The 2019 Instant View contest is over. View results
The Instant View Editor uses a three-column layout, so you really want to use it on a desktop screen that's wide enough. Sorry for the inconvenience.

Back to the main page »

Original

Preview

Link Preview

Issue #1

Current article - 2018
Article from related - 2019
So this block is dynamic and you shouldn't use it as related
Sergey Pomogaylenko
It is not dynamic so much to refuse of it.
3 related articles are from 2018 and one from march 2019. Obviously this list is not updated even every month. So I don't see any reasons to remove these useful for viewers links
Accepted by admin
The article's published date: 29/11/2018

Related articles' published dates:
19/03/2019
21/12/2018
21/12/2018
02/12/2018

All of them were published and added to this article later. That means there were different related articles or no articles at all at the moment when the article was published.
Sergey Pomogaylenko
Don't understand this decision.

I agree that we must not show related links if this list are modified often.
Or when it represents latest articles of some categories.

But this time links are related, from various periods, from different authors and from different subcategories.
Yes, they were added later.
It looks like they show the most related articles and this list is updated little by little when more related articles appear.
It explains why 3 of 4 related articles appeared in month from this article and only one newest 4 months later.

I see nothing bad in showing them because this list is not totally blinded and it was not incorrect at publication time too but became better later.
What is better for viewer this time? To lose possibility of going by related link at all or to save it?
Accepted by admin
Type of issue
Author added their own content
Reported
Apr 28 at 5:19 PM