Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues10

This page shows a list of issues for 20minutes.fr that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #2 F	Issue #1 May 31, 2017	Nico Missing the date and time of the article Accepted by admin The date is missing.
Template #4 Ivan Nikitin	Issue #1 Jun 17, 2017	Sergey Pomogaylenko this page's content updates online every minute until event ending. not static content Accepted by admin
Template #5 F	Issue #1 Jun 17, 2017	Sergey Pomogaylenko this page's content updates online every minute until event ending. not static content Accepted by admin
Template #4 Ivan Nikitin	Issue #2 Jun 18, 2017	☄️ Must generate an IV for articles Accepted by admin
Template #5 F	Issue #2 Jun 18, 2017	☄️ These are not parts of the article Accepted by admin
Template #6 ☄️	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	Sherali Rysbekov IV is not generated, there is other reason that "Embed_not_supported" though. IV should be not generated as long as it is "live" article - data updates every second. Thus, you throwed a wrong error. This issue is almost the same as https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/20minutes.fr/template4/issue1/ ☄️ Will fix, thanks Accepted by admin
Template #4 Ivan Nikitin	Issue #3 Jun 18, 2017	Roman empty p in code Accepted by admin Empty paragraphs are not so critical, but there are also two videos at this page which are missing.
Template #8 ☄️	Issue #1 Jun 18, 2017	Sherali Rysbekov You throwed the wrong error... again. When handling dynamic pages likes this, you should merely prevent your template from being generated, like I do. ☄️ First of all, what's important is that my template does not generate an IV for dynamically updated articles. It's all that checklist asks from us. Secondly, I insist on the opposite: simply not generating an otherwise article-looking page is misleading, "not supported" gives you a clearer picture on why it's not an IV. And lastly, I _specifically_ target the live widgets to distinguish dynamic articles from the static ones, so there won't be any false negatives cases. Not sure about yours. Declined by admin
Template #8 ☄️	Issue #2 Jun 18, 2017	Sherali Rysbekov First things first, I'm sorry for adding that issue again, but, unfortunately, I was not able to respond to the previous one. First, you said that checklist was requiring only not to generate IV for dynamic pages. Read carefully, 'cause docs tell us to "mark any unsupported essential content using the @unsupported function". At this page, there is no content that could be marked unsupported, which means you do not follow the checklist. Secondly, you said about "a clearer picture". As long as there are no elements could be marked with "@unsupported", you do not make thing clear. Instead, you trick users and admins by (I'm not sure, but I deduce so) deliberately adding an unsupported iframe. Thirdly, what the freaking widgets are talking about? The only thing that helps you to determine whether this page is static or dynamic is in the json data(find yourself), which I use, in case you are "not sure" about mine. Whatever, I'm sure that admins will make right decision regarding this problem. ☄️ I'm done justifying myself to you, so this comment is dedicated to the admin. There are exactly two kinds of widgets on this website (buttons, ultimately), which let us know that current article is live: • <p class="refresh"> here: goo.gl/KspVVg • <button id="live-refresh"> on the current page Those allow us to refresh the page dynamically, and those are the markers telling us that these elements are not supported by IV and that the page is not static. Claiming that I added some iframe is ridiculous, since my preview says ELEMENT_NOT_SUPPORTED, not EMBED_NOT_SUPPORTED. You can also check my code too make sure it's true. Declined by admin No IV page is generated for dynamically updated page. Seems that 'Refresh'-button is commonly used for such pages, so in that case, it's acceptable to mark it as unsupported.
Template #9 Sherali Rysbekov	Issue #1 Jun 19, 2017	F No content for this article Sherali Rysbekov Fine. There's a following element on the page which indicates its dynamic nature: <script type="application/ld+json"> {"@context":"https:\/\/schema.org","@type":"LiveBlogPosting ... It's a live posting, i.e. it updates. Declined by admin No IV should be generated for dynamically updated page.