Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues30

This page shows a list of issues for kaztag.kz that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Raphael	Issue #1 May 19, 2017	Арман time of the publication is not shown Accepted by admin
Template #2 Арман	Issue #1 May 21, 2017	Yelnar IV must be generated for this page. Accepted by admin
Template #4 Арман	Issue #1 May 22, 2017	Yelnar Because <br> tags has been removed, this article is harder to read rather than the original one. Accepted by admin
Template #6 Арман	Issue #1 May 24, 2017	Dzmitry Radkevich It's not necessary. Арман <p> </p> and <br> are heavily used on this site for formatting purposes. Removing them often leads to poorly formatted text. There are articles which rely on <br> based formatting instead of paragraphs, so even removing consecutive <br> may break the formatting. For example: http://kaztag.kz/gallery/detail.php?ID=460682 Declined by admin The original article includes these linebreaks. So them do not hurt the IV.
Template #6 Арман	Issue #2 May 24, 2017	Dzmitry Radkevich The author is KazTAG: Kazakh telegraph agency. Арман Author name is not required if it is not present in a clear way in the article. Declined by admin Author links are optional: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-author-link
Template #6 Арман	Issue #3 May 24, 2017	Yelnar This <br> tags at the end can be easily removed without any format breaking issues. Declined by admin The original article includes these linebreaks. So these breaks does not hurt the IV.
Template #6 Арман	Issue #4 May 24, 2017	Yelnar This redundant paragraph can be easily removed without any bad effect on readability of other pages. Declined by admin The original article includes these linebreaks. So these breaks does not hurt the IV.
Template #6 Арман	Issue #5 May 24, 2017	Yelnar Can be removed as well. Declined by admin The original article includes these linebreaks. So these breaks does not hurt the IV.
Template #6 Арман	Issue #6 May 25, 2017	Yelnar Extra paragraph. Declined by admin The original article includes this linebreak that acts as a separator. It does not hurt the IV.
Template #12 Yelnar	Issue #1 May 25, 2017	Dzmitry Radkevich The page has lost all paragraphs.It is inconvenient to read. Accepted by admin
Template #13 Dzmitry Radkevich	Issue #1 May 25, 2017	Yelnar Wrong time is displayed. Declined by admin The time is correct. By the way, the IV editor‘s ’Preview‘ section will always show the date/time in UTC format, while the ’Original' section may use a different time zone. It is possible for a perfect template to display a date/time that is different from the original. (https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-9-date-and-time)
Template #14 Арман	Issue #1 May 26, 2017	Yelnar All this empty paragraphs, especially those at the bottom, can be removed and raise the quality of readability. Арман <p> </p> and <br> are heavily used on this site for formatting purposes. Removing them often leads to poorly formatted text. Declined by admin While removing empty paragraphs is not critical, it could be nice to address them in a future revision of the template. The reporter's template removes the empty paragraphs and it still seems quite readable: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/kaztag.kz/template28/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fkaztag.kz%2Finterview%2Fdetail.php%3FID%3D532097
Template #20 Aleksandr	Issue #2 Jun 3, 2017	Dzmitry Radkevich The author of the page is Ирина Гумыркина. Accepted by admin
Template #14 Арман	Issue #2 Jun 3, 2017	Dzmitry Radkevich The author of the page is Ирина Гумыркина. Арман The reason is because it is part of the article text. It has no clear selector like id or class to target it. It was added by the author of the text and can be present or absent, or be in some other format. While it is doable using regex pattern matching, it is going to be error prone and not 100% accurate. There are even cases where it is defined in the middle of paragraph and in the middle of text: http://kaztag.kz/interview/detail.php?ID=261387 And after all, even though author name is not inside the "Date, Author" box, it is not missing in the IV. I think that, rather than fiddling with picking it out of the text of the article, it might be better to just leave it as part of the text. Declined by admin It seems that it is not possible to consistently parse author names from articles on this wesite. In such cases, it is much better to omit author names than to generate wrong names in some cases.
Template #14 Арман	Issue #3 Jun 3, 2017	Yelnar Author information is wrong. Should be "Владимир Радионов". Declined by admin It seems that it is not possible to consistently parse author names from articles on this wesite. In such cases, it is much better to omit author names than to generate wrong names in some cases.
Template #14 Арман	Issue #4 Jun 3, 2017	Dzmitry Radkevich The author is Бауыржан Муканов Declined by admin It seems that it is not possible to consistently parse author names from articles on this wesite. In such cases, it is much better to omit author names than to generate wrong names in some cases.
Template #26 Yelnar	Issue #1 Jun 3, 2017	Dzmitry Radkevich The author is missing Yelnar Author information in articles in news section can not be fetched correctly. Because it is not wrapped separately in any tag and also there is no specified rule as in some other pages. For example, you template cannot display author in this page http://kaztag.kz/news/detail.php?ID=134698. As soon as you fix it, I can find some more other pages. Declined by admin The link in the creator's response (http://kaztag.kz/news/detail.php?ID=134698) illustrates that it is not possible to consistently parse author names from articles on this wesite. In such cases, it is much better to omit author names than to generate wrong names in some cases.
Template #27 Dzmitry Radkevich	Issue #1 Jun 6, 2017	Yelnar As admin reported, it is much better to omit author names in this website. Declined by admin It seems that it is not possible to consistently parse author names from articles on this website. In such cases, it is much better to omit author names than to generate wrong names in some cases.
Template #14 Арман	Issue #5 Jun 12, 2017	Kesantielu Dasefern Needs IV Declined by admin It is acceptable not to support this page. It is a service page, while the main focus is on articles.
Template #27 Dzmitry Radkevich	Issue #2 Jun 17, 2017	Kesantielu Dasefern Site name used for author name Declined by admin
Template #27 Dzmitry Radkevich	Issue #3 Jun 17, 2017	Арман Formatting issues Accepted by admin Reporter's template handles this case better: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/kaztag.kz/template14/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fkaztag.kz%2Freviews%2Fdetail.php%3FID%3D263722
Template #27 Dzmitry Radkevich	Issue #4 Jun 18, 2017	Арман This page can have an IV Accepted by admin
Template #33 Yelnar	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	Арман Incorrect formatting. Declined by admin Not a critical issue.
Template #34 Kesantielu Dasefern	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	Арман Formatting issues. Kesantielu Dasefern Incorrect formatting of old page's source Declined by admin
Template #14 Арман	Issue #6 Jun 18, 2017	Dzmitry Radkevich Something wrong Арман The page has an unsupported table layout. Declined by admin The page has an unsupported table layout.
Template #33 Yelnar	Issue #2 Jun 18, 2017	Dzmitry Radkevich Something wrong Declined by admin The page has an unsupported table layout.
Template #34 Kesantielu Dasefern	Issue #2 Jun 18, 2017	Dzmitry Radkevich Something wrong Kesantielu Dasefern Table is on the page! Fucking «Jack-in-a-last-15-minut-box» idiot Declined by admin The page has an unsupported table layout.
Template #33 Yelnar	Issue #3 Jun 19, 2017	Kesantielu Dasefern Checklist: "EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used: When the article consists entirely of a slideshow and there's no other content" Yelnar Well there is "fs" text below, no matter what that means. Declined by admin The page is obscure. Template properly handles all the pages with galleries and text.
Template #14 Арман	Issue #7 Jun 19, 2017	Kesantielu Dasefern Checklist: "EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used: When the article consists entirely of a slideshow and there's no other content" Арман There is actually some content under the slideshow: "fs" Even though it's not useful, it's a text that was added by the author of the post. I'm not sure if it's required to handle such kind of special cases. Declined by admin The article is old enough. Current galleries contain text, template #14 handles them properly.
Template #34 Kesantielu Dasefern	Issue #3 Jun 19, 2017	Yelnar This is paywall. Kesantielu Dasefern Fixed in my unpublished version Accepted by admin This page must not generate an IV in accordance to 2.4 of Perfect Template Checklist: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#2-4-inaccessible-pages Kesantielu Dasefern Admins, please, pay attention to this template: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/m3llm.net/template9/ Its status is «declined by Kesantielu Dasefern at 6:27 PM, Jul 17» But I did not reject this template, also after the end of the contest it is generally impossible to do this! Accepted by admin Thanks for the heads up. We will investigate!

Processed Issues30

Log In