Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues56

This page shows a list of issues for punkt-a.info that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #2 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #1 May 20, 2017	Egor Danilin Article's date is not shown Accepted by admin
Template #3 Egor Danilin	Issue #1 Jun 3, 2017	Лёня empty paragraphs Declined by admin This is a minor issue and can be considered if this template gets rejected because of a major issue.
Template #3 Egor Danilin	Issue #2 Jun 8, 2017	Danil Dunaitsev Vote poll is rudimentary content Accepted by admin
Template #4 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #1 Jun 17, 2017	Sergei Ivanov 🦄 @tgcreator No photo captions. My template proccess it. Accepted by admin
Template #8 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	Konstantin Korotchenko Duplicated/hidden text not removed. Accepted by admin Here is a better one: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/punkt-a.info/template11/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpunkt-a.info%2Fnews%2Fpolitika-i-jekonomika%2Fpravitelstvo-astrakhanskoy-oblasti-pokupaet-novyy-vnedorozhnik-
Template #11 Konstantin Korotchenko	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	Sergei Ivanov 🦄 @tgcreator Category name - need remove Konstantin Korotchenko In header this is h2. So this is subtitle Declined by admin It's possible to use it as a subtitle.
Template #11 Konstantin Korotchenko	Issue #5 Jun 19, 2017	Poma Unsupported table Konstantin Korotchenko My bad. Forget checked this table. 2+ column must be unsupported, but next author remove all tables. This is very bad. Accepted by admin The original article contains complex tables. Complex tables are unsupported content. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-8-1-tables
Template #12 Sergei Ivanov 🦄 @tgcreator	Issue #5 Jun 19, 2017	Konstantin Korotchenko Must be unsupported page, cuz have 2+ column tables Accepted by admin This page should be unsupported by IV.
Template #11 Konstantin Korotchenko	Issue #6 Jun 19, 2017	Sergei Ivanov 🦄 @tgcreator Must be unsupported page, cuz have 2+ column tables Konstantin Korotchenko Check previous issue man, before posting. Duplicated issue https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/punkt-a.info/template11/issue5/ Declined by admin Duplicated issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/punkt-a.info/template11/issue5/
Template #14 Peter	Issue #1 Feb 5, 2019	Yuriy 🐼 Panarin Must be supported Peter Disagree Accepted by admin
Template #16 Peter	Issue #2 Feb 8, 2019	David There is no image from the article Accepted by admin
Template #17 David	Issue #1 Feb 8, 2019	Yuriy 🐼 Panarin Must be processed haven't unsupported element Accepted by admin
Template #19 David	Issue #1 Feb 8, 2019	Peter "Other news" should be deleted. They aren't connected with current article. Accepted by admin
Template #18 Yuriy 🐼 Panarin	Issue #1 Feb 8, 2019	Peter "Other news" should be deleted. They aren't connected with current article. Yuriy 🐼 Panarin Optional, related news in that case optional Accepted by admin The related articles should be actually related to the article. Otherwise they should be removed
Template #20 Peter	Issue #1 Feb 10, 2019	David This page must be IV Peter No Accepted by admin
Template #23 David	Issue #1 Feb 10, 2019	Dzmitry Radkevich Rudimentary content not removed. "Реклама" = "advertisement" David This text is in the content section of the div[itemprop = "description"]. Do you suggest deleting all the words "advertisement" from the article? This block is not identified by the class or id. <p style="text-align: right;"> <span style="font-size: 8pt;">Реклама</span> </p> Declined by admin
Template #23 David	Issue #2 Feb 12, 2019	Dzmitry Radkevich No IV available for article page. My template handle this problem Accepted by admin
Template #25 David	Issue #1 Feb 12, 2019	Dzmitry Radkevich Missing site_name in preview link Checklist>3.2. Link preview "The site_name property must include the correct name of the website." David The name of the site is not provided on the page in the meta tags or properly defined for it, if you insert the site name in the text, problems may arise in the future when the site owner adds the name to the meta tags. Declined by admin
Template #25 David	Issue #2 Feb 13, 2019	Dzmitry Radkevich Hi! Site name in link preview is missing. "3.2. Link preview https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#3-2-link-preview .... - The site_name property must include the correct name of the website. If the webmaster includes unnecessary data (e.g. ‘Site {sitename}’) or mixes the site name with the article title, your template must take care of this. " And check this issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/hegnar.no/template19/issue3/ Thx for attention. David The name of the site is not indicated on the page in the meta tags and is not properly defined for it. If you paste the site name into the text, problems may arise in the future when the site owner adds the name to the meta tags. Arbitrators, please clarify whether it is possible to add the site name simply with text or need to be taken from the meta data, if they are present on the page, if you can add this information to the rules. Previously, this problem in my template was rejected (see the link below), how to be? https://punkt-a.info/news/novosti-kratko/tsentralnuyu-naberezhnuyu-astrakhani-zhdut-sushchestvennye-izmeneniya Accepted by admin
Template #26 Dzmitry Radkevich	Issue #1 Feb 13, 2019	danya Blockquotes not marked Dzmitry Radkevich Hi, thx for your issue. On the original page blockquote is not identified. There are no classes or id to define blockquote. In my opinion, It would be nice to keep the author's formatting. This text is not like a quote. Declined by admin It's optional.
Template #25 David	Issue #3 Feb 13, 2019	danya Blockquotes not marked David On the original page, the text is highlighted in the <b> and <i> tags. There are no classes to define blockquote. The text does not look like a quote. Do you propose to select text in a quote if the following DOM tree is provided? <span style="font-size: 14pt; color: rgb(69, 14, 97);"> <b> <i> TEXT </i> </b> </span> Declined by admin
Template #25 David	Issue #4 Feb 15, 2019	danya Photo captions not marked, they can be recognized (check my template). Also, the list of links at the end of the article is not deleted, these are not related links, this is a list of ALL materials of this rubric David Photo captions are quite difficult to recognize, since they are not marked with a class or id, relying on the <i> tags that follow the photos may not be a very good implementation. The block "Materials of the rubric" are part of the article, as they are provided in the block <div itemprop = "description" /> Links are located in the text of the article, removing links leading to other articles of the site is not a good idea. Removing links for some specific words is also not a very good implementation. Declined by admin
Template #25 David	Issue #5 Feb 15, 2019	Andrew IV must be generated Accepted by admin
Template #25 David	Issue #6 Feb 15, 2019	Andrew Must be splitted into paragraphs Accepted by admin
Template #26 Dzmitry Radkevich	Issue #3 Feb 15, 2019	Andrew Text is not splitted into paragraphs. It is possible to do. Check my template. Declined by admin It's optional.
Template #27 danya	Issue #1 Feb 15, 2019	Andrew Text is not splitted into paragraphs. It is possible to do. Check my template. danya The text is divided in the original article, I do not see the point of removing these separators. Declined by admin It's optional.
Template #28 David	Issue #1 Feb 15, 2019	Andrew Text is not splitted into paragraphs. It is possible to do. Check my template. David Do the rules have a clause that you need to break it into paragraphs? Declined by admin It's optional.
Template #26 Dzmitry Radkevich	Issue #4 Feb 15, 2019	Andrew Dynamic page Accepted by admin
Template #26 Dzmitry Radkevich	Issue #5 Feb 15, 2019	David This page must be IV Accepted by admin The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #28 David	Issue #2 Feb 16, 2019	Andrew This text should be really splitted. "Также к записи Денис приложил два бланка писем..." is a new paragraph on the site. David The text starts with a new line, the text style is saved. Accepted by admin
Template #28 David	Issue #3 Feb 16, 2019	danya Headers not marked David These are not headings, but text with a specified font-size style. I don’t think it would be a good idea to select all the text in the headings which will have the specified style: font-size of a certain size. This may lead to other errors in other articles. Declined by admin
Template #29 Andrew	Issue #1 Feb 16, 2019	danya Headers not marked Andrew Okay, give me another page when "headers" are <b> with nested <span> with "color: #450e61; font-size: 16pt;". Declined by admin
Template #28 David	Issue #4 Feb 16, 2019	danya Image captions not marked David It's pretty hard to define such a figcaption. On this site, the captions of the photos are made differently. No class or id to define it Declined by admin
Template #29 Andrew	Issue #2 Feb 16, 2019	danya Image captions not marked Andrew Again: this is not possible to cover such cases, when "caption" is <span> with "text-align: center;" which in <b> which in <span> with "font-size: 10pt;" (or other combinations on this page). This is just a random markup. Declined by admin
Template #28 David	Issue #5 Feb 17, 2019	Andrew These links should really be in <related> tag David And how do you propose to identify them? All internal links to put in related? No class or id to define these links. The remaining three links are not material headings? Declined by admin
Template #28 David	Issue #6 Feb 17, 2019	Sergey Pomogaylenko sure, it should not be the problem Accepted by admin
Template #29 Andrew	Issue #4 Feb 17, 2019	Sergey Pomogaylenko is it related or not. if there is <related>-block than it must be in it too Andrew Yes. But when there's no mess in the markup. They decided to put the last link in <div>. I decided only to include links within <p> in related block for the sake of safety (and because this case with div is unique, I didn't expect that). Accepted by admin Since it's not possible to identify these links as related (simple <p> or <div>), it's acceptable to not format them as related. But since the template already did this, all the links should be formatted as related for consistency
Template #30 danya	Issue #1 Feb 17, 2019	Sergey Pomogaylenko links after "Материалы рубрики" can be identified like related links danya They are indicated in the article absolutely randomly, they can not be guaranteed to be recognized in all articles. Declined by admin
Template #28 David	Issue #7 Feb 17, 2019	Sergey Pomogaylenko There are on this site 1) free-style news articles and 2) special rubrics ("Записки астраханского натуралиста", "Астрахань: Я вспоминаю..."). In second case author can be easily identified by a regular viewing user and can be extracted from the article David Material rubrics are not related articles. How is the winter feeding of birds and peculiarities of the praying mantis sex life related? As I understand it, there should be one topic, but it turns out that the topics are different. Declined by admin
Template #29 Andrew	Issue #5 Feb 17, 2019	Sergey Pomogaylenko There are on this site 1) free-style news articles and 2) special rubrics ("Записки астраханского натуралиста", "Астрахань: Я вспоминаю..."). In second case author can be easily identified by a regular viewing user and can be extracted from the article Andrew It would be not good to not preserve "Ведущий рубрики" piece of text. But to preserve it, I would've needed to actually duplicate author name. In short, I think it's not that critical to not identify an author on pages like this. Declined by admin
Template #30 danya	Issue #2 Feb 17, 2019	Sergey Pomogaylenko There are on this site 1) free-style news articles and 2) special rubrics ("Записки астраханского натуралиста", "Астрахань: Я вспоминаю..."). In second case author can be easily identified by a regular viewing user and can be extracted from the article danya I think this is not the author of the article, but something like the editor-in-chief of this column. Declined by admin
Template #29 Andrew	Issue #6 Feb 18, 2019	David This is not a related article. How are Caspian tigers related to poisonous plants? Andrew Why not make them related to improve UX? I think they can be considered related to a certain degree anyway. Declined by admin
Template #31 Sergey Pomogaylenko	Issue #1 Feb 18, 2019	David This is not a related article. How are Caspian tigers related to poisonous plants? Sergey Pomogaylenko Interesting question about link between tigers and plants, but why do you think that relationship of 2 articles defines only by similarity of object of the article? And besides they're both a nature. So what's my point. We have special rubrics. Every rubric dedicated to one theme ("Записки астраханского натуралиста" dedicated to flora and fauna and written by one naturalist, "Астрахань: Я вспоминаю..." is memories of one Astrakhan citizen). Articles in every rubric are written by one and only person ("Ведущий рубрики", and they are authors of articles sure enough). And these authors wnat their readers to see links to previous articles in their rubrics. So the add links to previous articles in the end of the article text. And add them manually (!). So we have authors, who continue their rubrics with new articles, and IV with <related>-block to deliver a better IV-reading experience to the users. So why not? And I can say more. These links are identifiable. So we have 2 options: 1) they are related and must be Declined by admin
Template #30 danya	Issue #3 Feb 19, 2019	Andrew Not all links has been preserved Accepted by admin
Template #33 David	Issue #1 Feb 20, 2019	danya Image captions not marked, it can be easely recognised David Not classs or id to identification figcaption. Declined by admin
Template #31 Sergey Pomogaylenko	Issue #3 Feb 20, 2019	Andrew Nothing wrong with the layout, but all the titles are missing in IV. Accepted by admin
Template #33 David	Issue #2 Feb 20, 2019	Andrew Line breaks are missing Accepted by admin
Template #31 Sergey Pomogaylenko	Issue #4 Feb 20, 2019	David The nested element must be fixed Sergey Pomogaylenko You wanted so much to write issue that found three years old news article with lost images, lost yt-videos and unsupported webm-video at the same time Declined by admin
Template #34 Andrew	Issue #2 Feb 20, 2019	David The nested element must be fixed Andrew If I even fix this presumably extremely rare issue, an IV wouldn't be generated anyway because of unreachable URLs. Declined by admin
Template #37 danya	Issue #1 Feb 22, 2019	Sergey Pomogaylenko normal image, must be found danya Sometimes on this site, links are in urlencode format, image links are converted via the urldecode function for correct display. The link is correct and nothing is deleted. If the pimg.mycdn.me service cannot process links in urldecode format, then where is my template? Here you created a claim on the links to images in the urlencode format: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/punkt-a.info/template34/issue3/ Accepted by admin
Template #36 David	Issue #1 Feb 22, 2019	Sergey Pomogaylenko normal image, must be found David Sometimes on this site, links are in urlencode format, image links are converted via the urldecode function for correct display. The link is correct and nothing is deleted. If the pimg.mycdn.me service cannot process links in urldecode format, then where is my template? Here you created a claim on the links to images in the urlencode format: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/punkt-a.info/template34/issue3/ Accepted by admin
Template #36 David	Issue #2 Feb 23, 2019	cescus I suspect they should be related articles David No class or id to identify these links. I do not think that this is a good implementation for creating linked links leading to the internal pages of the site at the end of the article without identification. Declined by admin
Template #36 David	Issue #3 Feb 23, 2019	Andrew Seems like you're using @urldecode for all links to support https://punkt-a.info/news/glavnoe/astrakhanskiy-aeroport-nachnut-pereimenovyvat-ne-ranshe-vesny, but this breaks even more pages. This one, for example, and https://punkt-a.info/news/glavnoe/astrakhan-ya-vspominayu-lyel-a-ya-v-kinishku-namylilsya- David Sometimes on this site, links are in urlencode format, image links are converted via the urldecode function for correct display. The link is correct and nothing is deleted. If the domsovet.tv service cannot process links in urldecode format, then where is my template? Here you created a claim on the links to images in the urlencode format: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/punkt-a.info/template34/issue3/ Accepted by admin
Template #48 David	Issue #1 Mar 1, 2019	Andrew Source is missing David There is no class or ID to identify the source, besides, the link is located outside the <blockquote> on the source page, and is also located in IV Declined by admin
Template #48 David	Issue #2 Mar 1, 2019	Andrew Not an issue (nevermind, I'm stupid, stupid scrolling) David Understood nothing Declined by admin
Template #48 David	Issue #3 Mar 1, 2019	Andrew I don't know what's going on here, but my template is able to handle this page David Do not believe it, but my template also supports this page. I do not know how you made it so that in the original it broke, judging by the code in the iframe. All meta headers were transferred to <body> judging by HTML, so it was not generated as IV, but I took the link, pasted it and reloaded the page: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/punkt-a.info/template48/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpunkt-a.info%2Fnews%2Fglavnoe%2Fv-astrakhanskoy-oblasti-budut-razvivat-zimnie -vidy-sporta As you can see the template generates IV Declined by admin Doesn't seem to be an issue with the template. Reloading the source page in this template generates an IV.

Processed Issues56

Log In