Contest - Instant View

Processed Issues45

This page shows a list of issues for 5minutes.rtl.lu that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 ☄️	Issue #1 Jun 4, 2017	Rodrigo Vieira Video in this page is missing and not supported Accepted by admin
Template #2 ☄️	Issue #1 Jun 6, 2017	Сергей Герасимов it is article. Declined by admin The original article contains unsupported embedded video: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-8-2-videos-from-unsupported-players
Template #2 ☄️	Issue #2 Jun 15, 2017	linedo lobuga ✅ unsupported embedded video Accepted by admin
Template #3 Сергей Герасимов	Issue #1 Jun 15, 2017	linedo lobuga ✅ unsupported embedded video Accepted by admin The original article contains unsupported embedded video: https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-8-2-videos-from-unsupported-players For's template handles it better: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/5minutes.rtl.lu/template4
Template #4 ☄️	Issue #1 Jun 17, 2017	Deleted Account This page has no instant view available ☄️ The video in the article cannot be embedded the straightforward way. So you either have to support it (which you don't) or not generate an IV by tagging the video with "@unsupported" function (or letting telegram do it on its own) Declined by admin Issues about unsupported content may be considered if they include a link to a template that supports the disputed content.
Template #4 ☄️	Issue #2 Aug 2, 2017	admin Sadly, this page contains a feedback form that is missing from the IV. Accepted by admin Source: http://telegra.ph/Reports-4-08-02 This issue was created as part of our final processing of appeals on our earlier decisions submitted by the contestants. Thank you very much for taking the time and effort to participate in our contest! Please note that we no longer accept submissions of new issues in any form. As of this stage, we can only process appeals on our decisions about the issue for which the appeal was submitted.
Template #6 Deleted Account	Issue #1 Aug 2, 2017	admin This page contains an embedded post. Unfortunately, it is not present in the IV. Accepted by admin This issue was created as part of our final processing of appeals on our earlier decisions submitted by the contestants. Thank you very much for taking the time and effort to participate in our contest! Please note that we no longer accept submissions of new issues in any form. As of this stage, we can only process appeals on our decisions about the issue for which the appeal was submitted.
Template #7 Сергей Герасимов	Issue #1 Aug 2, 2017	admin Unfortunately, this page is missing the cover caption and the lead paragraph. Accepted by admin This issue was created as part of our final processing of appeals on our earlier decisions submitted by the contestants. Thank you very much for taking the time and effort to participate in our contest! Please note that we no longer accept submissions of new issues in any form. As of this stage, we can only process appeals on our decisions about the issue for which the appeal was submitted.
Template #13 Максим³	Issue #1 Feb 6, 2019	Fabio Murru missing site name in link preview https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#3-2-link-preview Accepted by admin
Template #15 Максим³	Issue #1 Feb 6, 2019	Fabio Murru Target page not generated Accepted by admin
Template #19 Максим³	Issue #1 Feb 7, 2019	Fabio Murru target page not generated Accepted by admin
Template #20 Fabio Murru	Issue #2 Feb 10, 2019	Anton S. There is a video in the original article here Accepted by admin
Template #20 Fabio Murru	Issue #5 Feb 10, 2019	Anton S. Header formatting is lost Accepted by admin
Template #21 Максим³	Issue #1 Feb 10, 2019	Vyacheslav B. Missing name of Related section, using title of related article for it instead Максим³ It isn't clear from documentation what exactly should be in the related title. After all, IV preview just shows a link without any titles and images and it seemed weird for me to see just "Next article" text and link. Accepted by admin
Template #21 Максим³	Issue #2 Feb 10, 2019	igo Hey dude, what's with your paragraphs? Why they are so big? @admin, does there any rules about that? Cause I spent a lot time trying to separate such things, so that on mobile devices it could be possible to select/copy the whole paragraph but not the whole article :D Максим³ original page does not use <p>'s and it can be quite unreliable to parse //em/br Declined by admin In this case it looks fine
Template #21 Максим³	Issue #3 Feb 10, 2019	igo That is not a related article, like added the by a human. It's autogenerated, you can ensure in it on the early page (2008 year): http://5minutes.rtl.lu/culture/musique/1009.html It suggests a festival that will be in 10 years, in 2019. Максим³ on most pages it does point to article in the same time period, so I assume they are added by human, but in some cases they will be replaced automatically with the latest availiable article from category (Not sure if this is even possible to handle properly). Example: http://5minutes.rtl.lu/sport/tennis/1070843.html (30 août 2017 and the next article is 29 août 2017) also 6.3.2 We will not accept issues on whether or not links formatted as “Related articles” are thematically related enough or static enough. Declined by admin
Template #21 Максим³	Issue #4 Feb 10, 2019	cescus Titles are not formatted like titles, they are clearly extractable (I did it with a clean logic) Максим³ They are formatted as bold Accepted by admin
Template #26 Максим³	Issue #1 Feb 11, 2019	Deleted Account static page must be generated Максим³ it contains google maps and it seems like it is unsupported in IV (I haven't seen any IV that got maps working) Declined by admin This page must generate no IV.
Template #26 Максим³	Issue #2 Feb 11, 2019	Deleted Account site_name is incorrect.You only write website`s url Максим³ site_name is correct. <title> of the original page contains "5minutes.lu". Declined by admin Kindly resubmit with a link to a template that handles this case better.
Template #26 Максим³	Issue #3 Feb 11, 2019	Deleted Account static pages must be generated https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#1-iv-targets-must-generate Максим³ duplicate of issue #1: it contains google maps and it seems like it is unsupported in IV (I haven't seen any IV that got maps working) Declined by admin Duplicated issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/5minutes.rtl.lu/template26/issue1/
Template #26 Максим³	Issue #4 Feb 12, 2019	cescus This IV can be generated and the unsupported element can be managed Максим³ 6.4.2 Video/Audio from unsupported players If the unsupported widget has an iFrame version, make it into an <iframe>. If you do that, the IV page will not be generated due to unsupported content, but things will work out of the box if and when we support that widget. that's exactly what I did. Declined by admin
Template #26 Максим³	Issue #5 Feb 12, 2019	cescus Opening the page properly, you'll notice that there are some titles that you're treating like parts of your paragraph. Would be optimal to extract them and manage them Максим³ These subtitles are marked with bold in the IV. I don't really understand what is the issue here Accepted by admin <span class="article-title"> should be a header
Template #26 Максим³	Issue #6 Feb 12, 2019	cescus This article is not related, it's the one that follows chronologically (i guess) the current one. Максим³ (duplicate of https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/5minutes.rtl.lu/template21/issue3) on most pages it does point to article in the same time period, so I assume they are added by human, but in some cases they will be replaced automatically with the latest availiable article from category (Not sure if this is even possible to handle properly). Example: http://5minutes.rtl.lu/sport/tennis/1070843.html (30 août 2017 and the next article is 29 août 2017) also 6.3.2 We will not accept issues on whether or not links formatted as “Related articles” are thematically related enough or static enough. Declined by admin
Template #26 Максим³	Issue #7 Feb 12, 2019	cescus This page can have an IV, look at my template Максим³ Indeed, your template can generate an IV, but the video is really lowres there (426x240). In fact it's technically impossible to get the highres video working because of "Resource fetch failed" errors(maybe it's because of the size of the file? hq videos here are around 60 MB). Actually there's no separate rule for that in checklist, but I believe the image quality section shares the same rules: 6.2.1 Image quality When several image resolutions are available, the IV page should use better quality images. If for some reason it is only technically possible to obtain low-resolution versions of images (lower than 320px) for a page, on which high-resolution images are available on the web, the page should not generate an IV. Accepted by admin
Template #26 Максим³	Issue #8 Feb 12, 2019	cescus Should be a subtitle Максим³ This is lead paragraph 6.1.4 Lead paragraph Many publications use a slightly different style for their lead paragraphs. Unlike subtitles and summaries, the lead paragraph is a part of the article's text. Even if the lead uses a different style from the rest of the text, it is less desirable to present it as a subtitle — but this is not critical. We will not accept issues on templates for presenting the lead paragraph as the subtitle in IV. If the lead paragraph uses a different style, it is recommended to use bold or italic text (we will not accept issues based on the absence of such formatting). Declined by admin
Template #26 Максим³	Issue #9 Feb 12, 2019	cescus "Par" is "by" in french, it should be removed Максим³ I think that it is not really important Accepted by admin
Template #30 cescus	Issue #1 Feb 16, 2019	Максим³ Image should be before "Les rencontres Arts..." paragraph Accepted by admin
Template #35 Deleted Account	Issue #1 Feb 16, 2019	Максим³ Related articles are missing 6.3.2 Related articles It is obligatory to format “Related articles” links using the new <related> tag, provided they are identifiable in the source. Deleted Account They're not related. Declined by admin
Template #35 Deleted Account	Issue #2 Feb 16, 2019	Максим³ <span class="article-title"> should be a header: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/5minutes.rtl.lu/template26/issue5/ Accepted by admin
Template #29 Максим³	Issue #1 Feb 16, 2019	Deleted Account "Article suivant" means "Next article" and is not related to the current article (except by the luck). Максим³ It is header for the related articles block. It should be "Next article" in this case. Accepted by admin
Template #29 Максим³	Issue #2 Feb 17, 2019	cescus If you open the page you'll see that there's a link that is missing Максим³ It is contained in <script> if ($('#comments').length > 0) $('#comments').before('<div class=\"base-hl related\">... and it can change anytime, so it's not safe to parse stuff like that Declined by admin
Template #29 Максим³	Issue #3 Feb 17, 2019	Deleted Account You missed captions for medias. Check with my template. "6.2.4 Captions Any captions present in the source article must be preserved. This includes captions for the cover image and captions for all individual elements of slideshows. If the image has no caption, but has meaningful text in the alt attribute, you may use that text as the caption. ... " Максим³ this page isn't generated anyways because of too big videos. other pages use a different format for captions Accepted by admin
Template #39 Максим³	Issue #1 Feb 18, 2019	cescus Kicker missing Максим³ It's not a kicker but rather a category name Declined by admin
Template #41 Максим³	Issue #1 Feb 21, 2019	Deleted Account Hi, It should be presented as header <h(N)> as you said in other issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/5minutes.rtl.lu/template40/issue1/ Also, admin says the same in this accepted issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/5minutes.rtl.lu/template26/issue5/ Accepted by admin
Template #43 Максим³	Issue #1 Feb 23, 2019	cescus Error in getting the media Максим³ If you'll try to open this link in the browser you'll see it's loading, so it's error on the telegram crawler side. Probably size limit or smth. Declined by admin The link works fine, but the IV Editor cannot fetch the media.
Template #42 Deleted Account	Issue #4 Feb 24, 2019	Максим³ <span class="article-title"> should be a header: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/5minutes.rtl.lu/template26/issue5/ Accepted by admin
Template #43 Максим³	Issue #2 Feb 24, 2019	Deleted Account "EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used: ... When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content." https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-3-galleries-and-slideshows -- Also, it's more appropriate and logical to use the bold text in the body as the subtitle of the article. https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-1-3-subtitle Максим³ It does use the slideshow in the original article. Also there's text before the photo (lead paragraph) so the page doesn't consist only of a slideshow Accepted by admin
Template #43 Максим³	Issue #3 Feb 24, 2019	Deleted Account IV should be generated. Check with my template. Accepted by admin
Template #51 Максим³	Issue #1 Feb 27, 2019	Deleted Account These iframes could be supported. Check with my template. Accepted by admin
Template #52 Максим³	Issue #1 Mar 2, 2019	is summer missing iv Accepted by admin
Template #55 Максим³	Issue #1 Mar 4, 2019	Deleted Account Simple paragraph that explaining the gallery is used as author name. Accepted by admin
Template #61 Максим³	Issue #1 Mar 8, 2019	Deleted Account Hi there. Congratulations! ( Women Day greetings to you!) Declined by admin
Template #63 Максим³	Issue #1 Mar 8, 2019	Deleted Account <cite> could be used instead. This website always uses a structure that separates the cite from the caption with "/ ©" or just "©". Your previous templates were able to do this though. Максим³ It is not contained in the separate container and it was causing some problems on the old version of website so I decided not to do it here. Declined by admin
Template #63 Максим³	Issue #2 Mar 8, 2019	Deleted Account Response to issue #1's answer: Can you give a URL that cause problems you've talked about? Because it seems like you've forgotten to implement such feature after rewriting the template for this website's new design yesterday. They always use the same structure for captions and cites. Declined by admin
Template #64 Deleted Account	Issue #1 Mar 10, 2019	Максим³ slideshow can be supported Deleted Account gallery data encoded with base64. admins, is there a way to decode it in TG's IV system? I didn't see such a thing in the docs. Accepted by admin It's possible to decode it through @inline function. I accept the issue since the other template's author found a way to do this.

Processed Issues45

Log In