Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues23

This page shows a list of issues for blog.codinghorror.com that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #3 José Sazo	Issue #1 May 26, 2017	Nuzz wit da ㌩ Static blog post without very complicated content, so should have an instant view page. Declined by admin Issues regarding articles with unsupported content (such as tables) may be considered if they include a link to a template that handles the disputed content well.
Template #6 David Martínez Rubio	Issue #1 May 26, 2017	Odwalla Blog post should work (https://instantview.telegram.org/my/blog.codinghorror.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.codinghorror.com%2Fthunderbolting-your-video-card%2F) David Martínez Rubio Nope, it contains not supported content Accepted by admin
Template #7 Odwalla	Issue #1 May 27, 2017	David Martínez Rubio Image is missing Accepted by admin The image is missing.
Template #8 David Martínez Rubio	Issue #1 May 27, 2017	Odwalla Eliminated author name and url Accepted by admin
Template #9 Odwalla	Issue #1 May 27, 2017	David Herrmann Author is known and can be found in source, but is missing. Odwalla As you said he is known, so there is no need to add him in the info, because this is his personal blog so he is the only writer Accepted by admin The author name is required.
Template #10 David Herrmann	Issue #1 May 28, 2017	David Martínez Rubio This should have an IV David Herrmann Thanks for your feedback! The page has a table with more than three columns – quoting https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-8-1-tables: "Three-column tables and more complex tables should be tagged as @unsupported." In my opinion this is not a valid issue. Declined by admin
Template #11 David Martínez Rubio	Issue #1 May 28, 2017	David Herrmann Table with more than two columns should not be supported: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-8-1-tables Accepted by admin
Template #10 David Herrmann	Issue #2 May 28, 2017	David Martínez Rubio This doesn't have to have a IV because it contains not supported content, but this should show there is no instant view for this instead of crashing with an ELEMENT_NOT_SUPPORTED error David Herrmann Thanks for your feedback! It is not crashing – I believe this is the correct behaviour described here: https://instantview.telegram.org/docs#unsupported. In my opinion this is not a valid issue. Declined by admin
Template #10 David Herrmann	Issue #3 May 28, 2017	David Martínez Rubio Video source not found. This should have an IV like this one https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/blog.codinghorror.com/template12/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.codinghorror.com%2Fon-parenthood%2F Also, with respect to issue 2, I think every instant view that appears with a red frame is wrong, even if you have labelled the table with @unsupported, but it could be I'm wrong. Accepted by admin
Template #12 David Martínez Rubio	Issue #1 May 28, 2017	David Herrmann Empty paragraph not removed. David Martínez Rubio I don't see why I should remove this, the author wrote a <br> in the original article for the reasons he had, it's part of the article Declined by admin
Template #12 David Martínez Rubio	Issue #2 May 29, 2017	David Herrmann Regarding to https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-8-1-tables, tables should either be "rendered into lists without loss of information and legibility" or IV should not be available at all. Accepted by admin
Template #9 Odwalla	Issue #2 May 29, 2017	David Herrmann There should be a separation between the table columns: "Infinite15" should be "Infinite 15" or "Infinite: 15". Accepted by admin The table should be represented better.
Template #13 David Herrmann	Issue #1 May 30, 2017	Odwalla Why are " :" appearing at some point in the table? There is no one in the original Accepted by admin
Template #14 Odwalla	Issue #1 May 30, 2017	Artem Mangilev The previous article is not related to this article. The author specified at the beginning of the article Odwalla You are double wrong because: 1. Navigation it's only simple link (as written in https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#4-content-to-be-removed) 2. I'm not removing the important disclaimer pararaph Declined by admin
Template #15 Odwalla	Issue #1 May 30, 2017	David Herrmann Colons at the end of the lines should be removed, they don't exist in the original. Declined by admin Duplicated issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/blog.codinghorror.com/template9/issue2/
Template #3 José Sazo	Issue #2 Jun 4, 2017	Odwalla Reference template for https://blog.codinghorror.com/password-rules-are-bullshit Accepted by admin Odwalla's template supports the article nicely. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/blog.codinghorror.com/template18/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.codinghorror.com%2Fpassword-rules-are-bullshit%2F
Template #16 David Herrmann	Issue #1 Jun 13, 2017	Yx No Instant View available Declined by admin Kindly resubmit with a link to a template that handles this case better.
Template #18 Odwalla	Issue #1 Jun 13, 2017	Yx No Instant View available Declined by admin The original article contains complex tables. Complex tables are unsupported content. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-8-1-tables
Template #19 David Martínez Rubio	Issue #1 Jun 13, 2017	Yx No Instant View available David Martínez Rubio It contains not supported content, in particular tables with 3 columns or more Declined by admin Kindly resubmit with a link to a template that handles this case better.
Template #16 David Herrmann	Issue #2 Jun 16, 2017	Odwalla Quote text appears as one block, but it's not Accepted by admin
Template #19 David Martínez Rubio	Issue #2 Jun 16, 2017	Odwalla Quote isn't rendering right, shouldn't appear as one single block Accepted by admin
Template #20 Odwalla	Issue #1 Jun 17, 2017	David Martínez Rubio Rudimentary content not removed (actually, this is optional content, but in case of including it, you have to add all of them. What you have now is only a particular sentence of a whole paragraph) Odwalla The rest of paragraph is redundant infos like author name and its url Declined by admin Not critical.
Template #20 Odwalla	Issue #2 Jun 18, 2017	David Martínez Rubio Answer to the reply of issue 1 (https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/blog.codinghorror.com/template20/issue1/): No, it's as much as redundant as the sentence you have kept. It is something it is shown in every article and "Indoor enthusiast. Co-founder of Stack Overflow and Discourse. " or the url of author is as important as the disclaimer. As I said in the previous issue, this text is optional but if you leave it there you should leave everything, not just a sentence in the paragraph Declined by admin Not critical.

Processed Issues23

Log In