Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues48

This page shows a list of issues for termometropolitico.it that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #3 Matteo	Issue #2 Feb 4, 2019	Dario The cover image is duplicated in the article. Declined by admin It's also duplicated in the original article.
Template #4 Matteo Italia	Issue #1 Feb 4, 2019	Dario The cover image is duplicated in the article. Matteo Italia This is both the cover image that happens to be also an inline image, exactly as in the article; in particular, it's immediately referenced in the note below it ("nota metodologica allegata all'immagine" = "methodological note attached to the image"). it's not the template's business to meddle with the editorial style of the site. Declined by admin
Template #5 Dario	Issue #1 Feb 4, 2019	Luca Lumetti Is a link to another page, not related to the current page Declined by admin We will not accept issues based on ‘further reading’ links of any type being removed. We will also not accept issues based on ‘further reading’ links being present. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-2-cover-images
Template #4 Matteo Italia	Issue #2 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo This is not a subtitle Matteo Italia That's what the page itself reports as description, which most often makes for a good subtitle. Of course it's impossible that it will always be a "great" subtitle, but generally it's better than nothing. Accepted by admin
Template #5 Dario	Issue #2 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo This page is broken Dario Instant View page must not be generated because of unsupported (dynamic/interactive) content. Declined by admin We will only accept issues requesting to generate IVs for pages with content previously deemed unsupported if you include a link to a template that fully supports the content in question. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#unsupported-content
Template #6 Matteo	Issue #1 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia No IV generated for target page Accepted by admin
Template #5 Dario	Issue #4 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia IV not generated for a valid page Dario Instant View page must not be generated because of unsupported (dynamic/interactive) content. Declined by admin We will only accept issues requesting to generate IVs for pages with content previously deemed unsupported if you include a link to a template that fully supports the content in question. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#unsupported-content Even though this is supported in https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/termometropolitico.it/template7/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.termometropolitico.it%2Felezioni-politiche-2018 this is only possible by omitting important interactive content. The result is an incomplete IV which is highly undesirable. Declined by admin We will only accept issues requesting to generate IVs for pages with content previously deemed unsupported if you include a link to a template that fully supports the content in question. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#unsupported-content Even though this page is supported in https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/termometropolitico.it/template7/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.termometropolitico.it%2Felezioni-politiche-2018 this is only possible by omitting important interactive content. The result is an incomplete IV which is highly undesirable.
Template #6 Matteo	Issue #2 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia IV not generated for valid page Accepted by admin
Template #5 Dario	Issue #5 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia IV not generated for valid page Dario Instant View page must not be generated because of unsupported (dynamic/interactive) content. Accepted by admin The content you mentioned to be interactive are ads, it should be removed (4. Content to Be Removed of Cheklist). Template #21 generates IV for the page properly.
Template #6 Matteo	Issue #3 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia IV not generated for valid target page Accepted by admin
Template #6 Matteo	Issue #4 Feb 4, 2019	『Kyouin』 Title repetion Accepted by admin
Template #6 Matteo	Issue #5 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia The page is missing all the charts but the last one Matteo Can't be displayed since they are interactive objects Accepted by admin IV shouldn't be generated for pages with interactive objects
Template #7 Matteo Italia	Issue #1 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia The page is missing all the charts but the last one Declined by admin
Template #8 Dario	Issue #1 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia Missing IV for valid page Dario Instant View page must not be generated because of unsupported (dynamic/interactive) content. Declined by admin
Template #7 Matteo Italia	Issue #2 Feb 4, 2019	Dario The cover image is duplicated in the article. Matteo Italia This is both the cover image that happens to be also an inline image, exactly as in the article; in particular, it's immediately referenced in the note below it ("nota metodologica allegata all'immagine" = "methodological note attached to the image"). it's not the template's business to meddle with the editorial style of the site. Declined by admin
Template #8 Dario	Issue #2 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia IV page not generated Dario Instant View page must not be generated because of unsupported (dynamic/interactive) content. Declined by admin Duplicated issue
Template #8 Dario	Issue #3 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia Missing image-link Dario Banner that is not essential to the article in question must be removed. Declined by admin
Template #8 Dario	Issue #4 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia Missing IV for valid page Dario Instant View page must not be generated because of unsupported (dynamic/interactive) content. Declined by admin Duplicated issue
Template #8 Dario	Issue #5 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia Missing IV for valid page Dario Instant View page must not be generated because of unsupported (dynamic/interactive) content. Declined by admin
Template #7 Matteo Italia	Issue #3 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo This isn't the subtitle Accepted by admin
Template #8 Dario	Issue #6 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia Missing page Declined by admin Duplicated issue
Template #10 Matteo Italia	Issue #1 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo This is not the subtitle Accepted by admin
Template #8 Dario	Issue #7 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia The page is missing both charts, even though they are plain images (no dynamic content here) Accepted by admin
Template #12 Matteo Italia	Issue #1 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Author changed the page content Matteo Italia Given that most of the site contains charts, most of which are hosted through a handful of (currently not supported by IV) JS-based chart embedding services, I provided an external link to open them. The user is aware that a chart is missing (and can be readily be opened externally), but can still enjoy the article for a quick read. Declined by admin
Template #8 Dario	Issue #8 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia The page is missing both charts, even though they are both plain images (no dynamic content) Declined by admin Duplicated issue
Template #13 Matteo	Issue #1 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia The page is missing both charts, even though they are plain images (no dynamic content) Accepted by admin
Template #13 Matteo	Issue #2 Feb 4, 2019	Matteo Italia All charts have been silently removed, when they _can_ be provided Accepted by admin
Template #14 Matteo Italia	Issue #1 Feb 4, 2019	Dario Duplicated title Matteo Italia It's also there in the original page Accepted by admin Declined by admin
Template #16 Dario	Issue #1 Feb 5, 2019	Maks Chernenko Page doesn't work Declined by admin The source page contains a highly interactive embed. If essential content cannot be supported, then an IV should not be generated.
Template #16 Dario	Issue #2 Feb 5, 2019	Matteo Italia This page should be generated; it does have interactive content, but it can be rendered statically without problems (see my Template #17) Dario Replacing highly interactive content with static images could be misleading to users. Duplicate of issue #1 which is declined Declined by admin The source page contains a highly interactive embed. If essential content cannot be supported, then an IV should not be generated.
Template #16 Dario	Issue #3 Feb 5, 2019	Matteo Italia While this page contains interactive charts, they can be rendered statically just fine; see my Template #17 Dario Very similar to issues #1, #2 Accepted by admin In this case it's acceptable to render charts as images
Template #21 Matteo Italia	Issue #1 Feb 6, 2019	Duico This is not the title Matteo Italia Unfortunately IMO there's not much you can do about this. The page specifies completely different values for <title> ("Sondaggi politici elettorali. Medie di tutti i sondaggi"), og:title/twitter:title metadata (which is what I'm displaying here, as it's what the page author states that would like to see in the link preview) and <h1> ("Sondaggi Politici Elettorali"); none of these are what you would argue to be the real title (which only happens to be the first <h2> _in this page_). Switching the whole template to take the first <h2> and removing it from the article body would probably break lots of other stuff, so given that the "real" title is displayed anyway and no information is lost, I don't see any problem in leaving this like this. Accepted by admin The title is "Sondaggi Politici Elettorali" and it can be identified as a title for IV
Template #22 Matteo Italia	Issue #1 Feb 9, 2019	Darkcomet Missing video or link Accepted by admin
Template #23 Matteo Italia	Issue #1 Feb 9, 2019	Sherali Rysbekov Page content is missing Matteo Italia This is content to be removed, as per guidelines: 4. Content to Be Removed Anything that is not essential to the article in question should be removed from the Instant View page. - Footers removed - Social media links and buttons removed, including “Share” and “Like” links and buttons Declined by admin Matteo is right, the links are clearly identifiable on the source.
Template #26 Eaxon	Issue #1 Feb 10, 2019	A. No IV template for an article Eaxon One image in the article is inaccessible. Declined by admin
Template #23 Matteo Italia	Issue #2 Feb 12, 2019	Eaxon IV not generated for target page. Accepted by admin
Template #27 Matteo Italia	Issue #1 Feb 14, 2019	Eaxon Header is missing. Accepted by admin
Template #29 Matteo Italia	Issue #1 Feb 16, 2019	Eaxon Title is duplicated. Matteo Italia It's duplicated just as in the original page. Declined by admin
Template #29 Matteo Italia	Issue #2 Feb 16, 2019	Eaxon This image is used a link to another article. Matteo Italia "We will not accept issues based on ‘further reading’ links of any type being removed." Also, this banner has been the subject of a previous issue, which was accepted, requiring it to be removed. Declined by admin Declined by admin
Template #29 Matteo Italia	Issue #3 Feb 17, 2019	Eaxon “The date and time of publication is obligatory for news publications. It must be obtained by any means possible, including meta tags, etc.” Matteo Italia The date of publication is not provided in the page itself; although it is provided in the metadata, they - are not user-visible on the original site (so that would be "adding extraneous content") - have been proven completely unreliable on this site, down to the title of the page (see issue #1 on template #21 https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/termometropolitico.it/template21/issue1/) Declined by admin Since there's no date in the article content and in the meta, it's acceptable to not display it. Date extraction from URL isn't the safest solution anyway.
Template #29 Matteo Italia	Issue #4 Feb 18, 2019	admin It seems pages like these are dynamically updated during the event (elections in this case) Accepted by admin Matteo Italia This particular page is surely frozen (these elections happened last year), however I don't see any reliable way to detect these kinds of pages, if they fit the general "article" template. The pages of this kind that are currently visible all refer to past elections (so, they are frozen and are able safe targets for Instant Views), while for the future there's no safe way to find out what URLs they may use for articles being continuously updated. Accepted by admin These pages aren't articles, they are more like hubs with article links. It seems it's reflected in body classes: article-like pages have class "single-post" in <body> while hub-like pages don't. Also not all of them are correctly displayed in this template: https://www.termometropolitico.it/partiti-politici-italiani
Template #33 Eaxon	Issue #2 Feb 19, 2019	Matteo Italia Issue #4 of template #29 ("It seems pages like these are dynamically updated during the event (elections in this case)") applies here as well (https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/termometropolitico.it/template29/issue4/) Accepted by admin See details in that issue
Template #33 Eaxon	Issue #3 Feb 19, 2019	Ruslan S Duplicate title. Eaxon See: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/termometropolitico.it/template29/issue1/ Declined by admin
Template #34 Matteo Italia	Issue #1 Feb 20, 2019	Ruslan S This is not a quote. Declined by admin
Template #34 Matteo Italia	Issue #2 Feb 21, 2019	Ruslan S Link to related article. Declined by admin Not identifiable
Template #36 Ruslan S	Issue #1 Feb 21, 2019	『Kyouin』 Pic already in cover Declined by admin Source page duplicates the image
Template #34 Matteo Italia	Issue #3 Feb 21, 2019	Deleted Account Repeated image Matteo Italia It's there in the original article Declined by admin The source page duplicates the image
Template #36 Ruslan S	Issue #2 Feb 21, 2019	Deleted Account Repeated image Declined by admin Duplicate

Processed Issues48

Log In