Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues35

This page shows a list of issues for kk.no that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #4 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #1 Apr 16, 2019	Hlib NO IV for target page Danil Dunaitsev This is dynamic page with live timer and unsupported iframes. Declined by admin
Template #4 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #2 Apr 16, 2019	Hlib 3.2. Link preview The link preview must include a photo if a suitable image or document exist in the source. If the page has a cover but the meta data contains no image or contains the generic site logo, you must use the cover as the photo. link preview is wrong. must be cover Danil Dunaitsev It's suitable. This is image from meta. It has priority over cover. Declined by admin
Template #4 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #3 Apr 16, 2019	Hlib Table is broken, your template must repair it Danil Dunaitsev >> 2010 year Table isn't broken. It is absolutely the same as in the original article. Look at the original or check source code. Declined by admin
Template #4 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #4 Apr 16, 2019	Hlib List must be without rudimentary symbols Danil Dunaitsev Why they are rudimentary? The original article contains these characters, so my template must contain them too. Declined by admin https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-5-4-ancient-lore
Template #4 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #5 Apr 16, 2019	Hlib author is wrong Danil Dunaitsev <span class="firstname">All Over Press</span> This tag always contains the author on this site. https://i.imgur.com/zx1mnS0.png Declined by admin
Template #4 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #6 Apr 16, 2019	Hlib XCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used: Unrelated images end up collected in the slideshow (e.g. an illustration and a disclaimer). When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content. When the article uses images/videos/GIFs with captions as the main medium (e.g.: travel blogs that show many photos with captions, step-by-step crafting guides, cooking recipes, etc.). no need slideshow, images are going step by step about make up Danil Dunaitsev This is exactly a slideshow. https://i.imgur.com/VjeZ4nO.png Declined by admin
Template #4 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #7 Apr 16, 2019	Hlib too many related Danil Dunaitsev Exactly the same amount as in the original article. Declined by admin
Template #4 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #8 Apr 18, 2019	Saturn Missing the whole slideshow at the top. Accepted by admin
Template #10 Saturn	Issue #1 Apr 19, 2019	Heck Fy This page contains video that can be supported by IV after simple transformation. Both my and d3's templates do this. Accepted by admin
Template #14 Saturn	Issue #1 Apr 22, 2019	Heck Fy Part of related articles are missing Saturn I truncated them to 5. It's advisable to do it, you have 13 there. Declined by admin
Template #17 Saturn	Issue #1 Apr 24, 2019	Deleted Account Wrong title and duplicated in text Accepted by admin
Template #15 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #2 Apr 24, 2019	Deleted Account Wrong title Danil Dunaitsev Authors suddenly change title's class 🤔 Accepted by admin
Template #18 Saturn	Issue #6 Apr 25, 2019	Heck Fy This page has unsupported videos. Accepted by admin video is missing
Template #26 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #2 Apr 28, 2019	T•m missing gallery Accepted by admin
Template #26 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #3 Apr 28, 2019	T•m gallery in the original content Danil Dunaitsev There are only 2 paragraphs of text. Therefore, I do not use the slideshow here. EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used: - When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content. - When the article uses images/videos/GIFs with captions as the main medium Accepted by admin 2 paragraphs != "entirely of a slideshow". This is a normal article with a slideshow.
Template #25 Saturn	Issue #1 Apr 28, 2019	Danil Dunaitsev Video from original article is missing Accepted by admin
Template #24 Heck Fy	Issue #5 Apr 28, 2019	Danil Dunaitsev Video from original article is missing Accepted by admin
Template #27 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #1 Apr 28, 2019	Heck Fy > Sometimes, a cover is less desirable: > In single-image, single-video, or single-GIF articles with no significant text. Danil Dunaitsev Not an issue "less desirable" not equal "obligatory" Declined by admin
Template #30 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #1 Apr 28, 2019	Heck Fy This element is hidden in the original article. Danil Dunaitsev Not my fault. Site's bug. Declined by admin Not reliably identifiable
Template #32 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #1 May 1, 2019	Saturn Related items are mentioned in article, should not be formatted as <related>. I finally found the accepted issue here https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/mononews.gr/template2/issue1/, admin left a detail explanation. Danil Dunaitsev This isn't common case in this site. This is an isolated case. No one during the entire competition could ever find another similar situations. "Se noen av kandidatene som har blitt nye med KK i 2018 her:" means "See some of the candidates who have become new with KK in 2018 here:" Main word is "Some" - This is not a complete list, it does not mean that all articles will be listed. Even if for some pages will not be supported it does not change anything. We can even check manually that the pages from this list are supported. For the sake of one article, turning all related articles into regular links seems to me a bad idea. If you do this, then all other articles on the entire site will be contain rudimentary content. Let's check in reporter's template: https://www.kk.no/mote/her-blir-halima-21-historisk/71027476 Is it okay that in the middle of an article there is an image with a link that is not part of the article? Is it normal that one image is big and the other is small? It just looks awful. https:/ Accepted by admin These aren't related articles: this is a list of candidates with links ("See some of the candidates who have become new with KK in 2018 here:")
Template #33 Saturn	Issue #1 May 1, 2019	Heck Fy This element is hidden in the original article. The element has attributes to reliably identify it: <div data-cke-hidden-sel="1" data-cke-temp="1" style="position:fixed;top:0;left:-1000px">Må</div> It is not broken markup and not site's bug. It intended to be hidden from the user. So I consider it as a rudimentary content. It should be removed. Other templates handle this well, please see latest template by d3: http://tiny.cc/ibb15y or mine: http://tiny.cc/kcb15y Accepted by admin
Template #33 Saturn	Issue #2 May 1, 2019	Heck Fy There should be a divider (hr) before this block because this block is in frame on the original site. This frame separates this block from the surrounding content. In my opinion we should preserve this separation in IV too. Other templates do this. See for example template by d3: http://tiny.cc/otb15y or mine. Accepted by admin Saturn no, this one is nested in div.columns > div.row without any prev-sibling::, I don't think we can detect it reliably unless we add hr before without detecting prev-sibling::. Accepted by admin <aside class="panel"> seems suitable
Template #37 Heck Fy	Issue #1 May 2, 2019	Saturn extra hr added, you should detect prev-sibling here. Heck Fy I don`t think it is critical Declined by admin Duplicate (issue 2 was accepted)
Template #37 Heck Fy	Issue #2 May 2, 2019	Saturn extra hr, you should detect next-sibling::* first. Heck Fy I don`t think it is critical. Accepted by admin
Template #37 Heck Fy	Issue #3 May 3, 2019	Roie Ambulo Hey man, just wanted to let you know that this issue is actually valid https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/kk.no/template37/issue2/ Better to fix your template, resubmit and report valid issues on your opponents before the time runs off. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/lokal.hu/template11/issue1/ Heck Fy Thank you very much, Roie) I'l try Accepted by admin Declined by admin This is valid, but issue 1/2 were reported first.
Template #40 Vladislav	Issue #1 May 3, 2019	Saturn there're two authors in the source. Accepted by admin
Template #44 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #1 May 3, 2019	Saturn there're two authors in the source. Accepted by admin
Template #49 Saturn	Issue #1 May 3, 2019	Heck Fy Cover image is duplicated in article body. If I understand the rules correctly, it is a valid issue: > The cover must not be set if: > The cover image is duplicated in the article. Other examples of pages with the same problem: https://www.kk.no/samliv/disse-bryllupstrendene-blir-store-i-2018/69560714 https://www.kk.no/helse/5-tips-som-gjor-deg-til-en-superloper/67794386 https://www.kk.no/helse/slik-kan-du-trene-styrke-ute/67823726 The article is recent (2016). Saturn r u kidding? they are duplicated in the source, check https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/mynintendonews.com/template13/issue3/ Declined by admin
Template #52 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #1 May 3, 2019	Heck Fy Cover image is duplicated in article body. If I understand the rules correctly, it is a valid issue: > The cover must not be set if: > The cover image is duplicated in the article. Other examples of pages with the same problem: https://www.kk.no/samliv/disse-bryllupstrendene-blir-store-i-2018/69560714 https://www.kk.no/helse/5-tips-som-gjor-deg-til-en-superloper/67794386 https://www.kk.no/helse/slik-kan-du-trene-styrke-ute/67823726 The article is recent (2016). Danil Dunaitsev This rule means that if you take an image from an article as a cover, then this image should no longer be in the body of the article, only as a cover. In the links that you provided the cover exists and I use this image. I do not take the image from the body of the article. I did not add anything, all same as in the original article. Declined by admin
Template #50 Vladislav	Issue #2 May 3, 2019	Heck Fy Cover image is duplicated in article body. If I understand the rules correctly, it is a valid issue: > The cover must not be set if: > The cover image is duplicated in the article. Other examples of pages with the same problem: https://www.kk.no/samliv/disse-bryllupstrendene-blir-store-i-2018/69560714 https://www.kk.no/helse/5-tips-som-gjor-deg-til-en-superloper/67794386 https://www.kk.no/helse/slik-kan-du-trene-styrke-ute/67823726 The article is recent (2016). Vladislav SO as on original page Declined by admin
Template #49 Saturn	Issue #2 May 3, 2019	Danil Dunaitsev IV shouldn't be generated. All horoscope articles (https://www.kk.no/horoskop/) are only accessible to logged in users https://i.imgur.com/SKrQvL0.png 2.4. Inaccessible pages - Pages that are only accessible to logged in users, etc. Accepted by admin
Template #52 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #3 May 4, 2019	Heck Fy This page has videos here. Strangely enough the first one is ok. But other two are not there. Danil Dunaitsev It's strange. Everything worked fine. I don't know what's happen. Accepted by admin
Template #53 Heck Fy	Issue #3 May 4, 2019	Danil Dunaitsev Rudimentary advertisement image Heck Fy Seems like I didn't noticed it because it is invisible) Accepted by admin If you view it in mobile IV, it'll be a large blank space in the IV, since it gets upscaled to full screen width.
Template #52 Danil Dunaitsev	Issue #4 May 4, 2019	Danil Dunaitsev https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/kk.no/template52/issue3/ I have a typo inside the map function, so only the first video works. Sad. Now fixed. Declined by admin
Template #50 Vladislav	Issue #4 May 5, 2019	Heck Fy Supporting issues #1 and #2 - OK, and where is the link in this case? Vladislav You still can not calm down?)) Accepted by admin Yes, it looks like there should be a video there but it's missing (and no link).

Processed Issues35

Log In