Processed Issues49

This page shows a list of issues for farhangnews.ir that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Issue #1
May 21, 2017
this template doesn't have IV for this page (photo articles)
Accepted by admin
Template #3 Issue #1
Jun 4, 2017
When we have Date, the second one must be removed.
Ehsan Dehghani
who said that!
these are jalali and Gregorian date and different format for different people
Declined by admin
It's possible to preserve it.
Template #3 Issue #2
Jun 4, 2017
missing SlideShow
Declined by admin
Slideshow is optional here.

See https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-4-galleries-and-slideshows
Template #5 Issue #1
Jun 4, 2017
Cover image is duplicated in article.
Ehsan Dehghani
it's duplicated in source website too
Declined by admin
If the cover has a duplicate in the original article, it is fine to keep it this way.
Template #5 Issue #2
Jun 4, 2017
Video download link should be removed because it duplicates IV video element option to save videos and requires unnecessary interaction.
Ehsan Dehghani
there is nothing wrong about this kind of things that you say in issues
please read checklist first
Declined by admin
The link is a part of the article.
Template #7 Issue #1
Jun 4, 2017
Cover image is duplicated in article
Declined by admin
The original article duplicates the photo for cover. So this case is optional to show both photos or only one.
Template #7 Issue #2
Jun 4, 2017
This page should have IV
Accepted by admin
Template #7 Issue #3
Jun 4, 2017
This is an article containing video. According to the checklist:
"If it is not possible to represent the widget as an iFrame, but it is possible to get a direct link to the video, use this link to generate a <video> with the correct src attribute."
Declined by admin
See https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/farhangnews.ir/template7/issue2/
Template #10 Issue #1
Jun 7, 2017
You must not use"lead paragraphs" as subtitle in IV.
Also it's better to ignore the subtitle keyword in your IV; because many of Farhangnews's page has just one title, and if you want to use subtitle keyword in IV, you have two identical sentences which is bad. So just use title keyword.
for example:
http://www.farhangnews.ir/content/255262
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-11-subtitle
Accepted by admin
Template #7 Issue #4
Jun 7, 2017
You must not use"lead paragraphs" as subtitle in IV.
Also it's better to ignore the subtitle keyword in your IV; because many of Farhangnews's page has just one title, and if you want to use subtitle keyword in IV, you have two identical sentences which is bad. So just use title keyword.
for example:
http://www.farhangnews.ir/content/255262
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-11-subtitle
Declined by admin
Lead as subtitle is less desirable but not critical.
Template #8 Issue #1
Jun 7, 2017
The highlighted section is not subtitle.
It's wrong.
skrskrskr
It is subtitle
Declined by admin
Using a pre-headline as a subtitle is acceptable. We will consider issues that show why using the pre-headline in this manner may be a problem.
Template #5 Issue #3
Jun 7, 2017
The highlighted section is not subtitle.
It's wrong.
Also check out rule below:
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-11-subtitle
Ehsan Dehghani
it's a subtitle my friend!
Declined by admin
The subtitle is optional in this case.
Template #5 Issue #4
Jun 7, 2017
The "lead paragraph" is a part of the article's text.
You have added as subtitle. It's wrong.

You must rebuild your IV.

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-11-subtitle
Ehsan Dehghani
stop sending span issue!
this is not part of article
it's in the subtitle section in the source website
Declined by admin
Duplicated issue:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/farhangnews.ir/template5/issue3/
Template #11 Issue #1
Jun 11, 2017
subtitle is missing. The part that is selected in red box adds information to the title of article. According to the checklist:
"A subtitle is a subordinate title of a published work or article giving additional information about its content."
Accepted by admin
Saeed's template handles it better:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/farhangnews.ir/template16/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.farhangnews.ir%2Fcontent%2F255656
Template #11 Issue #2
Jun 11, 2017
main content are disordered in the article
Accepted by admin
Template #15 Issue #1
Jun 11, 2017
main content are disordered in the article
Accepted by admin
The formatting is broken.
Template #16 Issue #1
Jun 11, 2017
These are image captions and should be formatted accordingly.
Saeed
It is not clear in the main text. because there exist three <br> between the image and the text below.
Declined by admin
It's best not to apply fixes for particular pages in a template.
Template #17 Issue #1
Jun 12, 2017
These are not figcaptions in the source article
skrskrskr
Image captions are almost never contained in <figcaption> element in source articles and are often inside <p> elements like here. Most important is how they're displayed to the user and what's the meaning of contained text. These ones are clearly captions.
Accepted by admin
While these could indeed be formatted as captions, your approach is clearly not scalable as you simply include a rule for a PARTICULAR page. We may consider a template that finds a way to reliably identify captions on this website.
Template #18 Issue #1
Jun 13, 2017
As it is clearly specified in the source, this a "top-title" not a subtitle. Maybe better to put it before title. (Top Title: Title)
رو تیتر؛ تیتر
Ehsan Dehghani
this is subtitle
in some Persian sites subtitle comes at top of article title
there is no top-title! so no rule for top-title in check list
Declined by admin
Duplicated issue.
Template #17 Issue #2
Jun 13, 2017
Number better to be separate from file name.
Maybe you could use an ordered list.
skrskrskr
It's already separated by space.
Declined by admin
Template #19 Issue #1
Jun 16, 2017
These are image captions and should be formatted accordingly.
Declined by admin
Template #16 Issue #2
Jun 16, 2017
These are image captions and should be formatted accordingly.

I'm resubmitting this issue because my template doesn't have rules for this particular page as admin who declined it said probably based on comment in my template. This comment was for my own needs. My template suits all pages with similar formatting.
Saeed
Repeating the same issue! It is not clear in the main text. because there exist three <br> between the image and the text below. modifying the text formatting of the website is not the aim.
it has been rejected here:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/farhangnews.ir/template16/issue1/
Declined by admin
The source code of that original article does not show indicators that those are captions.
Template #16 Issue #3
Jun 16, 2017
You lost article content somewhere
Accepted by admin
Template #19 Issue #2
Jun 16, 2017
This is an article and must have IV page.
Ehsan Dehghani
this is right link to this article and this have an iv:
http://www.farhangnews.ir/content/156942
you enter keyword/category link and its kind of search result and article listing which is in this case this rearch result page find one article
by the way this is not an article page its a category/keyword page
Declined by admin
Duplicated issue.
Template #21 Issue #1
Jun 16, 2017
This is a category page, that means it is going to include some related articles for a topic. I mentioned the topic and the first title for the first article in red box for you.
so you should not create any IV for this URL because in some cases it will include more than an article. you can click on the first title to go to the original page of content of article.
skrskrskr
These parts you selected can be found in multiple articles on this site. This is an article. It's only one, it's static content and should be supported. How do you imagine such page displaying multiple articles? Please, submit issue with page which is displayed incorrectly.
Declined by admin
The example of the link in the Issue #8:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/farhangnews.ir/template21/issue8/
Template #19 Issue #3
Jun 16, 2017
the text is out of format and less readable
Ehsan Dehghani
there is no problem with this links
Accepted by admin
The formatting is missing.
Template #21 Issue #2
Jun 16, 2017
there is no audio player in the main article. they are just links in the browser view as well
skrskrskr
Yes, but if you click these links in e.g. Chrome browser, player will open. So it behaves like a player anyway. Such behavior on mobile device would be quite uncomfortable for user, so audio elements are quite handy here.
Also, audio element includes download button in right corner, so all functionality is preserved.
I see nothing wrong here.
Declined by admin
Template #23 Issue #1
Jun 17, 2017
this is a gallery photo with content and should display photos as slideshow
Saeed
1. the photos are not in a gallery or slideshow in the main source.
2. this is a typical photo news page from the website. all photo news are aimed to show some photos as the main content. so when there is not any article body (except the description paragraph) we should not create a slideshow for it. please check the following issue and the admin's decision:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/bornanews.ir/template21/issue1/
Declined by admin
The slideshow is optional in this case.
Template #21 Issue #3
Jun 17, 2017
this is a gallery photo with content and should display photos as slideshow
from checklist:
Slideshows are required only if the source article shows several photos or other media as a slideshow or gallery.
skrskrskr
It means when it looks like gallery. Here are just photos one by one.
Declined by admin
The slideshow is optional in this case.
Template #21 Issue #5
Jun 17, 2017
its a category post listing and has dynamic content
this page most not have an iv
skrskrskr
This is an article. It's static content and should be supported. How do you imagine such page displaying multiple articles? Please, submit issue with page which is displayed incorrectly.
Declined by admin
The example of the link in the Issue #8:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/farhangnews.ir/template21/issue8/
Template #23 Issue #2
Jun 19, 2017
Article requires IV page
Saeed
this is a category page. it is not an article. in fact it is composed of some articles related to a topic. you can understand this from the URL and from the topic name above the title of the first article in this page. here is another example in which there are more than one article in the category :
farhangnews.ir/category/پرونده/آموزش-پاورپوینت
Declined by admin
This page must not generate IV.
Template #24 Issue #1
Jun 19, 2017
Article requires IV page
Ehsan Dehghani
this is a article listing which is in this case contains one article
for example check this link:
http://www.farhangnews.ir/category/%D9%85%D9%86%D8%A8%D8%B9/%D8%B1%D9%88%D8%B6%D9%87
this link is at the same type of current link with different keyword and we can see it's listing articles
you did wrong in your template and show first article of list
Declined by admin
This page must not generate IV.
Template #23 Issue #3
Jun 19, 2017
Added non-existing caption.
Saeed
the caption is right below the video. also the text and the video are in the same DIV which is a video container. I add it as a caption for the purpose of completenss
Declined by admin
Template #23 Issue #4
Jun 19, 2017
Video download link should be removed because IV <video> element already has Download button
Saeed
the caption is right below the video. also the text and the video are in the same DIV which is a video container. I add it as a caption for the purpose of completenss
Declined by admin
Template #23 Issue #5
Jun 19, 2017
You're somewhy trying to add video file title to caption like in this page https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/farhangnews.ir/template23/issue4/

But now you've added number 1 instead of filename... This is wrong and inconsistent.
Saeed
the caption is right below the video. also the text and the video are in the same DIV which is a video container. I add it as a caption for the purpose of completeness. but generally it is not important to have a caption here and it is optional
Declined by admin
The "1" is also present in the source page. This is not critical.
Template #23 Issue #6
Jun 19, 2017
Added divider which doesn't exist in article
Saeed
if you check the browser view there is a line separating attached audio files from the rest of the body. i put a divider to make it more clear and well-designed and imitate the main source view
Accepted by admin
The list is also reduntant.
Saeed
The divider and the list are not redundant, because of the following reasons:
1- This is an audio post so it is going to attach some audio files. if you check the browser view there is a line separating attached audio files from main content of the article. I put a divider to imitate the mentioned line and to make it more clear and well-designed.
Also adding an extra divider to separate the content is used in telegram sample at the end of the article : https://instantview.telegram.org/samples/telegram.org/?url=https%3A%2F%2Ftelegram.org%2Fblog%2Fandroid-themes
2- In fact, the list is a part of the content of the source webpage and I did not invent it by myself. in some cases there are going to be more that one audio file, so the list is essential. for example: http://www.farhangnews.ir/content/187437
Declined by admin
Saeed has a point.
List is presented in the original. And adding the divider isn't critical.
Template #24 Issue #2
Jun 19, 2017
Download link should be removed because it duplicates Download button of <video> element
Ehsan Dehghani
no its not duplicated
this download button you can see added by your browser!
source article has this download link and add this like original article body and there is nothing wrong
Declined by admin
The link is presented in the article.
Template #24 Issue #3
Jun 19, 2017
You shouldn't use slideshow when article has essentially no other content.
Ehsan Dehghani
it's gallery post
- if you check the title of this article you can see the word "تصاویر" that means "GALLERY"
these three sentences at top of article body are CONTENT
and we should convert this gallery photos to slide show (as checklist says)
checklist says "When the article consists entirely of a slideshow and there's NO OTHER CONTENT"
and these three sentences are contents other than photo galleries and we can not ignore them
Declined by admin
The slideshow is optional in this case.
Template #24 Issue #4
Jun 19, 2017
slideshow should not be created.
1. the photos are not in a gallery or slideshow in the main source.
2. this is a typical photo news page from the website. all photo news are aimed to show some photos as the main content. so when there is not any article body (except the description paragraph) we should not create a slideshow for it. please check the following issue and the admin's decision:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/bornanews.ir/template21/issue1/
Ehsan Dehghani
it's gallery post
- if you check the title of this article you can see the word "تصاویر" that means "GALLERY"
these three sentences at top of article body are CONTENT
and we should convert this gallery photos to slide show (as checklist says)
checklist says "When the article consists entirely of a slideshow and there's NO OTHER CONTENT"
and these three sentences are contents other than photo galleries and we can not ignore them
that issue you mentioned here accepted because developer of that template doesn't answer your span issue
Declined by admin
The slideshow is optional in this case. (Several images appear in the article one after another.)

It was another situation with another website about a gallery, not an article. https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/bornanews.ir/template21/issue1/
Template #21 Issue #6
Jun 19, 2017
as I mentioned in the previous issue this is an example of the category URL which contains more than one article and your template is trying to create an IV for it. but because of not removing some ads your template is not able to load the content in this special case.
Declined by admin
The example of the link in the Issue #8:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/farhangnews.ir/template21/issue8/
Template #21 Issue #7
Jun 19, 2017
this is an article. you can remove ads to create an IV.
Accepted by admin
This page must generate IV.
Template #24 Issue #5
Jun 19, 2017
you should remove the rudimentary content instead of adding them to the next paragraph
Ehsan Dehghani
this is part of article and it's optional to remove this or not
read checklist section 6.6
Declined by admin
It's optional.
Template #21 Issue #8
Jun 19, 2017
this is a article category post listing
you did wrong in your template and show first article of list
this page should not have an iv
i mentioned this in this issue too but this link is proof of this(this kind of pages are category listing pages)
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/farhangnews.ir/template21/issue5/
Accepted by admin
This page must not generate IV.
Template #23 Issue #7
Jun 19, 2017
1.this download link is not needed because when you tap on play for hearing, its begin to download to your device and you can save it if you want.
2.in devices with ios (iPhone,...) operating system you can not save audio files to your storage, and you can just hear so this this download link is such as Rudimentary content
Saeed
the caption is right below the audio player in browser view. I add it as a caption for the purpose of completeness.in addition this approach is better than having a separate paragraph for the download link text. but generally it is not important to have a caption here and it is optional.
Declined by admin
The link is presented in the article, you shouldn't remove it. Template #24 handles it the same way.
Template #23 Issue #8
Jun 19, 2017
Content to Be Removed

Anything that is not essential to the article in question should be removed from the Instant View page.

Main navigation bars and menus removed (essential navigation may be adjusted to simple links)
Top bars removed
Side bars removed or adjusted and appended to bottom of IV page
Footers removed
Widgets removed
Advertisements removed
Banners removed
Social media links and buttons removed, including “Share” and “Like” links and buttons
Buttons removed (if the button is essential, it must be simplified into a link)
Etc.
Saeed
there is nothing rudimentary to remove!
if you compare it with the main webpage in browser you can see that every element is necessary and part of article body
Declined by admin
Duplicated issue:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/farhangnews.ir/template23/issue6/
Template #23 Issue #9
Jun 19, 2017
this is photo gallery and according to the rule you must generate slideshow:
Slideshows are required only if the source article shows several photos or other media as a slideshow or gallery.
Saeed
this is a photo news, so the only content of the article is several images. according to the checklist we should not create any slideshow when the only content is photos.
Declined by admin
The slideshow is optional in this case.
Template #24 Issue #6
Jun 19, 2017
this is an article
Ehsan Dehghani
the real url of the article is "http://www.farhangnews.ir/content/22465"
you are wrong again
there is no such link in this website
this can be checked by admin manually
you use this website bug to create new urls!
if you look at the url you can see "comment" word
Declined by admin
Template #23 Issue #10
Dec 4, 2017
45
Declined by admin
Template #23 Issue #11
Sep 22, 2018
خوب
Declined by admin