Processed Issues54

This page shows a list of issues for noen.at that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #5 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Teaser for related article not displayed correctly.
Accepted by admin
Template #9 Issue #1
Feb 8, 2019
According to checklist 6.3.2, it is obligatory to format “Related articles” links using the new <related> tag.
Accepted by admin
Bernhard K.
The rule change that the <related> tag is required came after my publishing this template. If I had changed it when the rules were changed, I'd lost my place on top of the queue. It's kinda unfair to be rejected for rules that didn't exist when you created your template and had no opportunity to implement.
Accepted by admin
Template #10 Issue #1
Feb 10, 2019
Author of the photo could be easily identified and must be wrapped with <cite> tag
Accepted by admin
Template #11 Issue #1
Feb 11, 2019
Only the first 3 images are part of the slideshow, the rest are teasers for other articles at the end of the slideshow.
Accepted by admin
The reporter's template handles this case better.
Template #11 Issue #2
Feb 11, 2019
only the first picture has a credit
Accepted by admin
Template #11 Issue #3
Feb 11, 2019
Missing part of the article
Accepted by admin
Template #21 Issue #1
Feb 14, 2019
Timezone not accounted for, so time if off by 2 hours (Germany has timezone GMT+1 and in this case an additional +1 for daylight savings time). And yes, it's possible to implement this, see:
- Winter time: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/noen.at/template22/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.noen.at%2Fmistelbach%2Fkreuzstetten-92-jaehriges-paar-nach-klinik-aufenthalt-wieder-vereint-kreuzstetten-rotes-kreuz-kreuzstetten-135744647
- Summer time: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/noen.at/template22/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.noen.at%2Fthema%2Fthailand%2Fthailands-highlights-inseln-und-straende-94144150
Note that in the first link, the time offset from Germany->UTC is +1, while in the second it's +2, because of the Daylight Savings Time.

Telegram's @datetime function will properly calculate the time offset to the reader's timezone, if implemented by the template creator correctly. It is possible to enter the Timezone information as something like "Europe/Berlin". This causes the datetime-parser to automatically i
Bernhard K.
Using "Europe/Berlin" as a timezone is a undocumented feature of the @datetime function that I just heard about for the first time.
Nevertheless there have many precedence issues that demonstrate that the not using the correct time zone doesn't warrant a rejection of the template.
Declined by admin
Template #22 Issue #1
Feb 16, 2019
This page (and other such pages) should be unsupported (because of quiz) (IMAGE_SOURCE_NOT_FOUND error doesn't matter in this case)
Falko
The error does not matter - the IV is not generated for this page, and this is true for every page that has a quiz.
Accepted by admin
The error matters. The template should be protected from interactive elements: next time there may be an image with correct src, so the template will generate IV for a page with quiz, that is unacceptable
Template #21 Issue #2
Feb 16, 2019
This page (and other such pages) should be unsupported (because of quiz) (IMAGE_SOURCE_NOT_FOUND error doesn't matter in this case)
Accepted by admin
Template #26 Issue #1
Feb 18, 2019
Wrong description in link preview. Correct would be the one e.g. stored in <meta name="description">, but the one used right now has nothing to do with the article and is the same across all pages, which is not right.
Accepted by admin
Template #26 Issue #2
Feb 18, 2019
this template must take care of correct site_name
Accepted by admin
Template #30 Issue #1
Feb 19, 2019
According to 6.2.3, this must be rendered as a slideshow.
Grigory Korepanov
The main content of this page is images.
The rules stipulate that in such cases a slideshow is not necessary
I asked that question, but I didn't get an answer =(

This site has articles with 200 images and paragraphs. The rules do not describe how to act in such cases. The answer of the administrator will be considered
faithful. So we will wait for the administrator.
Declined by admin
Template #30 Issue #2
Feb 21, 2019
It's possible to present this in higher resolution. Check my template.
Accepted by admin
Template #33 Issue #1
Feb 21, 2019
Image quality too low (less than 300px)
Accepted by admin
Template #33 Issue #2
Feb 21, 2019
There are 2 authors, but 1 link that leads to first author page. It's better to remove link at all in this case.
Grigory Korepanov
It is optional, pls read rules
Declined by admin
Template #29 Issue #3
Feb 21, 2019
There are 2 authors, but 1 link that leads to first author page. It's better to remove link at all in this case.
Declined by admin
Template #29 Issue #4
Feb 21, 2019
Oh, I'm sorry for the previous issue.
Darkcomet
Thanks
Declined by admin
Template #29 Issue #5
Feb 22, 2019
Content order is broken
Accepted by admin
Template #40 Issue #1
Feb 24, 2019
The page needs an IV.
Accepted by admin
Template #41 Issue #1
Feb 24, 2019
Incorrect year
Accepted by admin
Template #42 Issue #1
Feb 27, 2019
It's not a slideshow figcaption

Yeah, I know they're all the same, but they're all the same here.
but
https://telegra.ph/Slideshow-problem-02-27
Falko
I'm sorry, I don't get what the problem is here. If you have an example of a page where the caption is incorrect, please submit that as an issue.
Declined by admin
Agreed with the template's author. I don't see the issue here. For example other slideshow with different images: https://www.noen.at/krems/fuer-pkw-hatte-leitschiene-katapult-wirkung-krems-verkehrsunfall-137814653
Template #42 Issue #2
Feb 27, 2019
Falko
That's because of a voting widget in the article. In this case the voting widget is non-essential, but in other cases (like here: https://www.noen.at/sportlerwahl/jetzt-abstimmen-noen-sportlerwahl-in-waidhofen-37458283) it's an essential part of the article and shouldn't be removed. It's not possible to reliably identify whether it's a main part of the article (same element, same class, etc), so it's best to just mark it as unsupported in case it's an essential part of that article.
Declined by admin
Template #42 Issue #3
Feb 27, 2019
It seems there are no unsupported elements.
Accepted by admin
Template #44 Issue #1
Feb 27, 2019
It seems there are no unsupported elements.
Accepted by admin
Template #46 Issue #1
Feb 28, 2019
There's a dot after the title that's not present in the original
Deleted Account
Is this too critical?
Accepted by admin
No content should be added, even if it's only one dot.

This dot is from <span class="hide">.</span>
You can't be 100% sure that it's always only a dot here. In case it's something more than just a dot your template will add content.
Template #48 Issue #1
Feb 28, 2019
This article is about voting for a picture. The voting widget is missing, along with the results (which are displayed inside the widget), but they are essential content
Accepted by admin
Template #50 Issue #1
Mar 2, 2019
Must be presented as slider.
Grigory Korepanov
<meta name="twitter:card" content="gallery">
This tag indicates that the main content of this page are photos

Most of the articles on this site, with this tag, store a lot of photos. The rules describe that if the main content is photos, the slideshow should be omitted

https://www.noen.at/mistelbach/laarisch-guat-2019-narrenshow-in-mega-laenge-laa-an-der-thaya-fotos-fasching-laarisch-guat-136282400
Accepted by admin
The slideshow must be preserved in this page.
Grigory Korepanov
Could you please explain where I should and shouldn't create a slideshow? How much should a photo/text ratio be?
Accepted by admin
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-2-3-galleries-and-slideshows
Template #50 Issue #2
Mar 2, 2019
Control elements of slideshow not removed
Accepted by admin
Grigory Korepanov
Do I have to support the elements of 2014?
Accepted by admin
Template #54 Issue #1
Mar 4, 2019
"Slideshows must not be used when the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content."
In this case all that's in the article is the slideshow and its description, so it should be rendered as individual images.
Deleted Account
The article have a lead paragraph and some text.
Declined by admin
In this case it's optional as there are some text.
Template #54 Issue #2
Mar 4, 2019
Missing video
Accepted by admin
Template #58 Issue #1
Mar 5, 2019
Page contains unsupported video and should not generate IV
Grigory Korepanov
Open the original page. There is no video there. If the widget doesn't work and the stringline is displayed, I think it's the correct behavior of the topic. Because if the widget works, the page is not generated.
Let's suppose that the widget is placed on another page, but it does not work. Can your topic react to another widget that is not working?
Also, the user will not find any video there after opening the original page
Declined by admin
Template #58 Issue #2
Mar 5, 2019
Static page should be supported
Grigory Korepanov
It is dynamical page
Declined by admin
This looks like a dynamic page.

Note that IVs are cached. So a page like this in IV would always be outdated.
Template #58 Issue #3
Mar 7, 2019
This is actually not a quote.
Grigory Korepanov
The authors of the site clearly wanted to highlight this text
Accepted by admin
"epaperlink" must be removed
Template #62 Issue #1
Mar 9, 2019
It is dynamical page
Accepted by admin
Note that IVs are cached. Since this IV sets a published_date, eventually the cache for this IV will never get updated.

So an IV like this will end up always outdated after a while.
Template #60 Issue #2
Mar 10, 2019
This is a dynamic page.
Accepted by admin
Note that IVs are cached. Since this IV sets a published_date, eventually the cache for this IV will never get updated.

So an IV like this will end up always outdated after a while.
Template #63 Issue #1
Mar 14, 2019
"epaperlink" must be removed
Accepted by admin
Template #64 Issue #1
Mar 14, 2019
Missing parts of article: email address and image <cite>
Accepted by admin
Template #67 Issue #1
Mar 17, 2019
Slider is not formatted, it's an article.
Falko
I don't see what you mean, exactly. This is a slideshow with only a description/caption of it, and nothing else, so it should not be made a <slideshow> but a series of individual images
Declined by admin
Template #68 Issue #1
Mar 17, 2019
Slider is not formatted, it's an article.
Grigory Korepanov
EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used:

When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content.
Declined by admin
Template #67 Issue #2
Mar 17, 2019
Description is missing. First paragraph is a good candidate for this, I guess.
Falko
When the site authors want to set a description, they set the meta tag with name="description", like here: https://www.noen.at/hollabrunn/land-um-hollabrunn-bei-fledermauszaehlung-neue-art-entdeckt-hollabrunn-grossmugl-fransenfledermaus-fledermaus-arno-klien-waldfreunde-139644717
Where they have set the following: <meta name="description" content="Fransenfledermaus &uuml;berwinterte rund um Hollabrunner Wald." />

On this article, the <meta> tag is not present, so no description is set. I don't think it's right to just grab the first paragraph of any given article and use that, as it may not always be representative of the whole article.
Accepted by admin
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#3-2-link-preview
Template #68 Issue #2
Mar 17, 2019
Description is missing. First paragraph is a good candidate for this, I guess.
Accepted by admin
Template #69 Issue #1
Mar 17, 2019
EXCEPTION! Slideshows must not be used:

When the article consists entirely of a slideshow (and its caption/description) and there's no other content.
Deleted Account
You can scroll a bit and you'll see other content.
Accepted by admin
Template #69 Issue #2
Mar 17, 2019
If the links are not generated, the text will remain alone. What will confuse the reader
Deleted Account
Well, are you sure that combine regular header with closest relateds is a safely enough idea? And content blocks in this site contains unconsistent empty paragraphs.
Accepted by admin
Template #70 Issue #1
Apr 1, 2019
Date is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #71 Issue #1
Apr 1, 2019
Date and author are missing
Accepted by admin
Template #74 Issue #1
Apr 1, 2019
Source should be put in <cite>
Accepted by admin
Template #79 Issue #1
Apr 4, 2019
Either yours or Grigoriys template https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/noen.at/template79/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.noen.at%2Faerzte%2Findustrieviertel%2Fwr-neustadt-orthopaedietechnik-helnwein-bandagist-aerzte-2019-90397448 displays incorrect time since Austria has +2 timezone. Your templates can't have 1 hour difference in time.

Probably yours?
Grigory Korepanov
Time zone optional. In some articles the time zone is specified, in some articles it is not
Declined by admin
Template #79 Issue #2
Apr 4, 2019
Text box must be separated from other article text in some way

I suggest using divider
Grigory Korepanov
Separation is optional in this case. In this case, the separator is the header, it fully copes with its task
Declined by admin
Template #79 Issue #3
Apr 4, 2019
Missing link preview description
Accepted by admin
Template #79 Issue #4
Apr 4, 2019
Why not support this article?
Declined by admin
Template #81 Issue #1
Apr 5, 2019
In case Google Maps iframe will be supported in the future, this article has the wrong content order. In the original, maps widget is at the beginning of the page, while in IV it's at the end.
Grigory Korepanov
https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#4-content-to-be-removed
Side bars removed or adjusted and appended to bottom of IV page
http://joxi.ru/4AkqZGYfoV8znm
Declined by admin
Not critical
Template #81 Issue #2
Apr 5, 2019
Gallery control elements not removed
Grigory Korepanov
2014...
Declined by admin
Template #81 Issue #3
Apr 8, 2019
"Only one header may be present for the block of related articles at the END of the page."
Grigory Korepanov
“Inline” blocks
You may leave “inline” related links in the middle the article. If you do, these <related> blocks must not have headers (unless the header contains critical information).

I think: "Wir hatten über den Überfall und seine Klärung berichtet:" it is critical information
Declined by admin
Inline <related> are allowed. And yes, if the inline <related> header has critical information, then that is okay too.
Template #82 Issue #1
Apr 8, 2019
Falko
"You may leave “inline” related links in the middle the article. If you do, these <related> blocks must not have headers (unless the header contains critical information)."
In this case the position of the related articles block is important (since at that part the article is talking about it) so it shouldn't be put at the end and should be made 'inline'. The header contains critical information - specifically, that this is a followup article and that you can read the previous ones below - and thus shouldn't be removed.
Declined by admin
Inline <related> are allowed. And yes, if the inline <related> header has critical information, then that is okay too.