Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues21

This page shows a list of issues for privet-rostov.ru that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #2 Евгений	Issue #1 May 27, 2017	ARX8x missing author name and url Евгений reread 6.1 its says "Author name is required only if it is presented in the source article in a clear way" And this hidden nicknames in the title, like "Helena" or "energy" is fake pages. If i will add these fake nicks that cant be finded in original page, what changed? Declined by admin
Template #2 Евгений	Issue #2 May 27, 2017	ARX8x whitesapces Евгений Minor issue but will fix ofc. Declined by admin This isn't a critical issue indeed.
Template #4 ARX8x	Issue #1 May 28, 2017	Алексей Images from the article can be put as a cover if it is directly under the heading. Author takes any first image, wherever it is. ARX8x As stated in 3.1, The main image can be shown as cover on IV page if a suitable image exists in the source. These images are very suitable as cover images and don't break any conditions in 6.3 This website has the first image that's suitable for cover and are obvious. Same is used as OG image. Go through a few pages and you'll see what I mean Declined by admin It is optional to add a cover in this case: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-cover-images
Template #5 Евгений	Issue #1 May 28, 2017	Алексей Images from the article can be put as a cover if it is directly under the heading. The author takes any first image, wherever it is. Евгений The rules dont forbid cut out images that is common wallpaper. Rules says its optional, but not forbid. In my opinion its looks better as cover, and supports target IV style. Declined by admin Covers are optional.
Template #4 ARX8x	Issue #2 May 31, 2017	Алексей The author's name on this site is the nickname of the editor's profile. This is hidden information that the user does not see during normal viewing of the site. See the checklist, 6.1. Author name. ARX8x It's says where author name is a requirement. It also says what you must prefer when you have conflicting author names in meta information and on page. Notice the wording here "It is possible to omit" which is phrased in such a way to tell you that it's possible to omit without making it a valid issue. Nothing there says I can't use an author name in the source which is confirmed to be the author name. Declined by admin The author does have a point.
Template #4 ARX8x	Issue #3 May 31, 2017	Алексей The author pulled out the image from the article and inserted it as a cover. After the text "Вот что осталось от деревьев..." there are images that are connected by meaning with this phrase. Accepted by admin Yes, this is a valid issue, as described here: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-cover-images Several images appear in sequence, it's not advisable to pull out one of them to create a cover.
Template #5 Евгений	Issue #2 May 31, 2017	Алексей The author pulled out the image from the article and inserted it as a cover. After the text "Вот что осталось от деревьев..." there are images that are connected by meaning with this phrase. Евгений These images all connected with article theme, and this phrase dont connected with imange like its a infographic. If you look at other images and the article theme you see that your issue is wrong. All images of this article connected by meaning to the article TITLE and second is this little phrase. Accepted by admin When several images appear in sequence it is not advisable to break it by extracting one of them as a cover. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-cover-images
Template #8 David	Issue #1 Jun 10, 2017	Евгений date not parsed Accepted by admin
Template #13 Евгений	Issue #1 Jun 10, 2017	Алексей Missing line breaks Accepted by admin
Template #15 Евгений	Issue #1 Jun 10, 2017	Алексей Why <p><em></ em></ p> make a quote? These are just italic paragraphs. There's no ID or class that's a quote. Accepted by admin
Template #16 Алексей	Issue #1 Jun 10, 2017	Евгений author not parsed Алексей It's so stupid. The author is not specified anywhere, and only here at the end of the page in the last paragraph. It's just a paragraph, with no id or class. It is possible to get the author by regex, but this is not a global solution, which can also incorrectly identify the author on other pages. Accepted by admin Author name is required if it is presented in the very end of the text. Looks like authors located in a same place on the http://privet-rostov.ru
Template #18 Евгений	Issue #1 Jun 12, 2017	David If the author is the person who posted the article. Then according to printable version: http://privet-rostov.ru/gorod/print:page,1,321-parkovochnye-mesta-dlya-invalidov-v-rostove-otmetili-rezonansnymi-znakami.html the author is not specified at the end of the article, and is specified as the user who posted the article http://privet-rostov.ru/user/energy/ Евгений "Разместил: energy" means he is just posted, not author. Author of the article is "Евгения Новикова" Declined by admin 'Евгения Новикова' is the author, as it is mentioned at the end of the article: 'Евгения Новикова' specially for 'Privet-Rostov.ru'. Also she is mentioned in the printable version. And 'energy' is a person who posted this article.
Template #18 Евгений	Issue #2 Jun 15, 2017	David Admins, give the answer: If the author is the person who posted the article. Then according to printable version: http://privet-rostov.ru/gorod/print:page,1,321-parkovochnye-mesta-dlya-invalidov-v-rostove-otmetili-rezonansnymi-znakami.html the author is not specified at the end of the article, and is specified as the user who posted the article http://privet-rostov.ru/user/energy/ Declined by admin Duplicated issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/privet-rostov.ru/template18/issue1/
Template #23 Алексей	Issue #1 Jun 16, 2017	David The author of this article "Евгения Новикова" and not "energy". Accepted by admin
Template #18 Евгений	Issue #3 Jun 16, 2017	David This text is not the author of the article. Accepted by admin
Template #27 Евгений	Issue #1 Jun 16, 2017	David This page should not be. Accepted by admin
Template #30 David	Issue #1 Jun 17, 2017	Евгений still missing paragraphs Accepted by admin
Template #32 Евгений	Issue #1 Jun 17, 2017	David This page should be IV, as this article. Евгений Its service page, its need for printing. Check url have "print:page" Original url http://privet-rostov.ru/stroitelstvo/14730-propusknaya-sposobnost-yuzhnogo-podezda-k-rostovu-posle-rekonstrukcii-budet-uvelichena-do-120-tysyach-avtomobiley-v-sutki.html Declined by admin It's optional to generate IV for this page.
Template #32 Евгений	Issue #2 Jun 19, 2017	David Missing author article. Евгений author is right at the end of the article :D Declined by admin The author name is optional in this case.
Template #33 David	Issue #1 Jun 19, 2017	Евгений cover image not set David Yes, the cover is recommended but is not required. See paragraph 6.3 of the rules. Declined by admin The cover image is optional in this case.
Template #33 David	Issue #2 Jun 19, 2017	Евгений wrong order, image is after four paragraphs. and whole article is set to blockquote when its should not David Source text highlighted as a quote. Therefore, given the same as given in the original article. The change in source code can cause problems in the future Declined by admin

Processed Issues21

Log In