2019
headers are displayed a bit incorrectly
Accepted by admin
Template #37 Issue #10
Feb 7, 2019
subtitle is missing
Accepted by admin
This text should be included, it is up to the template creator whether this summary sentence is displayed as a subtitle, or as the first part of the article text

Please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-3-subtitle
Template #40 Issue #4
Feb 7, 2019
photo gallery is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #36 Issue #10
Feb 7, 2019
template doesn't work for this page
Declined by admin
Other templates have been able to support these different types, whilst not 100% essential - the winning template will most likely be the one that supports the most amount of content in the best way
Template #37 Issue #11
Feb 7, 2019
photo gallery is missing
Accepted by admin
Please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-3-galleries-and-slideshows
Template #36 Issue #11
Feb 7, 2019
template must work for this page
Accepted by admin
Soundcloud widget is supported and it has been shown that this page is possible to create IV for
Template #37 Issue #12
Feb 7, 2019
template must work for this page
Accepted by admin
Soundcloud is supported and it is possible to generate an IV for this page
Template #37 Issue #13
Feb 7, 2019
needs some cleaning
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #36 Issue #12
Feb 7, 2019
this can be removed
Accepted by admin
Template #37 Issue #14
Feb 7, 2019
this can be removed
Accepted by admin
Template #36 Issue #13
Feb 7, 2019
score is missing
Declined by admin
Score is present
Template #37 Issue #15
Feb 7, 2019
score is missing
Accepted by admin
Due to this being a review, making it clear that this number is the rating can be considered as essential

Especially as we do not have the benefit of displaying it with the additional styling that the original site uses to make it clear
Template #40 Issue #6
Feb 7, 2019
score is missing
Usamah K
Not missing. Check again.
Declined by admin
Indeed, not missing.

However, in future versions of your template, making it clear that this number is the rating can be considered as essential

Especially as we do not have the benefit of displaying it with the additional styling that the original site uses to make it clear
Template #40 Issue #7
Feb 7, 2019
duplicate content
Accepted by admin
Since this information is duplicated in the title, and the linked page will not generate IV it is better to remove this - it is not really necessary here
Template #36 Issue #14
Feb 7, 2019
duplicate contents
Accepted by admin
Template #40 Issue #8
Feb 7, 2019
duplicate contents
Accepted by admin
Template #36 Issue #15
Feb 7, 2019
elements not separated
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #37 Issue #16
Feb 7, 2019
I think, it is supposed to be a picture description
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #36 Issue #16
Feb 7, 2019
headers are missing
Accepted by admin
Template #36 Issue #17
Feb 7, 2019
elements not separated
Accepted by admin
Template #40 Issue #9
Feb 7, 2019
header is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #28 Issue #7
Feb 7, 2019
This code will display 2 authors --> $body//div[has-class("authors-detail")]
undefined
While it is possible to display several authors, IV doesn't support individual author_url for each author.
Accepted by admin
Template #42 Issue #1
Feb 7, 2019
This page should be handled differently (I making an issue for myself, it is just too hard to know the answer in this case).
Declined by admin
Your handling is not really too bad :)

If possible, the best way to display this information would be a Slideshow at the top, with the Album art as the image and the name & rating as a caption

And then underneath, the article text
Template #28 Issue #8
Feb 7, 2019
no rating is displayed
undefined
duplicate issue
Declined by admin
Template #28 Issue #9
Feb 7, 2019
information is displayed incorrectly
undefined
duplicate issue
Declined by admin
Template #41 Issue #2
Feb 7, 2019
article contains unsupported media. IV shouldn't be gererated
Accepted by admin
Please see
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#unsupported-content
Template #41 Issue #3
Feb 7, 2019
picture descriptions are missing (the ones at left at least)
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #36 Issue #18
Feb 7, 2019
missing image captions
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #41 Issue #4
Feb 7, 2019
these headers can be separated as h1 and h2
Accepted by admin
Template #41 Issue #5
Feb 7, 2019
There are at least two ways to generate an appropriate IV for this page. Take a look at my template for reference.
Accepted by admin
This page can be supported
Template #41 Issue #6
Feb 7, 2019
This article has no unsupported elements. Media needs some additional handling,
Accepted by admin
This page can be supported
Template #41 Issue #8
Feb 7, 2019
There should be FB post embedded between thw two highlighted paragraphs
Accepted by admin
Template #41 Issue #9
Feb 7, 2019
duplicate elements
Accepted by admin
Template #41 Issue #10
Feb 7, 2019
highlighted itemlist can be turned into a slideshow
Accepted by admin
The best way to display this information would be a Slideshow at the top, with the Album art as the image and the name & rating as a caption

And then underneath, the article text
Template #36 Issue #19
Feb 7, 2019
authors not properly handled
Declined by admin
Template #37 Issue #17
Feb 7, 2019
author_url is missing
Declined by admin
"We will not be accepting issues based on author links. The only exception is when the author link is pointing to an inappropriate page."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-5-author-links
Template #42 Issue #2
Feb 7, 2019
the picture is too small. you can enlarge it
Anton
Not a mistake. You can't enlarge it, you can just take another image (another URI) hoping that the will be the same on every page.
Declined by admin
No "right" way here - the bigger image is better, but the original article displays the smaller album art
Template #42 Issue #3
Feb 7, 2019
no link preview picture
Declined by admin
Template #42 Issue #4
Feb 7, 2019
this block must be removed
Anton
Yeah, top 50 means worst 10 from top 50.
Declined by admin
Not accepting this issue because these controls take the user to other pages, they should not be removed like they are in your template (https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template28/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpitchfork.com%2Ffeatures%2Flists-and-guides%2Fthe-50-best-albums-of-2018%2F)

However, it would be nice to make it more obvious what these numbers actually mean to the end user
Template #42 Issue #5
Feb 7, 2019
these headers can be separated as h1 and h2
Anton
I will change that (agree, looks a little bit better) but probably not a mistake.
Accepted by admin
Template #42 Issue #6
Feb 7, 2019
photo gallery on this page can be turned into a slideshow
Anton
It wasn't a slideshow in the original, so it can stay not a slideshow here. At the same time great job with you version.
Accepted by admin
The original page does present this as a slideshow (click)

Please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-3-galleries-and-slideshows
Template #42 Issue #7
Feb 7, 2019
his element must be removed
Anton
It should here for the same reason it is in the original article.
Accepted by admin
This Tumblr embed is not needed here https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-3-auxiliary-widgets
Declined by admin
Actually, ignore the above - this exact case is being discussed more in-depth, and we will be able to give exact guidance in future
Template #42 Issue #8
Feb 7, 2019
IV should be generated for this page
Anton
Nope
Accepted by admin
It is possible to support this page in IV, so it should be done

Remember that the winning template will be the one that supports the most content in the best way
Template #42 Issue #9
Feb 7, 2019
the picture could be set a cover
Anton
I hope to postpone the moment when AI will take our jobs by being creative sometime and having my own opinion. During testing I tried both variants and it turns out this way is better for the eyes (at least for mine).
Declined by admin
This is not displayed as a cover (in the conventional sense) on the original website, so this can be considered a style choice by the template creator.

It would certainly be better as a header, but not a major issue in this case.
Template #42 Issue #10
Feb 7, 2019
these can be turned into a slideshow
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #42 Issue #11
Feb 7, 2019
image is too small, you can enlarge it
Anton
This is a duplicate.
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #42 Issue #12
Feb 7, 2019
no author_url
Declined by admin
"We will not be accepting issues based on author links. The only exception is when the author link is pointing to an inappropriate page."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-5-author-links
Template #43 Issue #1
Feb 8, 2019
There are 2 authors in this article.
Accepted by admin
Template #45 Issue #1
Feb 8, 2019
Both authors url pointing to the same page.
Alexander.G
I am working on fixing this bug. maybe I'm wrong, but I think it is impossible to implement.
Accepted by admin
Alex, you are correct - this cannot be fixed, so instead no URL should be used at all

Please see the "Note" here:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-5-author-links
Template #43 Issue #2
Feb 8, 2019
Missing the second author.
undefined
you duplicated your own report (https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template43/issue1/)
Declined by admin
Template #48 Issue #1
Feb 8, 2019
this content can be made as a cover caption
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #48 Issue #2
Feb 8, 2019
incorrect display of content
Accepted by admin
Template #48 Issue #3
Feb 8, 2019
this should be removed
Accepted by admin
Template #48 Issue #4
Feb 8, 2019
incorrect display of content
Accepted by admin
Template #48 Issue #5
Feb 8, 2019
missing link to author
Usamah K
Author link is optional -- https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-5-author-links
Declined by admin
As Usamah said:

"We will not be accepting issues based on author links. The only exception is when the author link is pointing to an inappropriate page."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-5-author-links
Template #48 Issue #6
Feb 8, 2019
there is no content of the article
Accepted by admin
Template #45 Issue #2
Feb 8, 2019
Soundcloud is supported. Try @wrap it
Alexander.G
Thank you for your advice.
I'll try to fix it.
but I think that this widget is not supported in this form.
you can check this link on my template, everything works there

https://pitchfork.com/news/60801-odesza-announce-in-return-deluxe-edition-team-up-with-little-dragon-on-light
Declined by admin
Author has explained why they have not supported this.

"We will accept issues requesting to generate IVs for pages with content previously deemed unsupported if you include a link to a template that fully supports the content in question."
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#unsupported-content
Template #48 Issue #7
Feb 8, 2019
there is no content of the article
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #48 Issue #8
Feb 8, 2019
content of the article is missing
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #45 Issue #3
Feb 8, 2019
subtitles is missing, seo description is showing instead
Alexander.G
Thanks, fixed.
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #45 Issue #4
Feb 8, 2019
paginator is missing
Accepted by admin
These controls take the user to other pages of this article, they should not be removed because without them the IV is incomplete
Template #45 Issue #5
Feb 8, 2019
paginator is missing
Alexander.G
duplicated previous ISSUE #4
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #45 Issue #6
Feb 8, 2019
weird word wraps
Alexander.G
Thanks, fixed
Accepted by admin
Template #45 Issue #7
Feb 8, 2019
this supposed to be a header, I believe
Alexander.G
Thanks, fixed
Accepted by admin
Template #45 Issue #8
Feb 8, 2019
quotation here looks better as a pullnote, but that's not critical
Alexander.G
Thanks.
Maybe I'll make a change.
after I'm done on more critical issues
Accepted by admin
"Pullquotes must be horizontally centered on IV page if pull quotes exist in the source."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#3-3-supported-elements
Template #45 Issue #9
Feb 8, 2019
photo gallery is missing
Alexander.G
Thanks.
I'm working on it))
I saw that you made a great option in your template.
But I ask You please don't each time to indicate a duplicate error.
Accepted by admin
Template #45 Issue #10
Feb 8, 2019
soundcloud embed not handled
Alexander.G
thank you!
I remember you pointed me to this error in the previous template.
I will fix this in the next template
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #49 Issue #1
Feb 8, 2019
There are headers, not the caption
Accepted by admin
Template #51 Issue #1
Feb 9, 2019
genres block not removed
Accepted by admin
These tags have limited use in IV, since the pages they link to will not generate IV. On the original site, they makes more sense because users can quickly see other articles with the same tags. For this reason it is better to remove these - they is not really necessary or useful here
Template #51 Issue #2
Feb 9, 2019
picture description is missing
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #51 Issue #3
Feb 9, 2019
subtitle is missing. the overall description is used instead
Accepted by admin
Template #54 Issue #1
Feb 9, 2019
This is an article and need IV
undefined
It contains a Spotify embed which is not supported by IV
Declined by admin
Author has explained that they do not think it's possible to support it in this case.

"We will accept issues requesting to generate IVs for pages with content previously deemed unsupported if you include a link to a template that fully supports the content in question."
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#unsupported-content
Template #54 Issue #2
Feb 9, 2019
Why there is no instant view page?
undefined
The article contains a Bandcamp player which is not supported by IV
Declined by admin
Author has explained that they do not think it's possible to support it in this case. In fact, your own template does not support this page for the same reason! So it's odd that you have made an issue for this...

"We will accept issues requesting to generate IVs for pages with content previously deemed unsupported if you include a link to a template that fully supports the content in question."
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#unsupported-content
Template #54 Issue #3
Feb 10, 2019
IV page does not generate the date when the event is held, As well as the button for buying tickets.
undefined
Good finding, thanks! I didn't encouter pages of this kind while browsing the site. I'd like to handle it now.

However, Admins, please confirm this page should have IV generated.
I'm asking because, in some different case, you said event pages should NOT.
Declined by admin
"Midwinter" is a yearly event held by Pitchfork, this page will likely be recycled in future for other instances of this event

Therefore, IV should not be generated for this subdomain/article

"IV pages are cached on our servers. The more time passed since an article was published, the less frequently the cached IV page will be updated. Any pages that update content in real time would subsequently display outdated IV pages to users — which is unacceptable."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-1-pages-with-dynamic-content
Template #56 Issue #1
Feb 10, 2019
This page does not include any dynamic content
Declined by admin
"Midwinter" is a yearly event held by Pitchfork, this page will likely be recycled in future for other instances of this event

Therefore, IV should not be generated for this subdomain/article

"IV pages are cached on our servers. The more time passed since an article was published, the less frequently the cached IV page will be updated. Any pages that update content in real time would subsequently display outdated IV pages to users — which is unacceptable."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-1-pages-with-dynamic-content
Template #54 Issue #4
Feb 10, 2019
no IV at all, when Spotify widget can be removed. According to https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-3-auxiliary-widgets
undefined
From the link above:
"unsupported widgets that are not essential for the understanding of the article"

The spotify widget provides the track to which the article is dedicated.
I think, it is essential for this page.
Declined by admin
Template #54 Issue #5
Feb 11, 2019
yes. IV supports Twitter and Instagram embedded elements
undefined
It's not about embedded elements, it's about simple img inside p :(
Damnit, I've checked HUNDREDS of pages on that site, and none has such an issue with the current version of template.
Thanks for finding. Gonna lose my first place... sigh.
Accepted by admin
Template #56 Issue #2
Feb 11, 2019
This is rudimentary content, from bandcamp widget which is not supported, my template handles this better(https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template58/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpitchfork.com%2Freviews%2Falbums%2Fcass-mccombs-tip-of-the-sphere%2F)
Accepted by admin
Pages with unsupported content shouldn't generate IV
Template #61 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
IV missing
undefined
The article contains Bandcamp player which is not supported by IV.
IV must not be generated in this case, as per rules.
Declined by admin
Template #58 Issue #2
Feb 12, 2019
There's no sense to show a number for pages(which is already numbered), and also it might be confusing on what page you are, this page doesn't show it.
Accepted by admin
It would be nice to make it more obvious what these numbers actually mean to the end user, and display them in a nicer way - other templates have been able to do this
Template #59 Issue #1
Feb 12, 2019
Navigation through the article is missing. It's not a navigation bar through the website.
Accepted by admin
These controls take the user to other pages, they should not be removed

Note:
If you add them, it would be better to make it obvious what these numbers actually mean to the end user - some other templates just translate them to a list with no context
Template #62 Issue #1
Feb 13, 2019
This is an article
undefined
It contains unsupported Spotify embed
Declined by admin
Template #62 Issue #2
Feb 13, 2019
May get page cover from <meta name="og:image" />
undefined
The original page does not have a cover image.
There's no reason to add it into IV.
Declined by admin
Template #59 Issue #2
Feb 13, 2019
why did you removed "photo by"? this makes no sense
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #58 Issue #3
Feb 13, 2019
the picture should be a cover
Declined by admin
This is not displayed as a cover (in the conventional sense) on the original website, so this can be considered a style choice by the template creator.

It would certainly be better as a cover, but not a major issue in this case.
Template #63 Issue #1
Feb 13, 2019
publish date and author are missing
Accepted by admin
Please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-1-author-name
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-2-date-and-time
Template #58 Issue #4
Feb 13, 2019
captions not handled
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #58 Issue #5
Feb 13, 2019
common author should not show
Declined by admin
It can be omitted, but it does not have to be in this case because the extracted name is sensible
Template #58 Issue #6
Feb 13, 2019
italic markup is lost
Declined by admin
Very minor, would be nice to fix but is there anything really lost by this just being normal vs italic headline?
Template #58 Issue #7
Feb 13, 2019
captions not handled
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #58 Issue #9
Feb 13, 2019
paginator not handled
Declined by admin
Duplicate Issue
Template #59 Issue #4
Feb 13, 2019
captions not handled
Accepted by admin
Please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-4-captions
and
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-5-media-credits
Template #59 Issue #6
Feb 13, 2019
paginator is missing
Accepted by admin
These controls take the user to other pages, they should not be removed

Note:
If you add them, it would be better to make it obvious what these numbers actually mean to the end user - some other templates just translate them to a list with no context
Template #63 Issue #2
Feb 13, 2019
the original page doesn't have a cover
Declined by admin
Images from meta-tags are not recommended – they might be suitable, but are usually designed with sharing widgets in mind and don’t work well in the IV environment.

However, this is not a failure, please see:

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-2-cover-images
Template #63 Issue #3
Feb 13, 2019
those are not captions, but headers. actual captions are missing
Accepted by admin
Template #59 Issue #7
Feb 13, 2019
should work for this page
Accepted by admin
Link has been given to a template that supports this page well - cannot see anything essential here that could not be supported by IV
Template #58 Issue #11
Feb 13, 2019
these can be divided into header and subheader
Accepted by admin
Template #59 Issue #8
Feb 13, 2019
these can be divided into header and subheader
Accepted by admin
Template #63 Issue #5
Feb 13, 2019
these can be divided into header and subheader
Accepted by admin
Template #58 Issue #12
Feb 13, 2019
these should be pullnotes
Accepted by admin
"Pullquotes must be horizontally centered on IV page if pull quotes exist in the source."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#3-3-supported-elements
Template #59 Issue #9
Feb 13, 2019
these should be pullnotes
Accepted by admin
"Pullquotes must be horizontally centered on IV page if pull quotes exist in the source."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#3-3-supported-elements
Template #63 Issue #6
Feb 13, 2019
these should be pullnotes
Accepted by admin
"Pullquotes must be horizontally centered on IV page if pull quotes exist in the source."

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#3-3-supported-elements
Template #58 Issue #13
Feb 13, 2019
this page needs IV
Accepted by admin
Link has been given to a template that supports this page well - cannot see anything essential here that could not be supported by IV
Template #59 Issue #10
Feb 13, 2019
slideshow is missing
Accepted by admin
Please see:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-3-galleries-and-slideshows
Template #63 Issue #7
Feb 13, 2019
slideshow is incomplete. there should be much more photos
Accepted by admin
Agreed, the original article displays 22 images here and other templates have been able to extract them all
Template #59 Issue #11
Feb 13, 2019
this page contains Spotify embed, which is unsupported.
IV should not be generated.
Declined by admin
The Spotify widget is not really essential to this article - it's fine to remove it in this case

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-3-auxiliary-widgets
Template #58 Issue #16
Feb 13, 2019
Soundcloud embeded player is missing
Accepted by admin
As Soundcloud embeds are natively supported by IV, it is better to have them as convertible iframes instead of just keeping the link
Template #59 Issue #13
Feb 13, 2019
Soundcloud embeded player is missing
Accepted by admin
As Soundcloud embeds are natively supported by IV, it is better to have them as convertible iframes instead of just keeping the link
Template #63 Issue #10
Feb 13, 2019
Soundcloud embeded player is missing
Accepted by admin
As Soundcloud embeds are natively supported by IV, it is better to have them as convertible iframes instead of just keeping the link
Template #58 Issue #17
Feb 13, 2019
Two different unsupported embeds on this page.
IV should not be generated.
Declined by admin
It is already not generated
Template #63 Issue #11
Feb 13, 2019
Two different unsupported embeds on this page.
IV should not be generated.
Declined by admin
Template #64 Issue #1
Feb 13, 2019
Is this really the official Pitchfork Telegram channel?

"To be considered official, the channel must be named as such somewhere on the source website."
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-3-channel-links

Can you provide such a link where they say this? Thanks
undefined
I think it's actually official. However it is not mentioned on the website.
I'll remove it.
Accepted by admin
Template #66 Issue #1
Feb 14, 2019
According to 2.3 Pages featuring content unsupported in the IV format it shouldn't be displayed because it has embedded element(on the bottom) that cannot be handled in any way.
undefined
Thanks for pointing it out. I forgot to remove debugging code...
Accepted by admin
Template #66 Issue #2
Feb 14, 2019
the track is missing, but the caption for it is still on the page
Accepted by admin
Template #70 Issue #1
Feb 16, 2019
Subtitle(or lead) marked in no way
It is not a kicker, this is a track category
Cover not marked
undefined
1. It's not a subtitle. It's a lead, and it is marked as it should be.
2. Kicker is optional, as I know. And that element nicely matches its purpose.
3. The picture is not a cover on the original page.
Declined by admin
Template #70 Issue #2
Feb 16, 2019
Sorry wrong in the previous issue, you have marked the lead, but everything else is valid.
Here. It is not dynamic page, IV must bu generated
undefined
Alhough it is static, it's not an article of any kind.
Admins would say, it's optional. I'd agree.
Declined by admin
Template #70 Issue #3
Feb 17, 2019
Progress bar numbers and button text
undefined
Good finding, thanks
Accepted by admin
Template #75 Issue #1
Feb 18, 2019
Without these tags, it's not clear what genre of music we are talking about, and for a music review site, it's quite important. At least they must be mentioned in plain text somewhere, like a kicker o even a blockquote.
undefined
I disagree
Declined by admin
Template #75 Issue #2
Feb 19, 2019
Missed ARTISTS IN THIS STORY block, it's important at this site, it looks better at my template
undefined
These are tags-like links. And they can't have their own IV.
If you've read the article, you already know which artists are in this story.
Declined by admin
Yes these seem similar to tags, they do not seem like essential content. Seems okay to remove them.
Template #75 Issue #3
Feb 19, 2019
Missed author
undefined
No need to show default author
Declined by admin
Template #75 Issue #4
Feb 19, 2019
Missed blockquote
undefined
It's an H3 header, not a blockquote.
Declined by admin
Template #75 Issue #5
Feb 19, 2019
Embed is missing on the page. This page should either display the embed or be omitted as IV.
undefined
That embed is just an ad. You won't find any page where tyhis type of embde is related to article in any way.
Declined by admin
Actually, it does seem to be not related to the article. If there is an example where this type of video is a part of an article then the issue would be relevant.
Template #75 Issue #6
Feb 20, 2019
Sorry for adding another issue, but this embed is a part of the article. There are some other pages, where you can find some kind of ads, but they are added dynamically via script. This embed is a part of the article markup.
undefined
<div src="https://player.cnevids.com/script/video/5c54bd722795511f75000002.js?autoplay=0"></div>

Does this random video seem essential? I don't think so.
Declined by admin
Duplicated issue https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template75/issue5/.
Template #75 Issue #7
Feb 20, 2019
"6.2.3 Galleries and slideshows
EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used:

When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content."
undefined
It wasn't me who made this gallery into a slideshow, and it shouldn't be me who tears it apart.
Accepted by admin
This is one of the slideshow exceptions. Whether template creator creates the slideshow or not, it still needs to not be displayed as a slideshow in the IV.
Template #75 Issue #8
Feb 20, 2019
Extra caption for the slideshow
undefined
That caption is visible when the slideshow popup is open
Declined by admin
Template #78 Issue #1
Feb 21, 2019
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template6/issue11/

This issue states that this page should have an IV.
undefined
The track, which the whole article is dedicated to, is not essential? I don't think so.
Declined by admin
Template #78 Issue #2
Feb 21, 2019
This is a site section, not a kicker. Same issue but on another template: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/kanobu.ru/template83/issue5/
undefined
please, stop wasting my time, and try to make a template for this damn domain yourself
Accepted by admin
Template #79 Issue #1
Feb 21, 2019
I think it's better to not generate IV for such pages with unavailable content. The context of the page tells us that we can watch a video below, but the article ends abruptly and we are missing information as a readers.
Declined by admin
Template #81 Issue #1
Feb 21, 2019
A video "The 10 Best Albums of 2018", which is directly related to the topic of the article is missing. I think it's better to omit IV for pages with such embeds.
undefined
It's not related
Accepted by admin
Template #80 Issue #1
Feb 22, 2019
ы
Ed Pelesh
і
Declined by admin
Template #80 Issue #2
Feb 22, 2019
It's not good gallery, you can look awesome gallery at my template:
Ed Pelesh
Why so? Looks great, I think.
Accepted by admin
Better to not use undocumented types, since they may be unsupported by clients
Template #82 Issue #1
Feb 22, 2019
It's not good gallery, you can look awesome gallery at my template:
undefined
You made it just a list of pictures. How is that awesome?
Accepted by admin
Better to not use <collage> since it's undocumented feature, that may be unsupported by clients
undefined
OMG, why have you waited three weeks to say that?
Accepted by admin
We regret the delay and the inconvenience. But the contest is based on the features documented in our Manual, not documented features can be removed, not supported or have problems.
Template #80 Issue #3
Feb 22, 2019
Wrooong &rsquo;s
Declined by admin
Template #82 Issue #2
Feb 22, 2019
Double content
undefined
It's not doubled. The first highlighted element is a title of the page. The second one is a caption of the photo gallery. The fact that they are equal in this particular case is just a coincidence, and doesn't happen for pages of this kind every time.
Accepted by admin
Template #80 Issue #4
Feb 22, 2019
Missed content
Declined by admin
Template #82 Issue #3
Feb 22, 2019
Missed content
undefined
You've already got this issue declined: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template75/issue2/
Stop spamming, please.
Declined by admin
Template #84 Issue #2
Feb 23, 2019
It's not a kicker, it's just a category
Accepted by admin
Template #84 Issue #3
Feb 23, 2019
They are tags, it's not essential
Accepted by admin
Template #82 Issue #4
Feb 23, 2019
Should be a cover
undefined
No, it shouldn't.
Declined by admin
Template #84 Issue #4
Feb 23, 2019
Poor editing. I suppose you see all the problems. The title is not set and the score goes as a title...
Accepted by admin
Template #82 Issue #5
Feb 23, 2019
Should be an IV page
undefined
IV not generated because "Embedded content is unavailable."
Declined by admin
Template #82 Issue #6
Feb 23, 2019
Slideshows shouldn't be used.
According to 6.2.3 "EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used:" "When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/DESCRIPTION)".
This instant view page template handles it better
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template84/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpitchfork.com%2Ffeatures%2Fphoto-gallery%2F9744-pitchfork-music-festival-paris-2015%2F
undefined
sigh... I've already added handling of pages with no text content at all.
If you think it is not ENOUGH content to make the gallery into slideshow, then how much text would you consider enough? What would be the threshold? And how one can figure it out? By counting paragraphs/words/letters?
For me, this a an edge case.
Accepted by admin
undefined
Admins, please tell us, how should we determine how much content is enough for a gallery to be a slideshow?
Accepted by admin
Everything depends on each site. If there is no content between the images, and the initial content is a simple description or a single paragraph, it should not be a slideshow. In summary: if the main purpose of that page is the images, it should not be a slideshow.
Template #80 Issue #6
Feb 23, 2019
Slideshows shouldn't be used.
According to 6.2.3 "EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used:" "When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/DESCRIPTION)".
This instant view page template handles it better
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template84/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpitchfork.com%2Ffeatures%2Fphoto-gallery%2F9744-pitchfork-music-festival-paris-2015%2F
Accepted by admin
Template #80 Issue #10
Feb 24, 2019
there are no expanding blocks in the original
Accepted by admin
Template #88 Issue #1
Feb 24, 2019
Should be cover
undefined
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template82/issue4/
Declined by admin
Template #88 Issue #2
Feb 24, 2019
Missed unsupported video, it page must not have IV
undefined
That video is just a random ad. Removing it is ok.
Accepted by admin
This video is related to the article. It presents first 10 places from the article's top-50.
undefined
Please read detailed explanation here
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template88/issue4/
Accepted by admin
Since there's no technical way to identify whether a video is an important part of the article or just "related-like", it must be represented as an <iframe> so IV won't be generated until such will be supported by IV.
Template #88 Issue #3
Feb 24, 2019
Missed video, look source (here is video before marked block)
undefined
you must decide for yourself what you really want: having a video or not having IV. you can't have both XD
u r such a spammer
Accepted by admin
Template #88 Issue #4
Feb 24, 2019
Missed video after block:
"In 2018, it felt hard to reach consensus on anything—including music. The heavy-hitters of pop and hip-hop returned, but many disappointed; in fact, sometimes, they were just confounding (cough Kanye cough). More than ever, music felt like a playing field where new, exciting artists were sharing the discussion with the veterans, if not taking it over outright. A sea change was underway, the borders eroded—and music was better for it. Here are the best albums of the year."

The best albums 2018 video
undefined
There's a TV section on this website, and here is the page where that video wa originally published:
https://pitchfork.com/tv/60-video-countdown/the-top-10-albums-of-the-1980s/

The video is about 10 best albums of 2018.
The article is about 50.
The video is only visible on the first page.
The best 10 albums are actually on the last page.
The video published on SEPTEMBER 10 2018.
The article published on DECEMBER 11 2018.

It is related-like video only in this particular case, because in others those videos are totally random.
We could wrap this video into <related>, but this would be pointless because those video pages cannot have IV.
Declined by admin
Duplicate
Template #88 Issue #5
Feb 24, 2019
And again, I had same issue, for example there with map:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/citydog.by/template27/issue2/
undefined
it's not even similar
Declined by admin
Template #88 Issue #6
Feb 27, 2019
I AM TERRIBLY SORRY FOR LAST MINUTE ISSUE. But I just finished my template. I'm really sorry I did not mean to :(

But this part cannot be displayed this way. I do respect your attention to details to match site's layout, I truly do and your work looks great.

But look what happened to the Link preview, it shows false information, article title is different, it changed and is misleading.

Again, I'm sorry for last minute, I did not intend to do that and I hate when people do that.
undefined
It's not possible to specify separate titles for an article and for a link preview.
Declined by admin
Template #90 Issue #1
Feb 27, 2019
Those are just tags, should be removed.
Accepted by admin
Alex
No, you can see tags below this block. It's block of artist and I think it's part of content because it's music site, and this article about this "Artists"
Accepted by admin
The artists' names are already mentioned in the article. There's no reason to preserve this content
Template #96 Issue #1
Mar 2, 2019
Rudimentary content not removed, images are too small
Accepted by admin
Template #102 Issue #1
Mar 3, 2019
Poor editing. Should be slideshow
Accepted by admin
The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #102 Issue #3
Mar 3, 2019
As it consists entirely of photos and its short description, there shouldn't be a slideshow. Even in the link, you see "photo-gallery". This template handles it better https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/pitchfork.com/template97/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpitchfork.com%2Ffeatures%2Fphoto-gallery%2F9744-pitchfork-music-festival-paris-2015%2F
Declined by admin
It's optional.
Template #102 Issue #4
Mar 3, 2019
Accepted by admin
Template #104 handles this case better.
Template #102 Issue #5
Mar 3, 2019
Accepted by admin
Template #103 Issue #1
Mar 3, 2019
This should be converted to inline player like original site does. Template by w3drt46523trc26 does it better. Mine too.
Accepted by admin
Template #104 Issue #1
Mar 3, 2019
There are unwanted characters here. (btw, I don't think really need that title, it's actually the same one as the article title)
Accepted by admin
Template #110 Issue #1
Mar 7, 2019
Sorry that I just gave you a heart attack, just wanted to say that your template inspired me to do my own ones better. I hope you win this, because you really earned it. I did a lot of tests to your template and it's really great. I like the typography little tricks and stuff. It's awesome.

Best wishes,
.vhs
undefined
Thanks man. Even if I win, I doubt I will deal with such complicated websites ever again. This one is so diverse, that a 50 urls limit for tracking doesn't cover even a half of possible layouts. It's too hard to work like this.
Declined by admin
Template #112 Issue #3
Mar 7, 2019
authors not properly handled
Alex
I do not like other authors
Accepted by admin