Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues49

This page shows a list of issues for 9to5mac.com that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Julio César Carbajal Casillas	Issue #1 May 18, 2017	Kenny Might want to <u>remove</u> this as well. Accepted by admin
Template #1 Julio César Carbajal Casillas	Issue #2 May 18, 2017	Яхья Картоев Too many irrelevant elements Accepted by admin
Template #2 Rishabh Harit	Issue #1 May 18, 2017	Ol Need to edit quote Accepted by admin
Template #1 Julio César Carbajal Casillas	Issue #3 May 19, 2017	Sa IV displays social media links, embeded videos not related to the article and some ads. Accepted by admin
Template #1 Julio César Carbajal Casillas	Issue #4 May 19, 2017	Abkr Rudimentary content Accepted by admin
Template #3 Alex	Issue #1 May 19, 2017	Stanisław No Press Release text Accepted by admin
Template #5 Roman	Issue #1 May 19, 2017	Davide Marchetti Missing embedded video Accepted by admin
Template #5 Roman	Issue #3 May 19, 2017	Stanisław You should not generate IV for main page Accepted by admin
Template #9 Deleted Account	Issue #1 May 19, 2017	Stanisław No author Accepted by admin
Template #12 Sergio	Issue #1 May 22, 2017	Benjamin Ads not removed Accepted by admin
Template #16 Rishabh Harit	Issue #1 May 22, 2017	chuchu Ad Accepted by admin
Template #20 Davide Marchetti	Issue #1 May 22, 2017	Odwalla missing cover photo Accepted by admin
Template #22 chuchu	Issue #1 Jun 2, 2017	tommy The 'About' page should be supported by IV. It is not frequently updated. chuchu Look this issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/blivenews.com/template1/issue1/ So about pages don't need IV Declined by admin About, Contact, and similar pages are optional.
Template #26 Andrey Mesyats	Issue #1 Jun 5, 2017	admin 2.1 Pages with dynamic content Accepted by admin Dynamically updated pages would be outdated due to IVs being cached, so they should not generate an IV.
Template #27 Sergio	Issue #1 Jun 5, 2017	admin 2.1 Pages with dynamic content Sergio I think this will become a static page once the live is over, so it should be fine to have an IV for it Accepted by admin Dynamically updated pages would be outdated due to IVs being cached, so they should not generate an IV.
Template #31 ☄️	Issue #1 Jun 8, 2017	Ronny Gunawan ️ List of articles, should not generate IV ☄️ Not quite. This is a "guide", a category of a sort on 9to5mac; the list of articles is actually down below (see 9to5mac.com/guides/mac-pro for another example). You can tell the list of articles apart from the category itself by looking at wide black bars that say either "OVERVIEW" (this is the guide) or the date of an article (this is an article preview). Accepted by admin
Template #35 Ronny Gunawan ️	Issue #1 Jun 8, 2017	☄️ It's probably a good idea to generate an IV of this page (everything before the black bar saying "Mac Pro STORIES") Declined by admin Dynamically updated lists of articles = No IV
Template #33 Odwalla	Issue #1 Jun 10, 2017	☄️ Wrong order: on the original page the image follows the paragraph, not the other way around. Accepted by admin This isn't exactly critical, but since the template will have to be resubmitted anyway due to a different issue, it may be a good idea to fix this as well.
Template #35 Ronny Gunawan ️	Issue #2 Jun 10, 2017	☄️ Wrong order: on the original page the image follows the paragraph, not the other way around. Accepted by admin This isn't exactly critical, but since the template will have to be resubmitted anyway due to a different issue, it may be a good idea to fix this as well.
Template #33 Odwalla	Issue #2 Jun 10, 2017	☄️ Some number that are not on the page were not removed. Accepted by admin This isn't exactly critical, but since the template will have to be resubmitted anyway due to a different issue, it may be a good idea to fix this as well.
Template #35 Ronny Gunawan ️	Issue #3 Jun 10, 2017	☄️ Two missing images. Accepted by admin Images are essential content and can not be missed.
Template #35 Ronny Gunawan ️	Issue #4 Jun 10, 2017	☄️ The ad must be removed ("NordVPN" at the end of the paragraph is a part of the ad). Accepted by admin
Template #33 Odwalla	Issue #3 Jun 10, 2017	☄️ Lost image caption Accepted by admin Media captions must be shown on IV page, aligned under their corresponding media if captions exist in the source.
Template #39 ☄️	Issue #1 Jun 10, 2017	chuchu Well, even title says this is a poll. IV should not be generated for such pages. ☄️ Not true, see Checklist 6.8.3: "Some websites include “And what would you do?” votes at the end of some of their articles to increase user engagement. None of these should bother you. Simply remove such non-essential widgets from the article and go ahead with generating the IV page." Even though Polldaddy widgets aren't supported by telegram, you can still easily take a poll on Polldaddy website by following a "noscript" link at the end of the article. Declined by admin The template creator handled this thing here quite well. He included links for the polls AND was able to display the article's content.
Template #40 chuchu	Issue #1 Jun 14, 2017	☄️ Slide captions missing chuchu krasava Accepted by admin Captions are missing. Here is a better one: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/9to5mac.com/template43/?url=https%3A%2F%2F9to5mac.com%2F2016%2F06%2F13%2Fhands-on-apples-new-remote-app-for-apple-tv-and-ios-gallery%2F
Template #42 Egrgrgrgr	Issue #1 Jun 14, 2017	☄️ Ads Accepted by admin Since the template will have to be resubmitted anyway due to a different issue, it may be a good idea to fix this as well
Template #42 Egrgrgrgr	Issue #2 Jun 14, 2017	☄️ Slideshow and slide captions are missing Accepted by admin Captions should definitely be fixed: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-5-captions But not essential to convert to slideshow as it's not displayed as a conventional slideshow on the original site
Template #43 ☄️	Issue #1 Jun 14, 2017	chuchu Should be formatted correctly ☄️ Nice, thanks Accepted by admin
Template #42 Egrgrgrgr	Issue #3 Jun 15, 2017	Ronny Gunawan ️ List of articles, do not generate IV Accepted by admin Please see: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-iv-targets-must-not-generate
Template #42 Egrgrgrgr	Issue #4 Jun 15, 2017	Ronny Gunawan ️ Remove ads Accepted by admin Since the template will have to be resubmitted anyway due to a different issue, it may be a good idea to fix this as well
Template #42 Egrgrgrgr	Issue #5 Jun 15, 2017	Ronny Gunawan ️ Turn galleries into slideshows Declined by admin Not essential, as not shown as a conventional slideshow in the original page
Template #46 ☄️	Issue #1 Jun 15, 2017	Ronny Gunawan ️ Turn galleries into slideshows Accepted by admin
Template #50 chuchu	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	☄️ Missing gallery/slideshow, missing captions chuchu >news sites >2012 Accepted by admin This article is from 2012, at this stage this would normally be declined as a minor issue However as this template has already been rejected due to a different issue, it would be good to fix this too - if you get a chance to modify this template
Template #54 Ronny Gunawan ️	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	☄️ Missing gallery/slideshow, missing captions Accepted by admin This article is from 2012, at this stage this would normally be declined as a minor issue However as this template has already been rejected due to a different issue, it would be good to fix this too - if you get a chance to modify this template
Template #50 chuchu	Issue #2 Jun 18, 2017	☄️ Missing captions Accepted by admin Caption text must be displayed as such Please see: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-5-captions
Template #54 Ronny Gunawan ️	Issue #2 Jun 18, 2017	☄️ Missing captions Accepted by admin Misplaced caption-text has the potential to confuse a reader Please see: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-5-captions
Template #50 chuchu	Issue #3 Jun 18, 2017	☄️ Using images with empty @src is a bad idea. chuchu Damn, you are so smart Accepted by admin This article is from 2012, at this stage this would normally be declined as a minor issue However as this template has already been rejected due to a different issue, it would be good to fix this too - if you get a chance to modify this template
Template #54 Ronny Gunawan ️	Issue #3 Jun 18, 2017	☄️ Using images with empty @src is a bad idea. Accepted by admin This article is from 2012, at this stage this would normally be declined as a minor issue However as this template has already been rejected due to a different issue, it would be good to fix this too - if you get a chance to modify this template
Template #49 ☄️	Issue #1 Sep 7, 2017	Arthur Missing quote. Huge empty spaces. Accepted by admin
Template #49 ☄️	Issue #2 Sep 11, 2017	Evgeniy Slezhuk A lot of empty space in the middle of page Accepted by admin
Template #49 ☄️	Issue #3 Sep 11, 2017	Sergey Strange white images Declined by admin Duplicate
Template #49 ☄️	Issue #4 Sep 13, 2017	Denis Declined by admin
Template #55 ☄️	Issue #1 Oct 2, 2017	nyz Weird white photos Accepted by admin
Template #56 ☄️	Issue #1 Nov 15, 2017	Alijah Simon Doesn’t display full article. ☄️ It does. The video at the bottom is not a part of the article. Declined by admin
Template #56 ☄️	Issue #2 Dec 14, 2017	John Chevrolet Bulleted list does not format properly in the quote block. ☄️ ❔ It's formatted exactly as on the target page. Declined by admin
Template #56 ☄️	Issue #3 Dec 24, 2018	nyz There's a GIF advertisement at the bottom of the IV. ☄️ It's right in the article's body without special marking. There's no telling whether it's ads or author's content. Moreover, this particular GIF is related to the company, which is the subject of the article. Declined by admin
Template #56 ☄️	Issue #4 Dec 31, 2018	Nobody 🌞 I don't know the problem Declined by admin
Template #56 ☄️	Issue #5 Jan 10, 2019	nyz There's an advertisement at the bottom Declined by admin
Template #60 admin	Issue #1 Mar 6, 2020	Josh Google's the Robot, not me Declined by admin

Processed Issues49

Log In