Processed Issues63

This page shows a list of issues for theoryandpractice.ru that were approved or declined by our admins.

Template #1 Issue #1
May 20, 2017
It missed the subtitle and important information about the event: the place, hosts, teachers, etc.
Accepted by admin
Template #1 Issue #7
May 22, 2017
Image captions are missing or misinterpreted as paragraphs
Accepted by admin
Template #5 Issue #1
May 30, 2017
This links are very important for page. It will be very frustrating, if I get this page through IV, but wouldn't be able to register or buy tickets.
Alexey Alekhin
Well, I followed the recommendation to remove all buttons. But probably you are right, I'm not sure.. The "buy ticket" button just reffers to an external website, and is the same as the preserved "more details" link (Подробнее)
Accepted by admin
The article in question becomes meaningless without the link
Template #6 Issue #1
Jun 8, 2017
The image appears right below the title and should be treated as a cover
Declined by admin
The image is not in the source as an explicit cover, it is considered optional to put it as one.
Template #6 Issue #2
Jun 9, 2017
A blockquote is rendered as a usual paragraph
Accepted by admin
Template #12 Issue #1
Jun 11, 2017
These side notes are detached from the context because they appear before the text referring to them (look for the asterisk in the following paragraph)
Yuri
I don't think it's a critical issue
Accepted by admin
While it could be argued that the original website doesn't display those footnotes too well either, Template #13 is clearly an improvement. We may accept a counter-issue if it can demonstrate how this approach could lead to problems.
Template #17 Issue #1
Jun 17, 2017
Missing cover image.
This image is a clear cover in the source article. It is used as cover in article preview:
https://pasteboard.co/e9pLR0uL.png

https://instantview.telegram.org/checklist#6-3-cover-images
“It is advisable to use a cover image when possible:
When the image appears as a cover on the source website.
In all other cases, cover images are optional

We will only accept issues based on absence or presence of a cover image in these cases:
The cover is missing from an article that has a cover on the source website.”
Alexey Alekhin
I would argue that it's not an obligatory cover, it's just an image that follows the title. I this it's optional
Declined by admin
In this case it's tricky, but it's not a cover image.

Covers in our definition are only:

1) If they appear above the title
2) If the title runs accross the image

So this image wouldn't be consiedered.
Template #17 Issue #2
Jun 18, 2017
Excuse me for submitting a fake issue, but as there is no more civilized way to communicate, I just wanted to give another argument against the issue:
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/theoryandpractice.ru/template17/issue1/

Compare this page and another one with exactly the same topic (kind of a sequel-post):
https://theoryandpractice.ru/posts/16077-ne-zabudte-zamyutit-eshche-20-obrazovatelnykh-telegram-kanalov

It has a clear cover-image, which is above the title, the first thing you see in the article. But the page with the submitted issue has it below the title. I believe that such an image, although being appropriate for a cover, doesn't necessarily have to be treated so.
Declined by admin
Check the issue, we already decided :)
Template #17 Issue #3
Jun 18, 2017
This paragraph is ill-formatted
Alexey Alekhin
Correct. But I think it's not a critical issue.
Accepted by admin
Alexey Alekhin
Is this really a critical issue which is enough to reject the only left template? It's just about adding a couple of newlines. Besides, the rest of the issues are just invalid (see my comments on them).
Accepted by admin
Unfortunately, this issue makes the layout look broken and it is totally valid. Since no template could parse this website perfectly, this domain will have no winners in the first contest.
Template #23 Issue #5
Jun 19, 2017
Cover image is missing
Accepted by admin
Image is missing.
Template #23 Issue #6
Jun 19, 2017
Cover caption is missing
Accepted by admin
Here is a better one:

https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/theoryandpractice.ru/template17/?url=https%3A%2F%2Ftheoryandpractice.ru%2Fposts%2F16093-ekspert-po-otkrytym-dannym-ivan-begtin-v-moey-zhizni-osnovnuyu-rol-sygralo-to-chemu-ya-uchilsya-samostoyatelno
Template #23 Issue #8
Jun 19, 2017
The name in the image caption is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #24 Issue #3
Jun 19, 2017
Image caption is missing
Accepted by admin
Template #17 Issue #5
Jun 19, 2017
There are not dividers in the source page.
But this template misses "asterisks" header, which are clearly defined as <h2>***</h2> in source.
Alexey Alekhin
This is clearly a divider and it has to be replaced with <hr>. This is a standard way to separate part of the text with triple asterisk (especially in poems).
Even if you leave it as is, it has to be centered (which doesn't appear so in your template)
Declined by admin
These asterisks are clearly dividers and should be exchanged with the IV dividers. The template creator did everything right.
Template #25 Issue #1
Feb 5, 2019
Some images are missing
Accepted by admin
Template #29 Issue #1
Feb 6, 2019
Kicker explicitly defined on the page but was missed.
Accepted by admin
Template #30 Issue #1
Feb 6, 2019
Navigation links should be removed
Accepted by admin
Those interactive elements do not work with IV.
Template #33 Issue #1
Feb 7, 2019
Kicker present on original page but removed.
Дмитрий
it is not a kicker, it is a category name: https://theoryandpractice.ru/projects/chtenie-na-kanikuly-gendernye-issledovaniya-i-feminizm
Declined by admin
Template #35 Issue #1
Feb 7, 2019
Missing vital info about the event
Accepted by admin
Template #33 Issue #2
Feb 7, 2019
Page is missing important information
Accepted by admin
Template #33 Issue #3
Feb 8, 2019
Should generate an IV page
Accepted by admin
Template #34 Issue #3
Feb 9, 2019
IV not generated for static content
Accepted by admin
This seems to be an issue with the template itself.

Tagir's template shows that this page can be supported.
Template #33 Issue #4
Feb 10, 2019
The author is wrong, he is "Антон Захаров" but not "Теории и практики"
Дмитрий
Anton is not an author of the publication, his lecture was outlined and published by Theory and Practice
Declined by admin
Template #47 Issue #2
Feb 13, 2019
Links to the 'list of events' and the second event are missing.
Accepted by admin
Template #47 Issue #3
Feb 13, 2019
These are nav buttons from the slideshow. I think, they should be removed.
Accepted by admin
Template #47 Issue #4
Feb 13, 2019
IV page not generated for a static page
Declined by admin
Template #47 Issue #5
Feb 13, 2019
Quotes are not formatted properly.
Also, rudimentary images are not removed.
Accepted by admin
Template #48 Issue #1
Feb 13, 2019
Some text blocks are removed.
Tagir
You cannot reliably differentiate between notes and ads.
For example, here there is an ad: https://theoryandpractice.ru/posts/16446-govoryat-kak-loshadi-pochemu-angliyskiy-stal-yazykom-snobov
Accepted by admin
In this case the text is important for the article.
Template #48 Issue #2
Feb 13, 2019
No kicker.
Tagir
That's a kicker, which represents regular section, and should be removed.
Rules:
If the kicker represents a regular section or category into which the article falls, (e.g. ‘CRIME: Seventy suitcases stolen from Heathrow airport’), it should be omitted. We will not accept issues based on missing section/category kickers.
Declined by admin
Template #49 Issue #1
Feb 16, 2019
Category not removed.
According to rules: If the kicker represents a regular section or category into which the article falls, (e.g. ‘CRIME: Seventy suitcases stolen from Heathrow airport’), it should be omitted.
Krond
I'm not sure this is really a category, only a few articles from the site really have this string.
Declined by admin
Template #49 Issue #2
Feb 16, 2019
Links to buy tickets are missing. Dates are missing, and date of the event is important, since it's the main content of such pages.
Similar issue: https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/theoryandpractice.ru/template33/issue2/
Krond
Dates are added and removed dynamically, there would be no dates for older articles.
Accepted by admin
Date is essential information about the event, the page has no sense without it. It's more obvious on pages with ongoing events. See: https://theoryandpractice.ru/courses/35172-internet-veshchey-kurs-mgu If you think the page contains too much dynamic content, it's acceptable to not generate an IV for event pages
Template #50 Issue #1
Feb 16, 2019
Accepted by admin
Template #51 Issue #1
Feb 18, 2019
"Cохранить в календарь" (Save to calendar) should be removed. The text should be properly formatted. The details block should have a header.
Accepted by admin
Tagir
Proper formatting is a bit vague.
However, this text is intended to be a details header.

Save to calendar is to be removed, that's for sure :)
Accepted by admin
Template #53 Issue #2
Feb 21, 2019
poorly formatted. what's the point of <details> if it is empty?
"4 000" loses meaning.
u are not supposed to put all information into <summary>
Tagir
It opens fine. Not in the issue editor though.
Summary is for important information, and so important info is there.
Accepted by admin
Tagir
What exactly is the issue?
This usage of details was never an issue, now suddenly it is?
Accepted by admin
As reporter said "4000" has no sense without rouble sign. Also I wouldn't recommend to use collapsible block in this case, since there is no collapsible block or similar element in the original article. But it's not so critical as missing rouble sign
Template #54 Issue #1
Feb 21, 2019
very questionable formatting
Accepted by admin
Template #55 Issue #2
Feb 22, 2019
these are related articles
Krond
Well, they are grants. In my template grants aren't targets, so I can't make them <related>.
Accepted by admin
It's acceptable to not create related block for unsupported links, but in this case this block should be removed then
Template #56 Issue #1
Feb 23, 2019
Shoul have bigger images
Accepted by admin
Template #65 Issue #1
Feb 23, 2019
<b> is missing. they use span.platform-content-strong instead of <b>. it is important to save this markup. here it highlights interviewer questions over answers
Nikita Tsyhankov
you right
Accepted by admin
Template #67 Issue #1
Feb 26, 2019
Link is duplicated. Image is missing.
shab
this is a related article. it is duplicated as it is in original article. these links are sometimes different
Accepted by admin
The block must not be formatted as related
Template #68 Issue #1
Feb 26, 2019
If the kicker represents a regular section or category into which the article falls, (e.g. ‘CRIME: Seventy suitcases stolen from Heathrow airport’), it should be omitted.
Nikita Tsyhankov
This is important part of header, but this is not a subtitle. (And not a article tag)
Declined by admin
Accepted by admin
Declined by admin
Template #68 Issue #2
Feb 26, 2019
The source has no bold.
h3 formatted as paragraph.
Nikita Tsyhankov
6.1.4 We will not accept issues on templates for presenting the lead paragraph as the subtitle in IV. If the lead paragraph uses a different style, it is recommended to use bold or italic text (we will not accept issues based on the absence of such formatting).
Declined by admin
Template #70 Issue #5
Feb 28, 2019
Photo caption removed.
Accepted by admin
Template #71 Issue #1
Feb 28, 2019
Order of text blocks changed.
Nikita Tsyhankov
https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/theoryandpractice.ru/template12/issue1/
Declined by admin
Template #71 Issue #3
Feb 28, 2019
Caused by slideshow, page contains links to full images that can be used instead. This way page is also rendered correctly.
Nikita Tsyhankov
answered in https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/theoryandpractice.ru/template71/issue2/
Declined by admin
Template #71 Issue #4
Feb 28, 2019
Bad element nesting.
Nikita Tsyhankov
Also old page with broken layout. No problems in new articles
Accepted by admin
Although the article is quite old, it's not a news article. It's a guide-like article that might be shared in Telegram nowadays. Also <img> nested in <a> is a pretty common markup for articles, it would be good to support it.
Template #72 Issue #1
Feb 28, 2019
If the kicker represents a regular section or category into which the article falls, (e.g. ‘CRIME: Seventy suitcases stolen from Heathrow airport’), it should be omitted.
Krond
Your template doesn't handle that one better, you are just removing this text. It doesn't appear just on each other article, also site has no regular sections at all.

Up to admin.
Accepted by admin
It's not a part of the title, it's a category title: https://telegra.ph/file/02f19937217a0a0ab9ba8.png
Template #74 Issue #1
Mar 5, 2019
Link is missing. Also there's no break line in the original article
Accepted by admin
Tagir
Link is present on the image ಠ_ಠ
Accepted by admin
Selected element is a caption. Link is missing in the caption.
Template #79 Issue #5
Mar 8, 2019
Dynamic profile page
Tagir
What exactly is dynamic?
Accepted by admin
This source page looks like it shouldn't generate an IV at all.

Even if an IV was to be generated, the source page looks like it is meant to list the different seminars, but this IV doesn't list them.
Template #84 Issue #1
Mar 20, 2019
It's not a pullquote. Also there are no visible • in the original article.

Also better to set "Theory and Practice" or "Теории и Практики" as a site name.
Accepted by admin
Template #85 Issue #1
Mar 20, 2019
It's not a blockquote. Also there are no visible • in the original article.

Also better to set "Theory and Practice" or "Теории и Практики" as a site name.
Accepted by admin
Template #86 Issue #1
Mar 20, 2019
An important part of the content is missing.

In this order it is difficult to read and understand.
Nikita Tsyhankov
Cannot agree
In first nothing is missing
In second this is kind of tags for event with same information sense
So listing this items looks fine
Declined by admin
Template #86 Issue #2
Mar 20, 2019
The event page has many elements with user interactions
Nikita Tsyhankov
All important informations and links are saved.
Declined by admin
Template #86 Issue #3
Apr 2, 2019
"platform-info-card-name" must be properly formatted

Note that support event pages like this isn't obligatory.
Accepted by admin
Template #88 Issue #1
Apr 2, 2019
"platform-info-card-name" must be properly formatted (perhaps like a header)
Link for "Московская высшая школа социальных и экономических наук (МВШСЭН) — это аккредитованное международное образовательное учреждение. МВШСЭН р…" must be preserved

Note that support event pages like this isn't obligatory.
Accepted by admin
Template #89 Issue #1
Apr 2, 2019
Site name must be "Theory & Practice" or "Теории и практики"
Accepted by admin
Template #95 Issue #1
Apr 4, 2019
IV should be available for "Courses" page of the site
Den S.
It is optional.

See what admins say about such pages:
"It's acceptable to not create related block for unsupported links" - https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/theoryandpractice.ru/template55/issue2/

"Note that support event pages like this isn't obligatory." - https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/theoryandpractice.ru/template86/issue3/
Declined by admin
This page needs ‘Registration’ buttons (which are completely removed in the reporter's template). Without them it is better not to generate IV.
Template #92 Issue #1
Apr 5, 2019
in original page these blocks looks like <aside>, here this block texts are mixed in main article without any style changes.
Accepted by admin
These blocks should be styled/highlighted somehow.
Template #95 Issue #2
Apr 5, 2019
Looks like it should be <figure> with <figcaption> and <cite>
Den S.
It's <div class="opinion">, you wouldn't say such things if you opened like 10 pages and looked through them. This block serves a showcase role, showing an author, a book, a story, an app etc. Certainly not a figure with figcaption and cite, how did you you even choose what is what?
Declined by admin
Template #95 Issue #3
Apr 5, 2019
should be replaced with <hr>
Accepted by admin
Template #98 Issue #1
Apr 5, 2019
IV should be available
Den S.
Duplicate of https://instantview.telegram.org/contest/theoryandpractice.ru/template95/issue1/
Declined by admin
This page needs ‘Registration’ buttons (which are completely removed in the reporter's template). Without them it is better not to generate IV.
Template #92 Issue #2
Apr 5, 2019
Rudimentary elements (also this elements are dynamic and its visibility will expired - so before IV robot make cache - it should be removed)
Accepted by admin
Template #98 Issue #2
Apr 7, 2019
lost description and channel link
Den S.
This is a category and it's description. Rudimentary content.
Declined by admin
Template #98 Issue #3
Apr 7, 2019
Longread article
Den S.
Read Checklist 6.5.1. This is a subdomain which doesn't look like nor has same markup as the main domain. Supporting it is optional.
Declined by admin