Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues42

This page shows a list of issues for zona.media that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Dmitry Starov	Issue #1 May 20, 2017	Vlad Ivanov Article name and date are missing Accepted by admin Author and date are missing.
Template #1 Dmitry Starov	Issue #2 May 20, 2017	Vlad Ivanov Images should be formatted as figures with <figcaption> Accepted by admin
Template #2 V	Issue #1 May 20, 2017	Vlad Ivanov Publication date is missing Accepted by admin
Template #2 V	Issue #2 May 20, 2017	Vlad Ivanov Bottom links aren't removed Declined by admin 'Read more' links at the end are optional.
Template #2 V	Issue #3 May 20, 2017	Vlad Ivanov Author name is missing Accepted by admin
Template #2 V	Issue #4 May 20, 2017	Vlad Ivanov This page is supposed to be "live" and can't be cached Accepted by admin
Template #7 Anton	Issue #1 May 26, 2017	M The static article Accepted by admin
Template #7 Anton	Issue #2 May 26, 2017	Vlad Ivanov Should be a subtitle? No explicit mention in the text Accepted by admin
Template #7 Anton	Issue #3 May 26, 2017	Vlad Ivanov Page contains interactive content Accepted by admin
Template #7 Anton	Issue #4 May 26, 2017	Vlad Ivanov Page contains interactive content Accepted by admin Formatting is lost. Rudimentary content isn't removed
Template #8 Vlad Ivanov	Issue #1 May 31, 2017	Anton This online already finished (look at chronological order and no date-update-url attribute), so this is a static page now and needs to have IV Accepted by admin
Template #8 Vlad Ivanov	Issue #2 May 31, 2017	Anton All needed content for this page is availible in source code and page content is managed by JS Accepted by admin
Template #11 Anton	Issue #1 Jun 1, 2017	Mark It is a page with dynamically updated content Anton This online already finished (look at chronological order and no date-update-url attribute), so this is a static page now and needs to have IV Declined by admin
Template #11 Anton	Issue #2 Jun 2, 2017	Aleks No caption Accepted by admin
Template #12 Anton	Issue #1 Jun 2, 2017	admin Second author is missing. Accepted by admin
Template #13 Anton	Issue #1 Jun 2, 2017	Руслан Емашов Wrong time Anton It's UTC time, Moscow timezone is +3 hours Declined by admin
Template #13 Anton	Issue #2 Jun 3, 2017	S G Author links exist but not presented. From checklist: "These properties are also essential, but not always present or supported in IV: Author name on IV page can link to the author URL if an author URL is specified in the source. " Anton Author link supports only one link, so with case of multiple authors this could be a problem for user Declined by admin Author links are optional: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-author-link
Template #14 chuchu	Issue #1 Jun 3, 2017	S G Author links exist but not presented. From checklist: "These properties are also essential, but not always present or supported in IV: Author name on IV page can link to the author URL if an author URL is specified in the source. " chuchu IV don't support 2+ links Declined by admin Author links are optional: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-author-link
Template #14 chuchu	Issue #2 Jun 3, 2017	S G news article is not displayed at all chuchu /online/ contains dynamicly updated articles. "at all" lol Declined by admin
Template #13 Anton	Issue #3 Jun 5, 2017	chuchu Missing main image Accepted by admin
Template #17 S G	Issue #1 Jun 5, 2017	Anton Page with interactive content S G There is no such rule to block page with interactive content fully. "IV Targets: Must NOT Generate: 2.2. Pages that require significant interaction." Where is the "significant interaction" in the generated page? "6.8. Unsupported content. Pages that display unsupported content (e.g. an interactive map widget) must not generate IVs." It doesn't display any interactive content. The button is removed according to another rule. So what is the problem? Accepted by admin The article is meaningless without that interactive content. In this case no IV should generate for that page, or at least a link to that content should be provided, so that the users can still reach it.
Template #18 Anton	Issue #1 Jun 6, 2017	S G The page represents a simple article. No instant view generated for this page Anton Content of this article is rules of the game and by pressing "Play" ("Играть") user starts game on the same page. This page fall under "2.2. Pages that require significant interaction." in my opinion Declined by admin Anton is right. Either no IV should generate for that page or a link should be provided. It would be better if a link would show up though.
Template #17 S G	Issue #2 Jun 6, 2017	chuchu The rule is simple. If an article have content that con not be displayed in IV, then IV should not be generated for this article. This article contains button, and, after user clicks on this button, there must be interactive game ("content that needed sagnificant interaction") S G There is no such rule to block page with interactive content fully. "IV Targets: Must NOT Generate: 2.2. Pages that require significant interaction." Where is the "significant interaction" in the generated page? "6.8. Unsupported content. Pages that display unsupported content (e.g. an interactive map widget) must not generate IVs." It doesn't display any interactive content. The button is removed according to another rule. So what is the problem? +it is a duplicate of issue #1 Declined by admin Duplicate of issue #1 (which was already accepted)
Template #18 Anton	Issue #2 Jun 14, 2017	chuchu There is anchor links. They should be preserved and work correctly Anton There is none anchor links in source page. Submenu with links needed for navigation with js on source page. Declined by admin
Template #18 Anton	Issue #3 Jun 14, 2017	chuchu Here is facebook embed. It should be wrapped correctly Accepted by admin
Template #26 Anton	Issue #1 Jun 15, 2017	chuchu This was today. How do you recognize that it is ended? Your template just renders everything from online section. Note that /online/ goes to /chronicle/ after it's ended Anton Finished online has chronological order, dosen't have date-update-url attribute and some another stuff. This case was already reviewed https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/zona.media/template8/issue1/ Also /online/ and /chronicle/ are diffrent Declined by admin
Template #28 S G	Issue #2 Jun 19, 2017	Andriy Kolodiy Wrong time. S G datetime(-2) used as recommended in manual Declined by admin Timezones are optional.
Template #26 Anton	Issue #2 Jun 19, 2017	Andriy Kolodiy Wrong time. Anton It's UTC time, Moscow timezone is +3 hours Declined by admin Timezones are optional.
Template #26 Anton	Issue #3 Jun 19, 2017	Andriy Kolodiy Subtitle is missing. Anton This is lead, not subtitle Declined by admin
Template #26 Anton	Issue #4 Jun 19, 2017	S G random paragraph order Anton This is intentional. Lead needs to be in start of article. Declined by admin In this case it is optional, the order does not affect the understanding of the article.
Template #26 Anton	Issue #5 Jun 19, 2017	S G IV generated for page with dynamic content - "Online" + info in the end of the article that the conclusion will be 21 june Anton This is online for one day of court session. Also this case was already reviewed: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/zona.media/template8/issue1/ Declined by admin That day has already passed, and the article has not been updated.
Template #28 S G	Issue #3 Jun 19, 2017	Anton This is not UTC time, Moscow timezone is +3 hours S G duplicate of issue 2 - datetime(-2) used as recommended in manual Declined by admin Timezones are optional.
Template #26 Anton	Issue #6 Nov 22, 2017	Aleks Only lead is shown, article text missing Declined by admin
Template #26 Anton	Issue #7 Dec 5, 2017	Игорь Шарков Accepted by admin Rudimentary content not removed (fundraising widget)
Template #30 Anton	Issue #1 Jan 31, 2018	Aleks In a he last section spaced missing for Поддержать Медиазону, no active links there. Either remove or better make an active link Accepted by admin
Template #33 admin	Issue #1 Apr 28, 2018	Александр Говоров Declined by admin
Template #34 admin	Issue #1 Aug 4, 2019	P for V. Т.е коррупция побеждена,можно и ФБК победить... Declined by admin
Template #34 admin	Issue #2 Dec 24, 2019	Deleted Account 2+1,6=2,6??? Declined by admin
Template #36 admin	Issue #2 Jun 7, 2020	Nikolai Video doesn’t works. iPhone X Declined by admin
Template #37 admin	Issue #1 Jun 21, 2020	Земфира Старикова В первом абзаце Маркин, во втором - Мухин. Каво? Declined by admin
Template #38 admin	Issue #1 Jul 28, 2020	V https://meduza.io/feature/2020/07/29/issledovatel-tvorchestva-van-goga-nashel-mesto-s-posledney-kartiny-hudozhnika-na-otkrytke-stoletney-davnosti Declined by admin
Template #41 admin	Issue #1 Oct 6, 2020	undefined there is also mediazona.ca https://instantview.telegram.org/templates/zona.media/template39/issue1/ Declined by admin

Processed Issues42

Log In