Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues37

This page shows a list of issues for tverigrad.ru that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Лёня	Issue #1 May 25, 2017	Ali F VI Has errors Accepted by admin
Template #2 Ali F	Issue #1 May 28, 2017	Alexey Alekhin First image (which should be a cover) is missing Accepted by admin It is optional to use it as a cover, but it shouldn't be missing from the article.
Template #8 Fjalla Jokull	Issue #1 Jun 9, 2017	Alexey Alekhin Photos attribution is missing Fjalla Jokull This is not essential information, just like source links and is optional https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-7-source-links Declined by admin The important aspect is that caption descriptions are preserved. If choosing between displaying either caption descriptions or credits, the credits are optional, while description is required. Displaying both description + credits is acceptable as well.
Template #5 Alexey Alekhin	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	Fjalla Jokull video missing Accepted by admin Alexey Alekhin First, I do admit that this is a critical issue and it's correct. I'd like to argue though, that my template got rejected too fast, just before the end of the contest. If it was left with the issue after the contest end, it could still compete with other templates which may have critical issues as well. (See for example https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/tverigrad.ru/template8/issue5/ with broken content). About the issue itself: this is a single video article and the video is outside of the article container that usually holds all article-related things. I fixed this issue by adding just one line to my template. The issue is critical, but is very primitive. I wish I had an opportunity to be evaluated based on the present issues together with the competitor template (also taking into account the order of submission before my template got rejected). Accepted by admin Keep in mind that we look for the perfect template, not the one that made it better at this time. As you said, this issue is still valid, so it is not a perfect template, and we have already processed the issue you mentioned in the other template that was active. Thank you!
Template #8 Fjalla Jokull	Issue #5 Jun 19, 2017	Alexey Alekhin The whole text is formatted as a subtitle and videos that should be in the middle of the text are pushed out. Fjalla Jokull Hm. I really think that i submit version with this fixes. For some reason the version has not been published where it is fixed Accepted by admin
Template #9 Sergii	Issue #1 Aug 8, 2017	Vitaly Doronin Missing blockquote existing on the source https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#3-3-supported-elements Accepted by admin
Template #14 Fjalla Jokull	Issue #1 Feb 6, 2019	Виталя Time is not right Fjalla Jokull 6.1.2. ... The IV editor‘s ’Preview‘ section will always show the date/time in UTC format, while the ’Original' section may use a different time zone ... Declined by admin
Template #14 Fjalla Jokull	Issue #2 Feb 8, 2019	Deleted Account no instant view... Fjalla Jokull It looks like tg server problem. In console I see message "Resource fetch failed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tOng13bEO4". But i can open this video in browser . Declined by admin
Template #14 Fjalla Jokull	Issue #3 Feb 8, 2019	Сергей С Gallery incomplete. There's pagination at the bottom of the page. Also slideshow must not be generated in this case according to Checklist's 6.2.3: EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used: When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content. Accepted by admin
Template #17 Сергей С	Issue #1 Feb 9, 2019	Denis photos can be gallery Сергей С 6.2.3 in checklist: EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used: When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content. Declined by admin
Template #17 Сергей С	Issue #2 Feb 9, 2019	Denis video moved to bottom page Сергей С Yep. The source page has odd formatting Accepted by admin
Template #17 Сергей С	Issue #3 Feb 9, 2019	Vladislav Its non-target page. And the more it contains contacts. IV should not be generated. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-2-pages-that-require-significant-interaction Declined by admin
Template #17 Сергей С	Issue #4 Feb 9, 2019	Vladislav Its non-target page. And the more it contains contact info. IV should not be generated. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-2-pages-that-require-significant-interaction Сергей С Since this page doesn't have any interactive or dynamic components I doubt it should have exception. Declined by admin
Template #23 ‏Vsevolod T	Issue #1 Feb 11, 2019	Fjalla Jokull All photo's missing in IV Accepted by admin
Template #17 Сергей С	Issue #5 Feb 11, 2019	Fjalla Jokull Article contains two pages of photos. Missing pagination (at article bottom) Сергей С Links to pages replaced with a link to a page with full slideshow Accepted by admin
Template #17 Сергей С	Issue #6 Feb 11, 2019	Vladislav Broken video content order Accepted by admin
Template #17 Сергей С	Issue #7 Feb 11, 2019	Vladislav IV should be generated. Look my template Declined by admin
Template #31 Сергей С	Issue #1 Feb 13, 2019	Vladislav Missing voting on current page Сергей С Nice catch! Accepted by admin The voting is the main purpose of the article, no IV should be shown in this case. Сергей С Please check https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/tverigrad.ru/template31/issue2/ Accepted by admin Since there's no way to determine whether the poll is essential or not, all pages with polls must be unsupported
Template #31 Сергей С	Issue #2 Feb 13, 2019	Сергей С I was in a bit of hurry to send comment on this issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/tverigrad.ru/template31/issue1/ so I write an append to that issue This site often place polls at the article. In most cases this is not an essential content: https://tverigrad.ru/publication/novaya-krysha-starojj-kormushki-ili-kak-administraciya-tveri-poteryala-dengi-i-kontrol-nad-rynkom-na-ulice-ordzhonikidze So I think marking it unsupported is a bad idea since we have no reliable way to check essentiality of polls. BTW: "Checklist 6.4.3 Auxiliary widgets" mention this case: Some pages include unsupported widgets that are not essential for the understanding of the article. ... Some websites include “And what would you do?” votes at the end of some of their articles to increase user engagement. Declined by admin Since there's no way to determine whether the poll is essential or not, all pages with polls must be unsupported
Template #36 Сергей С	Issue #1 Feb 14, 2019	Vladislav Page must be generate without voting because voting is not target of article. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-3-auxiliary-widgets Сергей С My template has been rejected due to voting widget, saying that this is the main purpose of the article. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/tverigrad.ru/template31/issue1/ I understand that this case is kinda rare, making good articles unsupported. Moreover - votings ends in a week. And that's the huge sacrifice. But there is no reliable way to check if voting is the main purpose or not. And relying on admin's decision I marked it unsupported. Declined by admin See: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/tverigrad.ru/template31/issue2/
Template #36 Сергей С	Issue #2 Feb 15, 2019	Vladislav Need IV for this page. The site has many polls that are not relevant to the purpose of the article, so these widgets should be ignored, and pages display Declined by admin See: https://tverigrad.ru/publication/tverskoe-pole-ehksperimentov-za-problemami-regiona-pri-perekhode-na-cifrovoe-televeshhanie-sledit-vsya-rossiya
Template #34 Fjalla Jokull	Issue #2 Feb 16, 2019	Сергей С Wrong header for related articles Fjalla Jokull There is no rules in Perfect Template Checklist of what the header should be or should not be. The main rule - It is obligatory to format “Related articles” links using the new <related> tag. It's done. Accepted by admin When IV handles <related> block on mobile, it will generate the title, desc, and image preview of the related link on its own. If the template itself includes the related link's title, the title will get duplicated. So unfortunately, Anton, this is a valid issue. Fjalla Jokull I agree. After the explanation, I understood how this new tag would work. Unfortunately, this is why I don’t want to participate in the competition anymore... https://telegra.ph/Why-I-dont-want-to-participate-in-the-second-IV-Contest-anymore-02-18 Accepted by admin
Template #36 Сергей С	Issue #3 Feb 18, 2019	admin Rudimentary content "Показать слайдшоу" not removed Accepted by admin Сергей С I thought explicit link to the slideshow could be useful and append it to body. Anyway slideshows on that site are kind of broken so I removed it in the current version. Accepted by admin
Template #48 Vladislav	Issue #1 Feb 18, 2019	admin The page with active poll shouldn't generate IV, since there's no way to determine whether the poll is essential pare of the article or not Accepted by admin
Template #49 Сергей С	Issue #1 Feb 18, 2019	Vladislav IV should be generated. My template correctly processes this page Declined by admin
Template #49 Сергей С	Issue #2 Feb 19, 2019	Deleted Account it is not in italic form Declined by admin
Template #49 Сергей С	Issue #3 Feb 20, 2019	Vladislav Missing sitename Accepted by admin
Template #56 Сергей С	Issue #1 Feb 21, 2019	Vladislav Missing footer paragraph: "Фото: Павел Макаров" Сергей С It is at the bottom of the page Declined by admin
Template #56 Сергей С	Issue #2 Feb 21, 2019	Vladislav IV should not be generated https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/tverigrad.ru/template31/issue1/ @Accepted by admin Since there's no way to determine whether the poll is essential or not, all pages with polls must be unsupported@ Сергей С This is voting results. Nothing unsupported here. Accepted by admin Сергей С The page don't have any interactive content. When the page has active voting widget my template marks it unsupported. Accepted by admin
Template #60 Сергей С	Issue #1 Feb 26, 2019	Vladislav Page should begenerate IV, this page has not a unsupported elements. My template fully supports similar pages Сергей С Converting nested tables to something acceptable for IV engine could be dangerous. Declined by admin
Template #60 Сергей С	Issue #2 Feb 26, 2019	Vladislav Missing a video Сергей С This page is pretty old and rendered in IV exactly as in browser: with no video. Declined by admin
Template #60 Сергей С	Issue #3 Feb 26, 2019	‏Vsevolod T There is interactive map on the original page Accepted by admin
Template #63 Сергей С	Issue #1 Feb 27, 2019	Vladislav IV slould be generated, this page has not a unsupported elements. My template fully supports similar pages Сергей С Converting nested tables to something acceptable for IV engine could be dangerous. While it's possible to adapt this particular table it doesn't have any special markup and cannot be relliably identified. Next time when author will change layout we'll get corrupted IV. So it's safer to mark it unsupported. Declined by admin
Template #63 Сергей С	Issue #2 Mar 1, 2019	is summer missing iv Accepted by admin
Template #67 Vladislav	Issue #1 Mar 2, 2019	‏Vsevolod T Page with "online" translation Vladislav This is static article by old broadcast of 2017 year... Declined by admin Accepted by admin On the other hand it seems the template has no rules regarding online broadcasts. So future ones will generate IV. Since it's possible to identify online broadcasts by div class="online_trans", they should be marked as unsupported Vladislav Admin, other templates skipped VK post (https://c2n.me/40ff0XR): https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/tverigrad.ru/template75/?url=https%3A%2F%2Ftverigrad.ru%2Fpublication%2Finkviziciya-dlya-pankov-ili-kak-proshlo-nashestvie-2018-v-tverskojj-oblasti https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/tverigrad.ru/template76/?url=https%3A%2F%2Ftverigrad.ru%2Fpublication%2Finkviziciya-dlya-pankov-ili-kak-proshlo-nashestvie-2018-v-tverskojj-oblasti Also: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/tverigrad.ru/template76/?url=https%3A%2F%2Ftverigrad.ru%2Fpublication%2Fiz-za-otsutstviya-otopleniya-v-poselke-pod-tveryu-zakryli-shkolu-i-detskijj-sad Accepted by admin We don't accept issues for other templates in appeals. That's unfair to other participants, since they're unable to answer and to prove their point. Also all participants had at least 3 days to properly report issues
Template #67 Vladislav	Issue #2 Mar 2, 2019	‏Vsevolod T Missing image from meta in link preview Vladislav ... Nice problem! Page with video hasn't preview img... 👍 Good work 👍 Declined by admin
Template #74 Сергей С	Issue #1 Mar 2, 2019	‏Vsevolod T Missing image from meta in link preview Declined by admin

Processed Issues37

Log In