Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues30

This page shows a list of issues for nationalgeographic.com that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #2 Agung Wahyu	Issue #1 Jun 1, 2017	chuchu Same images in every article Accepted by admin
Template #1 Augusto Queiroz	Issue #1 Jun 1, 2017	chuchu Missing all images Accepted by admin
Template #5 chuchu	Issue #1 Jun 11, 2017	Yx No Instant View available chuchu Unsupported video player here Declined by admin Kindly resubmit with a link to a template that handles this case better.
Template #5 chuchu	Issue #2 Jun 13, 2017	Serhii No Instant View available. Who? chuchu Here is some embed graphics Declined by admin
Template #5 chuchu	Issue #3 Jun 13, 2017	Serhii for news not generate instant view chuchu Gallery is unsupported :( Declined by admin
Template #5 chuchu	Issue #4 Jun 17, 2017	Deleted Account Resubmitting declined issue. Next template handles this page properly: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/nationalgeographic.com/template6/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fnews.nationalgeographic.com%2F2017%2F06%2Fvaquita-mexico-fishing-agreement-marine-environment%2F Accepted by admin
Template #6 admin	Issue #1 Jun 17, 2017	chuchu Damn you're good. There is missing like half of content. Listicle items admin I am, thanks. Note to admin: there's missing "Listicle" content, but I believe that page source that IV gives to my template is not the same as view-source:URL of the page. I will resubmit this issue with information about an IV bug, if it is a bug, or resubmit my template, if it's my issue (need some time to investigate). Declined by admin Yes, he is. It's ok now. Accepted by admin The issue is solved for the new version of the template but it was still valid for the earlier version.
Template #7 chuchu	Issue #1 Jun 17, 2017	admin In my template it works. chuchu Gj if it's true. I'll check you and resubmit if so Accepted by admin
Template #10 admin	Issue #1 Jun 17, 2017	chuchu Good job, but here is some problem that should be fixed Accepted by admin
Template #11 chuchu	Issue #1 Jun 17, 2017	admin This gallery is not related to an article. They are neither related to the topic, nor "read more", just a random gallery at the end. chuchu So read more is optional :) Accepted by admin
Template #11 chuchu	Issue #2 Jun 17, 2017	admin This is not a cover on the source page. Missing first photo in the slideshow. Accepted by admin
Template #16 admin	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	chuchu Missing one more author admin I've reached the template size limit ("Sorry, your template is too big" when trying to save). Anyway, this one is not very critical, since it's not an author of article, but a credit for illustrations. Declined by admin It is acceptable to only include the author of the text.
Template #18 chuchu	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	admin So, let's the show start. 1. Page is not generated for target page: this page is suggested when you press "Add template" or "Check other templates" button. Accepted by admin Template #19 handles this page.
Template #18 chuchu	Issue #2 Jun 18, 2017	admin Rudimentary content not removed Accepted by admin
Template #18 chuchu	Issue #3 Jun 18, 2017	admin Missing an IV for a target page. Accepted by admin This page must generate IV. Template #19 supports it.
Template #19 admin	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	chuchu No IV admin I didn't support any more subdomains than I do already, including those you report, because I've reached a template size limit. Declined by admin The template creator really hit a size limit. There is not much he can do about it without removing working code.
Template #18 chuchu	Issue #4 Jun 18, 2017	admin Missing a big cover image. Accepted by admin The cover is required in this case.
Template #19 admin	Issue #2 Jun 18, 2017	chuchu There is no loss of information if you make slideshow out of gfx. Ofc loosing some visual feature, but content remain admin This interactive element must be unsupported, because usually this comparator tool is essential to images it contains. In all cases I've met this element it was essential: without it, it'd be very inconvenient and not clear for a reader why there's a slideshow with 2 visually the same pictures. Or it would just take too much time and pain for a reader to find a difference between them. This one is a good example of how usually this block used and why it's essential: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/nationalgeographic.com/template18/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fnews.nationalgeographic.com%2F2015%2F12%2F151229-before-after-earth-features%2F I slightly agree that in article you've reported this block is not that much essential, as in other articles. But I can't really do much here, because there's no way to identify in what cases this block is essential to images it contains, and in what articles it's not. If there would be such image comparator block in Telegram IV, I would support it in my template. Declined by admin While a slideshow can be generated instead of the widged on the original site, it's probably the best to @unsupport it. If the site's owner would have wanted to create a slideshow instead of using such a slidebar, they probably would have. As the template creator already wrote, this is used to display changes in things (like the lake he linked to) directly - overlaying. This should be preserved and it's not possible to display such stuff in IV yet.
Template #19 admin	Issue #3 Jun 18, 2017	chuchu You know there is a lot of pages on which both templates are fup admin I didn't support any more subdomains than I do already, including those you report, because I've reached a template size limit. Speaking about, as you say, "fup"'ing. Nope, for now I've found only one valid issue for my template, which is not very critical compared to other's templates. Declined by admin Duplicate issue #1
Template #18 chuchu	Issue #5 Jun 18, 2017	admin No IV Accepted by admin This page must generate IV. Template #19 supports it.
Template #18 chuchu	Issue #6 Jun 18, 2017	admin no iv Declined by admin Duplicated issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/nationalgeographic.com/template18/issue1/
Template #18 chuchu	Issue #7 Jun 18, 2017	admin No need to comment Accepted by admin
Template #18 chuchu	Issue #8 Jun 18, 2017	admin Nested lists must either be formatted, when possible, or just be marked unsupported. Accepted by admin
Template #19 admin	Issue #4 Jun 18, 2017	chuchu If u see nested lists, then you should format them, not mark unsupported admin This is not the case. While it's possible to format nested list of second level, it becomes impossible at level 3, 4 or more. This page visually (and logically) describes a discussion tree (level 1 – topic, level 2 – subtopics/questions, level 3 – answers/etc). In instant view it just becomes a garbarge-formatted text no matter how many <br>s or extra symbols you put inside of it. Especially when elements contain too much information, like in this case. There should be some ability to add padding for the text from IV side for cases like these. Declined by admin Marking nested lists as unsupported is legit. The reporter's template doesn't support those either. There hasn't been a good solution for 3 level nested lists yet, which look good on all devices.
Template #20 admin	Issue #1 Oct 6, 2017	Deleted Account http://yourshot.nationalgeographic.com/photos/11085885/ Declined by admin
Template #20 admin	Issue #2 May 28, 2018	V Date not removed Accepted by admin
Template #21 admin	Issue #1 Nov 10, 2018	Denis It's doesn't work admin Unsupported image gallery Declined by admin
Template #21 admin	Issue #2 Jan 25, 2019	Deleted Account Image notre being displayed Declined by admin Outdated IV
Template #21 admin	Issue #3 Feb 22, 2019	Anil Jacob (DU) Videos don’t play in Instant View. Would love to have this feature please? Thanks! Declined by admin Outdated IV
Template #21 admin	Issue #4 Jun 20, 2019	Akmal image is missing when the instant View is opened Declined by admin Outdated IV

Processed Issues30

Log In